Genuine question re. In game changes.
#1
At what point you change things or stick with them, must be a damn hard choice. 

As a fan, it was clear after 10 mins today was a shit show, but I also appreciate the need for calm heads and to stick with it, to an extent.

I'm not sure the purpose of this post, other than to acknowledge changing things up when they're not working isn't perhaps as easy as it seems. It's a difficult balance, isn't it. 

I don't think I've got anything wrong today, at all. It's just shit. I could probably go about and write things better, but oh well. 

Anyway, I've had a few pints with a Wolves mate after the game in the Great Western, which was nice. It's always nice to chat with the opposition post game and see what they make of it, and that gets lost in all the policing. 

BTW, he was expecting more from us, and was waiting for us to equalise. Funny how we view the game, ain't it. 

Sorry, that tuned into a ramble, after a genuine question. Fuck it. 

Have a good evening all, it you want to have a go, then do. I'm all in for it.
Reply
#2
The players could have had no complaints with 2 or 3 half time changes given the work O'Leary was exposed to.
Reply
#3
(09-20-2026, 04:19 PM)Jacko Wrote: The players could have had no complaints with 2 or 3 half time changes given the work O'Leary was exposed to.

Just the two or three!! 

Genuine question though - would you have the balls to change things? 

I can imagine a situation where you're working on something in training, and you believe in it so much, it takes some mental strength to admit that's gone tits up within minutes and change it, right? 

Hand on heart, I think I'd struggle with the internal battle of sticking with what I believe in, and then accepting it needs changing. I think that's massive battle with management. there's a line where you need to stick with something, but then change it, isn't there?

Maybe? I don't know. I'm off for a beer.
Reply
#4
Well there were 3 I wouldn't have started with and they were all shit, so yes, I think I would have.
Reply
#5
Managers have spent all week prepping a game plan and will have worked probably from Thursday or Friday with the starting XI on scenarios and in game patterns. The days of players getting to the dressing room and seeing their name on the team sheet are long gone so it’s only natural that managers will stick with that selection and plan for as long as possible.

On top of this, the prep all week will have been around 2-3 scenarios we’d anticipate from Wolves, and it’ll nominally take 10-15 mins for us to see what they are going to do, so calls for changes after 15mins are usually stupid and would be reckless unless you suddenly find yourself 2-down.

I agree today we were well out of it first half, but we had gone in level, and I’m sure with some HT adjustments Mozza and the coaches wanted to see the impact those changes would have, only for us to concede that stupid error.

I was disappointed we didn’t make changes at HT, but we did improve. Partly due to being behind and Wolves letting up a little, and partly later due to the subs.

I guess what I’m saying is I doubt we will ever see tactical, non enforced changes in a first half as there is too much game week prep that goes into that, and certainly not when we’re level away from home as still facing/with 11 men.

For me HT is the first opportunity to change something, as you have time with players to explain what the new plan is. Otherwise you need to give it 5-10 mins and see if it’s working.

Today we were too late refreshing the middle, but had Phillips and Molumby not had contrived to lose the match, we may well have escaped with a point.
Reply
#6
(09-20-2026, 04:12 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: At what point you change things or stick with them, must be a damn hard choice. 

As a fan, it was clear after 10 mins today was a shit show, but I also appreciate the need for calm heads and to stick with it, to an extent.

I'm not sure the purpose of this post, other than to acknowledge changing things up when they're not working isn't perhaps as easy as it seems. It's a difficult balance, isn't it. 

I don't think I've got anything wrong today, at all. It's just shit. I could probably go about and write things better, but oh well. 

Anyway, I've had a few pints with a Wolves mate after the game in the Great Western, which was nice. It's always nice to chat with the opposition post game and see what they make of it, and that gets lost in all the policing. 

BTW, he was expecting more from us, and was waiting for us to equalise. Funny how we view the game, ain't it. 

Sorry, that tuned into a ramble, after a genuine question. Fuck it. 

Have a good evening all, it you want to have a go, then do. I'm all in for it.

Our problem is if changes were made it would be a like for like change so we really do not have that option for 1st half changes. That being said we could alter the shape etc if the players know the different
Reply
#7
(09-20-2026, 04:26 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Managers have spent all week prepping a game plan and will have worked probably from Thursday or Friday with the starting XI on scenarios and in game patterns. The days of players getting to the dressing room and seeing their name on the team sheet are long gone so it’s only natural that managers will stick with that selection and plan for as long as possible.

On top of this, the prep all week will have been around 2-3 scenarios we’d anticipate from Wolves, and it’ll nominally take 10-15 mins for us to see what they are going to do, so calls for changes after 15mins are usually stupid and would be reckless unless you suddenly find yourself 2-down.

I agree today we were well out of it first half, but we had gone in level, and I’m sure with some HT adjustments Mozza and the coaches wanted to see the impact those changes would have, only for us to concede that stupid error.

I was disappointed we didn’t make changes at HT, but we did improve. Partly due to being behind and Wolves letting up a little, and partly later due to the subs.

I guess what I’m saying is I doubt we will ever see tactical, non enforced changes in a first half as there is too much game week prep that goes into that, and certainly not when we’re level away from home as still facing/with 11 men.

For me HT is the first opportunity to change something, as you have time with players to explain what the new plan is. Otherwise you need to give it 5-10 mins and see if it’s working.

Today we were too late refreshing the middle, but had Phillips and Molumby not had contrived to lose the match, we may well have escaped with a point.

Excellent post. 

But that's my point - it's gonna take a strong manager to rip it all up after 10 mins. 

In fact, it's stupid, isn't it? 

Imagine today if Morrison had made a sub after, say, 30 mins, and they scored soon after? 

Managers can't win. It's a thankless task at times, in terms of first half. Second half there's clearly time when we're crying out for a change.
Reply
#8
Changes doesn't have to be subs. There's a time to play out from the keeper and there's a time to mix it up. Today the dings were quicker, sharper, stronger and the crowd fed off them pressing our defenders. Which after all, led to the goal. It also made our players nervous. Another change needed was to get some width. 1st 4t we were so narrow compared to the room Mane had out wide in our half.
Having got to ht unscathed maybe that was the time for a change? Certainly cut out some of the kamikaze playing out - well that didn't happen - and play on where they are weakest, in there own box. That didn't happen either.
A bad day at the office that could have been much worse.
Reply
#9
My sort of general rule in thinking is this.

No tactical subs first half unless clearly obviously necessary.
If first half didn't go well, one, two at a push half time subs.
Always make a change around 60 minutes, and this is a sub that could have been planned midweek.
From 60 minutes, sub if any player is exhausted or a sub has something to offer the team is missing.

How I would manage subs if I was a manager.

Today fwiw, at half time Molumby would have come off, he wasn't offering us anything of value. Collyer would have been on.
Reply
#10
(09-20-2026, 05:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: My sort of general rule in thinking is this.

No tactical subs first half unless clearly obviously necessary.
If first half didn't go well, one, two at a push half time subs.
Always make a change around 60 minutes, and this is a sub that could have been planned midweek.
From 60 minutes, sub if any player is exhausted or a sub has something to offer the team is missing.

How I would manage subs if I was a manager.

Today fwiw, at half time Molumby would have come off, he wasn't offering us anything of value. Collyer would have been on.

But how and when would you deviate? How would you decide that? 

Not being a dick, just think it's interesting to see things from outside my POV. 

It's so easy for me to say Heggebø is having a shit game, change him. But it's not that easy, is it?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: