Richard III/Princes in the Tower.
#11
There's an interesting novel from back in the "golden age", The Daughter of Time by Josephine Tey. Her hero Inspector Grant is hospitalised and undertakes a belated investigation of the whole Princes in the Tower story. If you can get past her rather stodgy style of writing, it's full of fascinating facts. Leans heavily towards the notion that Henry VII had far more motive than Richard III to do the dirty deed. Shakespeare definitely wrote for the Tudor royal audience. Personal view, the whole damn lot of them (Henry VII through to Elizabeth I) were thoroughly unpleasant bastards. A dark time in our history, somehow elevated in the public conscious to a time of great glory.
Reply
#12
I've read a few Tudor novels, and Elizabeth I is always portrayed as a spoilt brat with a serious anger problem. She didn't let any of the women in her court marry, as far as I can tell, out of spite more than anything.

That being said, when your old man was a bit of a tyrant that basically murdered your mother, sexually abused by your step mother's husband, imprisoned by your half sister - narrowly avoiding execution, you can perhaps be forgiven for being a little unhinged, angry, and paranoid!

(10-03-2026, 11:59 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Almost certainly Richard 3, but Shakespeare did a real number on him fir his Tudor paymasters.

And Hawkins is right that Supergrass album is really good.

And here's a question if Christopher Marliw hadn't been murdered at the age if 29, would he be more reveted than Shakespeare is today.

I accept that Richard III had a clear motive to be rid of his nephews, but if he killed them, why the total silence?
While announcing he had murdered them would obviously have been political suicide, killing them and keeping completely silent makes little sense either. By silence, I don’t mean failing to admit to a murder - I mean never announcing their deaths at all. He could easily have claimed they died of natural causes or illness, yet neither he nor any contemporary sources made any official mention of their passing.

We also have the bizarre situation where the princes' mother, Elizabeth Woodville, willingly allowed her daughters into Richard's care. That seems an extraordinary step for a mother to take if she believed Richard was responsible for the death of her sons, doesn't it? 

Obviously, we will never know the truth for certain, but it makes for a fascinating debate!
Reply
#13
I remember visiting Bosworth where there a fair amount of info from the "White Boar" (?) society who were stand-bearers for Richard III. One of their claims was that it was untrue he was a "crookback" and that was invented by Shakespeare or his sponsors, let's say, but that was disproven when they found his body in the car park in Leicester.
Reply
#14
(10-03-2026, 02:54 PM)Fido Wrote: I remember visiting Bosworth where there a fair amount of info from the "White Boar" (?) society who were stand-bearers for Richard III. One of their claims was that it was untrue he was a "crookback" and that was invented by Shakespeare or his sponsors, let's say, but that was disproven when they found his body in the car park in Leicester.

I think Shakespeare's claim was that he had a hunchback, and a smaller arm (I think?) which would have impacted how he walked. That was proven to be incorrect when his remains were discovered. He did, however, have scoliosis, which it appears he hid from his contemporaries, and his condition was only discovered after his death, where he was allegedly stripped of his clothing and thrown on the back of a horse, which would have exaggerated his condition - hence the origin of the hunchback myth. 

Therefore, the Boar society were actually correct.
Reply
#15
Reading this thread reminded me that Ghosts of Princes in Towers by Rich Kids was a fine track.
It probably adds nothing to the debate but is a timely reminder that there is life outside of Abba.
Reply
#16
There's a been a recent documentary on this, can't remember what it was called or the channel but it suggested there was evidence on the continent that the Princes were banished to mainland Europe. The evidence suggested that at least one of them had tried to come back to England to take the crown with the support of a country like Denmark or the Netherlands. They're got battered in some sort of olden times Royal rumble towards the east.

Now if i could remember the name of the documentary or any of the specifics this post might be slightly more helpful but perhaps it can be googled. Anyhow, it was interesting in that it's entirely possible that the history we know was written that way by interested parties i.e. a potential Donald Trump of medieval times.

Glad to have added limited value here chaps.
Reply
#17
There's a poster on this dump who has PhD in History and  knows about this shit. Come on CWB where am ya
Reply
#18
Lol - 500 year old conspiracy theories. Its what I'm here for.
Reply
#19
Same thing has happened to Megan's kids tbf.
Reply
#20
(10-03-2026, 08:29 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote: Reading this thread reminded me that Ghosts of Princes in Towers by Rich Kids was a fine track.
It probably adds nothing to the debate but is a timely reminder that there is life outside of Abba.

Saw the Rich Kids at JBs. Proper tight band, very good. I can't help with the whereabouts of the Princes in the tower though, where were they last seen?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: