Posts: 3,652
Threads: 119
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
He's an amazing shot player no doubt - but until he arrests the really silly dismissals he's not a great. Every batsman will have the odd head wobble - it comes with the job - but Brook is just as likely to smash 30 from the over as he is to run him self out or give up his wicket as if he was a 90 year old playing village cricket. He's product of the modern game I suppose but in cricket we need to see some control or else it's just baseball.
Posts: 410
Threads: 21
Joined: Feb 2026
(09-16-2026, 08:50 AM)wba13 Wrote: (09-16-2026, 08:38 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Root is a better batsman than Brook. You can throw around all the current rankings you want, I'm not having it! 
That's not me criticising Brook. He's a fantastic, if not infuriating at times (as AB said, concentration is often lacking), batsman. He gives his wicket away cheaper than I'd like and sometimes struggles to play the match situation, but he's so good, and I'm sure those criticisms will be corrected with experience and maturity.
Root has been consistently up there with the best in the world for almost 15 years - across all 3 formats, too. He's by far the best current English batsman, arguably best of all time for England, and won't be far off the conversation for best off all time behind Don Bradman, by the time he's done.
Again, this isn't an opinion intended to downplay Brooks talent, that's there for all to see. But to place him above Joe Root is just wrong.
Agree Root is the best batsman England have ever had,but at present Brooke is the best Test batsman in the world, the rankings don’t lie.I’m not placing him above Root in the all time rankings, as I said initially at present Brooke is the best batsman in the world. Nothing you say or do will alter those rankings.im not talking Opinions what I’ve said is fact.
Brook is No 1. Brooke ain’t even on the list. Just saying loike
Posts: 305
Threads: 6
Joined: Jan 2026
Reputation:
1
09-16-2026, 09:28 AM
(This post was last modified: 09-16-2026, 09:28 AM by ericlegrisly too.)
(09-16-2026, 08:56 AM)MGalea Wrote: He's an amazing shot player no doubt - but until he arrests the really silly dismissals he's not a great. Every batsman will have the odd head wobble - it comes with the job - but Brook is just as likely to smash 30 from the over as he is to run him self out or give up his wicket as if he was a 90 year old playing village cricket. He's product of the modern game I suppose but in cricket we need to see some control or else it's just baseball.
My thoughts exactly.
He is so close to being an absolute great, but his consistent lunacy leaves him short of that.
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(09-16-2026, 09:02 AM)RamsAy it Wrote: (09-16-2026, 08:50 AM)wba13 Wrote: (09-16-2026, 08:38 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Root is a better batsman than Brook. You can throw around all the current rankings you want, I'm not having it! 
That's not me criticising Brook. He's a fantastic, if not infuriating at times (as AB said, concentration is often lacking), batsman. He gives his wicket away cheaper than I'd like and sometimes struggles to play the match situation, but he's so good, and I'm sure those criticisms will be corrected with experience and maturity.
Root has been consistently up there with the best in the world for almost 15 years - across all 3 formats, too. He's by far the best current English batsman, arguably best of all time for England, and won't be far off the conversation for best off all time behind Don Bradman, by the time he's done.
Again, this isn't an opinion intended to downplay Brooks talent, that's there for all to see. But to place him above Joe Root is just wrong.
Agree Root is the best batsman England have ever had,but at present Brooke is the best Test batsman in the world, the rankings don’t lie.I’m not placing him above Root in the all time rankings, as I said initially at present Brooke is the best batsman in the world. Nothing you say or do will alter those rankings.im not talking Opinions what I’ve said is fact.
Brook is No 1. Brooke ain’t even on the list. Just saying loike 
Edited for you piss taker.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
(09-16-2026, 08:50 AM)wba13 Wrote: (09-16-2026, 08:38 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Root is a better batsman than Brook. You can throw around all the current rankings you want, I'm not having it! 
That's not me criticising Brook. He's a fantastic, if not infuriating at times (as AB said, concentration is often lacking), batsman. He gives his wicket away cheaper than I'd like and sometimes struggles to play the match situation, but he's so good, and I'm sure those criticisms will be corrected with experience and maturity.
Root has been consistently up there with the best in the world for almost 15 years - across all 3 formats, too. He's by far the best current English batsman, arguably best of all time for England, and won't be far off the conversation for best off all time behind Don Bradman, by the time he's done.
Again, this isn't an opinion intended to downplay Brooks talent, that's there for all to see. But to place him above Joe Root is just wrong.
Agree Root is the best batsman England have ever had,but at present Brook is the best Test batsman in the world, the rankings don’t lie.I’m not placing him above Root in the all time rankings, as I said initially at present Brook is the best batsman in the world. Nothing you say or do will alter those rankings.im not talking Opinions what I’ve said is fact.
The rankings don't lie, correct, and Hull City are in a Champions League place in the Prem, also correct. Joe Root is the best batsman in the world though. When Brook addresses his silly dismissals he might have a chance to be best himself.
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(09-16-2026, 12:18 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: (09-16-2026, 08:50 AM)wba13 Wrote: (09-16-2026, 08:38 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Root is a better batsman than Brook. You can throw around all the current rankings you want, I'm not having it! 
That's not me criticising Brook. He's a fantastic, if not infuriating at times (as AB said, concentration is often lacking), batsman. He gives his wicket away cheaper than I'd like and sometimes struggles to play the match situation, but he's so good, and I'm sure those criticisms will be corrected with experience and maturity.
Root has been consistently up there with the best in the world for almost 15 years - across all 3 formats, too. He's by far the best current English batsman, arguably best of all time for England, and won't be far off the conversation for best off all time behind Don Bradman, by the time he's done.
Again, this isn't an opinion intended to downplay Brooks talent, that's there for all to see. But to place him above Joe Root is just wrong.
Agree Root is the best batsman England have ever had,but at present Brook is the best Test batsman in the world, the rankings don’t lie.I’m not placing him above Root in the all time rankings, as I said initially at present Brook is the best batsman in the world. Nothing you say or do will alter those rankings.im not talking Opinions what I’ve said is fact.
The rankings don't lie, correct, and Hull City are in a Champions League place in the Prem, also correct. Joe Root is the best batsman in the world though. When Brook addresses his silly dismissals he might have a chance to be best himself. Even with his saft dismissals he’s no1 in the world Fact.
Posts: 341
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
Root is a better test batsman and Brook is a better one day batsman.
It depends entirely on the format.
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(09-18-2026, 09:57 AM)Moore Than Wrote: Root is a better test batsman and Brook is a better one day batsman.
It depends entirely on the format.
I don’t disagree with you, but in the formats that both Brook and Root play for England in. Brook is top test batsman and Root is the better 50 over player.
That’s according to the ICC world rankings.
Posts: 656
Threads: 43
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
3
How can Brook be a generational talent how many ODI & T20 WCs has he won with England!!!???…His IPL form very average & he has not been in an IPL winning team!!….
He’s been great against a very very average SL team playing on cold autumn evenings in England!!..Marvellous.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
09-18-2026, 01:52 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-18-2026, 01:54 PM by AnelkasBeard.)
(09-18-2026, 01:09 PM)pindgill Wrote: How can Brook be a generational talent how many ODI & T20 WCs has he won with England!!!???…His IPL form very average & he has not been in an IPL winning team!!….
He’s been great against a very very average SL team playing on cold autumn evenings in England!!..Marvellous.
Firstly, he was part of the team that won in 2022. Only one less than Virat
Secondly, what a bizarre barometer of success. Would you say AB de Villiers wasn't a generational talent? No WC's to his name.
|