The death row case of Christa Pike
#31
Kill the very worse criminals? Fuck no.

Kill the little old man who thinks he's a burden on his family? G'wed then.

Love this place  Big Grin

With regards to this US case, two points, the accomplice was a minor hence no death penalty. The State execution protocol has a failsafe if the first lethal injection doesn't work, of a 2nd injection. No one bothered to add a failsafe if the 2nd also doesn't work, so legally they had to stop. Likely she'll have a serious brain injury I'd imagine.
Reply
#32
My take is simple. Killing people is wrong.
End of.
Reply
#33
(10-01-2026, 02:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Kill the very worse criminals? Fuck no.

Kill the little old man who thinks he's a burden on his family? G'wed then.

Love this place  Big Grin

With regards to this US case, two points, the accomplice was a minor hence no death penalty. The State execution protocol has a failsafe if the first lethal injection doesn't work, of a 2nd injection. No one bothered to add a failsafe if the 2nd also doesn't work, so legally they had to stop. Likely she'll have a serious brain injury I'd imagine.

She’ll fit in well on the Politics Board
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#34
(10-01-2026, 01:10 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It'll all be fine when Judge and Jury are replaced with AI, there'll be no risk of injustice then.

That or VAR
Reply
#35
(10-01-2026, 02:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Kill the very worse criminals? Fuck no.

Kill the little old man who thinks he's a burden on his family? G'wed then.

Love this place  Big Grin

With regards to this US case, two points, the accomplice was a minor hence no death penalty. The State execution protocol has a failsafe if the first lethal injection doesn't work, of a 2nd injection. No one bothered to add a failsafe if the 2nd also doesn't work, so legally they had to stop. Likely she'll have a serious brain injury I'd imagine.

As per Ted Cadsy "oversimplifying is the first grave mistake we make when confronted by complexity; overconfidence is the second. And there is a third: based on our overconfidence in our oversimplified conclusions, we overreact".
Reply
#36
When does the Netflix doc come out?
In the form of his life.
Reply
#37
(10-01-2026, 03:57 PM)Arti Wrote: My take is simple.  Killing people is wrong.
End of.
You a Christian?

I agree btw.

(10-01-2026, 02:38 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 02:33 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: This is why it can't be judged purely on the seriousness of the crime, it has to be judged on the level of ambiguity.
If there is absolutely no doubt whatsoever, then the miscarriage of justice argument is moot and it becomes a purely moral dilemma and I would be more inclined to consider it..
If, however, there is even the slightest doubt, it can simply never be an option.

I think this would always be the case though. The criminal standard for guilty is "beyond reasonable doubt". So there can still be some doubt for them to be found guilty.

Especially these days when video evidence can be doctored more easily than ever, and witness testimony is as always, flawed, you just won't be 100% certain almost ever.

None of us will remember the Derek Bentley case in 1953.
Simply put, a 19 years old was hung for being an accomplice to a murder of a policeman. He had the mental age of an 11 year old. Because he was an "adult" he was hung. The shooter was 16, so got ten years.The film "Let Him Have It" explored the case.
Bentley got a royal pardon in the 90s. The case was quashed.
I'm sure he's very relieved.
We must never have a death penalty. It's barbaric. It doesn't work in stopping crime - look at the USA.
Reply
#38
It doesn't even actually as a deterrent in any way either. In fact data suggests the exact opposite, crime is worse in areas with the death penalty.

I'm all for a more barbaric prison structure for the worst cases, people for whom there is no rehabilitation into society. It must never be an option to execute them.
Reply
#39
(10-02-2026, 09:27 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It doesn't even actually as a deterrent in any way either. In fact data suggests the exact opposite, crime is worse in areas with the death penalty.

I'm all for a more barbaric prison structure for the worst cases, people for whom there is no rehabilitation into society. It must never be an option to execute them.

As I have said above.

(10-01-2026, 03:57 PM)Arti Wrote: My take is simple.  Killing people is wrong.
End of.

And this x1000. 

My suggestion to those in favour of the death penalty is simple: try living in a country which uses it. You’ll find yourself back home pretty soon is my guess. 

A barbaric society does not equate to a civilised one. As said above (and - again - with no sympathy for these fuckers nor denial that some just need keeping away from society) - an eye for an eye and we all end up blind.
Reply
#40
I will not change what I think.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)