Associate Membership of the EU
#1
Perhaps there was another way had the EU been willing.

Perhaps global conflict, a bond market crisis and the collapse of German industry was just a little too late for the UK to leverage its position. Hopefully St Carney can show that there is indeed a different way.
Reply
#2
Hopefully everyone has grown up a little given more recent events and after both sides seemed so keen to cut off their noses to spite their faces.
Reply
#3
Canada and Australia are ineligible to join the EU by virtue of not being geographically within Europe, the UK is not. Carney has signalled that Canada would be open to preferential access to EU member states on labour movement, that was a red line for us that blocked off the single market. Canada and Australia have more leverage for concessions as they're less reliant on access to the European markets for goods and services and have vast natural resources to leverage for concessions.

How are these situations remotely comparable? The closest comparison was the EU's offer to associate membership to Ukraine but that was both to act as a stepping stone to EU membership and an olive branch to the likes of Victor Orban, which again doesn't apply to the UK.
Reply
#4
I'm not suggesting it's comparable, I'm suggesting there was not just one single way of skinning a cat. The EU damaged itself as well as the UK in its approach to the Brexit negotiations. It's clear from the overtures being made to Canada that there is far more flexibility when the mood takes them. That you're completely captured by their myopia is your problem.

Like every negotiation there could have been a win-win. The EU decided to punish the UK, which for me remains a source of deep regret - what with us having rescued them from the last attempt at a continental superstate.

I don't wish to go over old ground, and I shan't after this post. However the opening up of new and exciting relationships with the EU illustrates there was always more than one way to leave it (or to become semi-detached) - and I'm afraid you'll never change my mind on that matter.
Reply
#5
The stupid "red lines" that blocked a more optimum deal from being agreed with the EU were unilaterally imposed by the UK, the UK has unilaterally suspended the reset talks because Starmer resigned..

Carney has signalled moving Canada towards the four freedoms.

That is the difference. Do you honestly think that the EU wouldn't have accepted an EEA-style arrangement with the UK if not for the stupid red lines?
Reply
#6
(09-16-2026, 11:08 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm not suggesting it's comparable, I'm suggesting there was not just one single way of skinning a cat. The EU damaged itself as well as the UK in its approach to the Brexit negotiations. It's clear from the overtures being made to Canada that there is far more flexibility when the mood takes them. That you're completely captured by their myopia is your problem.

Like every negotiation there could have been a win-win. The EU decided to punish the UK, which for me remains a source of deep regret - what with us having rescued them from the last attempt at a continental superstate.

I don't wish to go over old ground, and I shan't after this post. However the opening up of new and exciting relationships with the EU illustrates there was always more than one way to leave it (or to become semi-detached) - and I'm afraid you'll never change my mind on that matter.

Or any matter.
Reply
#7
(09-16-2026, 11:42 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The stupid "red lines" that blocked a more optimum deal from being agreed with the EU were unilaterally imposed by the UK, the UK has unilaterally suspended the reset talks because Starmer resigned..?

Quite. So we're agreed that there was actually more than one way of leaving the EU. And all this bullshit accountability that I and the other 52% are supposed to carry is due to political failure and not that of the electorate.

Thank you.
Reply
#8
(09-16-2026, 11:08 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm not suggesting it's comparable, I'm suggesting there was not just one single way of skinning a cat. The EU damaged itself as well as the UK in its approach to the Brexit negotiations. It's clear from the overtures being made to Canada that there is far more flexibility when the mood takes them. That you're completely captured by their myopia is your problem.

Like every negotiation there could have been a win-win. The EU decided to punish the UK, which for me remains a source of deep regret - what with us having rescued them from the last attempt at a continental superstate.

I don't wish to go over old ground, and I shan't after this post. However the opening up of new and exciting relationships with the EU illustrates there was always more than one way to leave it (or to become semi-detached) - and I'm afraid you'll never change my mind on that matter.

We shouldn't argue that there wasn't more than one way to leave. The point made, right, on here is that if you'd have put the following options on the ballot.

Remain
Associate Membership
'Leave means leave

Remain would have won by miles. The Leave campaign couldn't even agree what leave should look like and still can't, so to pretend it was the right decision let down afterwards is also disingenuous.
Reply
#9
I don't agree. The emergence of a new model supports my contention not yours. The situation we're in is a product of bloody mindedness on the part of both parties. As someone who has negotiated contracts every day for the thick end of 30 years I have resorted to litigation only 3 times.
Reply
#10
(09-17-2026, 07:04 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-16-2026, 11:42 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The stupid "red lines" that blocked a more optimum deal from being agreed with the EU were unilaterally imposed by the UK, the UK has unilaterally suspended the reset talks because Starmer resigned..?

Quite. So we're agreed that there was actually more than one way of leaving the EU. And all this bullshit accountability that I and the other 52% are supposed to carry is due to political failure and not that of the electorate.

Thank you.

There were multiple avenues of how we could have left, there is only one Brexit which is the one we've ended up with.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: