Harry Brook
#1
Gets a lot of flak the lad, but he's a generational talent.

114 not out off 49 balls in the T20I.
Reply
#2
(09-15-2026, 07:49 PM)Jacko Wrote: Gets a lot of flak the lad, but he's a generational talent.

114 not out off 49 balls in the T20I.

The best batsman in the world, wonderful talent.
Reply
#3
(09-15-2026, 09:39 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(09-15-2026, 07:49 PM)Jacko Wrote: Gets a lot of flak the lad, but he's a generational talent.

114 not out off 49 balls in the T20I.

The best batsman in the world, wonderful talent.

Edged ahead of Joe Root on averages..... but not longevity.
Reply
#4
Lad has to really prove and establish himself against the very best.His record in the IPL very average born out by his auction price.
However great knock against a very poor inexperienced bowling attack.
Reply
#5
(09-15-2026, 09:39 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(09-15-2026, 07:49 PM)Jacko Wrote: Gets a lot of flak the lad, but he's a generational talent.

114 not out off 49 balls in the T20I.

The best batsman in the world, wonderful talent.

There's no questioning his talent. But he's not even England's best batsman, let alone the best in the world!
Reply
#6
(09-16-2026, 05:44 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-15-2026, 09:39 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(09-15-2026, 07:49 PM)Jacko Wrote: Gets a lot of flak the lad, but he's a generational talent.

114 not out off 49 balls in the T20I.

The best batsman in the world, wonderful talent.

There's no questioning his talent. But he's not even England's best batsman, let alone the best in the world!

Most naturally talented current batsman is what I'd say. And he produces pretty damn consistently. His average in Tests is still 53, his T20 output is pretty much always very good. His ODI batting could probably use some work but otherwise it's just a concentration thing.
Reply
#7
Just a little something for those who say he is not the best batsman in the world at present.
As of the 15th of September 2026 the ICC official world rankings.
1 Brooke England
2 Smith. Aussie
3 Root. England
4 Head Aussie.
I rest my case with you disbelievers. It’s not about what or who we want to be number 1 it’s FACT.
Don’t care about the other formats this is proper Cricket how I was bought up.
Reply
#8
Root is a better batsman than Brook. You can throw around all the current rankings you want, I'm not having it! Big Grin

That's not me criticising Brook. He's a fantastic, if not infuriating at times (as AB said, concentration is often lacking), batsman. He gives his wicket away cheaper than I'd like and sometimes struggles to play the match situation, but he's so good, and I'm sure those criticisms will be corrected with experience and maturity.

Root has been consistently up there with the best in the world for almost 15 years - across all 3 formats, too. He's by far the best current English batsman, arguably best of all time for England, and won't be far off the conversation for best off all time behind Don Bradman, by the time he's done.

Again, this isn't an opinion intended to downplay Brooks talent, that's there for all to see. But to place him above Joe Root is just wrong.
Reply
#9
(09-16-2026, 08:38 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Root is a better batsman than Brook. You can throw around all the current rankings you want, I'm not having it! Big Grin

That's not me criticising Brook. He's a fantastic, if not infuriating at times (as AB said, concentration is often lacking), batsman. He gives his wicket away cheaper than I'd like and sometimes struggles to play the match situation, but he's so good, and I'm sure those criticisms will be corrected with experience and maturity.

Root has been consistently up there with the best in the world for almost 15 years - across all 3 formats, too. He's by far the best current English batsman, arguably best of all time for England, and won't be far off the conversation for best off all time behind Don Bradman, by the time he's done.

Again, this isn't an opinion intended to downplay Brooks talent, that's there for all to see. But to place him above Joe Root is just wrong.

Agree Root is the best batsman England have ever had,but at present Brook is the best Test batsman in the world, the rankings don’t lie.I’m not placing him above Root in the all time rankings, as I said initially at present Brook is the best batsman in the world. Nothing you say or do will alter those rankings.im not talking Opinions what I’ve said is fact.
Reply
#10
Just to be clear, I'm of the opinion Root is still a better batsman than Brook!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: