Associate Membership of the EU
#21
The massive assumption you have there Jacko is that everyone who voted leave actually meant it and didn't treat it as a protest vote. The problem from the very start was this was purely an exercise to keep the Tory party together, experts were sidelined and loons like that fat bloke who cosplayed army at the weekend took his chance at anyone listening to him.

Your approach would ultimately mean that a number as low as 10% of the population would decide on what everyone in the country had to endure, and there is a chance that people that used the vote as a protest didn't bother with the detail and the loons, who would be more engaged, would get to choose. A disaster worse than we had I reckon.
Reply
#22
(09-17-2026, 01:14 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The massive assumption you have there Jacko is that everyone who voted leave actually meant it and didn't treat it as a protest vote. The problem from the very start was this was purely an exercise to keep the Tory party together, experts were sidelined and loons like that fat bloke who cosplayed army at the weekend took his chance at anyone listening to him.

Your approach would ultimately mean that a number as low as 10% of the population would decide on what everyone in the country had to endure, and there is a chance that people that used the vote as a protest didn't bother with the detail and the loons, who would be more engaged, would get to choose. A disaster worse than we had I reckon.

You're still allowed to vote in the 2nd Ref if you voted remain. This approach would have guaranteed the softest of soft Brexits but the Remainers wouldn't even consider it without a reversal of the first referendum option on the ballot.
Reply
#23
Yeah that's right - Remainers were the problem. Arf again

Canada aligning with the EU to protect their sovereignty aa well btw. We must look like a fucking basket case to the rest of the world.
Reply
#24
(09-17-2026, 02:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Yeah that's right - Remainers were the problem. Arf again

Canada aligning with the EU to protect their sovereignty aa well btw. We must look like a fucking basket case to the rest of the world.
To be fair you still don't accept the result of the referendum hence your initial response to my post. Protest vote, my eye. So yeah, there's plenty of blame to go round.
Reply
#25
Every vote since 2008 has been a protest vote on way or another.
Reply
#26
(09-17-2026, 02:23 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(09-17-2026, 02:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Yeah that's right - Remainers were the problem. Arf again

Canada aligning with the EU to protect their sovereignty aa well btw. We must look like a fucking basket case to the rest of the world.
To be fair you still don't accept the result of the referendum hence your initial response to my post. Protest vote, my eye. So yeah, there's plenty of blame to go round.

Why should Remainers accept the result? It was a fucking stupid decision with the campaign led by some of the dodgiest, most dishonest politicians in living memory, served by useful idiots on the doorstep. 

Farage and co,  never accepted being in the EU and at some point in the next few decades we will end up back in the EU or ever closer ties. Just waiting for the fantasists in the older generations to disappear. 

Somewhere along the line Proth has forgotten his support for the Brexit Beliends sorry Spartans (or whatever they called themselves) like Steve Baker and the Haunted Pencil who wouldn’t compromise their red lines. There was never any chance of a good deal, every deal was going to be worse than what we already had. 

It’s absolute oss shit to pretend otherwise.
Reply
#27
(09-17-2026, 02:23 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(09-17-2026, 02:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Yeah that's right - Remainers were the problem. Arf again

Canada aligning with the EU to protect their sovereignty aa well btw. We must look like a fucking basket case to the rest of the world.
To be fair you still don't accept the result of the referendum hence your initial response to my post. Protest vote, my eye. So yeah, there's plenty of blame to go round.

I accept the result of the referendum in the same way that I would accept if Reform got voted in. That doesn't mean that the people that voted know what they were going to get. I'm at the point now where i'm not surprised by anything politically any more and if it takes a few doses of FAFO then so be it. The fact that Farage has not been found out yet shows how fucked things are whereby you would have expected the snake oil salesmen to have been called out in normal times.
Reply
#28
It's pointless talking about re joining EU, it can't happen in the foreseeable future for two reasons -

The EU wouldn't want to enter complicated negotiations about the UK re joining without some assurance that we were serious about it and wouldn't want in a very short order to leave again. We couldn't in all honesty provide that assurance, given the volatility of our current politics.

And why would we want to rejoin an organisation that might be in existential crisis in a handful of years if the AFD win the German elections in 2027 and Le Pen wins the French presidency in the same year.
Reply
#29
(09-17-2026, 03:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-17-2026, 02:23 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(09-17-2026, 02:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Yeah that's right - Remainers were the problem. Arf again

Canada aligning with the EU to protect their sovereignty aa well btw. We must look like a fucking basket case to the rest of the world.
To be fair you still don't accept the result of the referendum hence your initial response to my post. Protest vote, my eye. So yeah, there's plenty of blame to go round.

Why should Remainers accept the result? It was a fucking stupid decision with the campaign led by soe of the dodgiest, most dishonest politicians in living memory, served by useful idiots on the doorstep. 

Farage and co,  never accepted being in the EU and at some point in the next few decades we will end up back in the EU or ever closer ties. Just waiting for the fantasists in the older generations to disappear. 

Somewhere along the line Proth has forgotten his support for the Brexit Beliends sorry Spartans (or whatever they called themselves) like Steve Baker and the Haunted Pencil who wouldn’t compromise their red lines. There was never any chance of a good deal, every deal was going to be worse than what we already had. 

It’s absolute oss shit to pretend otherwise.

You either believe in democracy or you don't, it's no different to Trump saying the Dems stole 2020.

The rest is just a diatribe and has nowt to do with anything else I've posted.

But, an opportunity to have a pop at Proth can't be missed I suppose?
Reply
#30
(09-17-2026, 03:49 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-17-2026, 02:23 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(09-17-2026, 02:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Yeah that's right - Remainers were the problem. Arf again

Canada aligning with the EU to protect their sovereignty aa well btw. We must look like a fucking basket case to the rest of the world.
To be fair you still don't accept the result of the referendum hence your initial response to my post. Protest vote, my eye. So yeah, there's plenty of blame to go round.

I accept the result of the referendum in the same way that I would accept if Reform got voted in. That doesn't mean that the people that voted know what they were going to get. I'm at the point now where i'm not surprised by anything politically any more and if it takes a few doses of FAFO then so be it. The fact that Farage has not been found out yet shows how fucked things are whereby you would have expected the snake oil salesmen to have been called out in normal times.

The difference is, that the Leave vote was the greatest vote for anything in our history. How many voted for the current government? I accept the result. I’m not accusing anyone of being stupid. The last PM dropped every single position he held when elected as Labour leader, so if you want to talk about snake oil salesmen….
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: