Taxing Times for Labour
#51
(09-10-2026, 12:44 PM)Øssian Wrote: So, if I'm interpreting these exchanges correctly, there's an argument to be had that fiscal drag is actually a good thing as it progressively pulls more low-end earners into paying tax to relieve some of the disproportionate burden on high-earners?

No, because Fiscal drag impacts on high earners as well. But taxes on low and middle earners in the UK are low compared to many OECD countries.
Reply
#52
(09-11-2026, 05:51 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(09-10-2026, 12:44 PM)Øssian Wrote: So, if I'm interpreting these exchanges correctly, there's an argument to be had that fiscal drag is actually a good thing as it progressively pulls more low-end earners into paying tax to relieve some of the disproportionate burden on high-earners?

No, because Fiscal drag impacts on high earners as well. But taxes on low and middle earners in the UK are low compared to many OECD countries.

Yes, I get that frozen allowances pass all the way up the line to the top rate payers, but what are the alternatives? Raising the bottom rate would be electoral suicide; is the gap between the base and 40% rate wide enough to insert an intermediate (30% say) band? And middle earners are already vocal about being a squeezed demographic. 

I do remember colleagues in Belgium having about 5 bands, fairly tightly spaced: the bottom rate was similar to ours, but there were increments all the way up to about 55%. Employer's Social Security (as they called it - the equivalent of our employer's NI) was up around 30%, so sick pay, maternity pay, lay-off and redundancy compensation were all far more generous than UK equivalents; things like housing and public transport were also much cheaper. But anyway, this was all a long time ago and none of those options look viable for the UK as things presently stand.

Addendum: And anything any government does - however well intentioned - which is perceived as protecting the wealthy at the expense of the lower and middle demographics is a hard sell politically. That said, I think we're at the point where there are no easy sells.
Reply
#53
(09-11-2026, 07:25 AM)Øssian Wrote:
(09-11-2026, 05:51 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(09-10-2026, 12:44 PM)Øssian Wrote: So, if I'm interpreting these exchanges correctly, there's an argument to be had that fiscal drag is actually a good thing as it progressively pulls more low-end earners into paying tax to relieve some of the disproportionate burden on high-earners?

No, because Fiscal drag impacts on high earners as well. But taxes on low and middle earners in the UK are low compared to many OECD countries.

Yes, I get that frozen allowances pass all the way up the line to the top rate payers, but what are the alternatives? Raising the bottom rate would be electoral suicide; is the gap between the base and 40% rate wide enough to insert an intermediate (30% say) band? And middle earners are already vocal about being a squeezed demographic. 

I do remember colleagues in Belgium having about 5 bands, fairly tightly spaced: the bottom rate was similar to ours, but there were increments all the way up to about 55%. Employer's Social Security (as they called it - the equivalent of our employer's NI) was up around 30%, so sick pay, maternity pay, lay-off and redundancy compensation were all far more generous than UK equivalents; things like housing and public transport were also much cheaper. But anyway, this was all a long time ago and none of those options look viable for the UK as things presently stand.

Addendum: And anything any government does - however well intentioned - which is perceived as protecting the wealthy at the expense of the lower and middle demographics is a hard sell politically. That said, I think we're at the point where there are no easy sells.

Yep, tax reform is difficult. We already essentially have a 32% band with NICs. What the Tories were doing was quite sensible... lower the NICs, fiscal drag for income tax. That meant the pensioners were starting to pay more - seems fair given many of them voted for Brexit and most of our taxes go to pay their health care because they didn't pay enough over their lifetimes (child benefit for everyone, no VAT on private schools etc..............................).
Reply
#54
I beleive there is an obvious one that is being missed at the moment and that is get rid of the triple lock and to balance it out put the PA in line with whatever the state pension moves to.
Reply
#55
(09-10-2026, 10:34 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You appear to be arguing that rich people should be incentivised to stay in the Uk instead of doing what rich people have done forever which is fuck off somewhere hot. Not everyone makes decisions based on how much tax they pay. Your own argument is that rich people should pay less tax - that in itself means someone has to make up the shortfall. It’s an idiotic stance

What are you talking about? I just want the UK with its abundant attractions - like London - to be as attractive to UK and overseas HNW taxpayers as it can be. There is a reason some huge taxpayers CHOSE to domicile themselves here and have now CHOSEN not to. What do think that reason is?

Many overseas HNWs used to (using your parlance) "fuck off" to London.

My argument is simple, but let me spell it as you don't seem to understand. We were once attractive to HNWs because they perceived taxes on income and wealth to be fair, or at least worth the opportunity cost of being in London rather than elsewhere. Now, they are not.

If you have a lower tax rate, but far more HNW taxpayers what do you think happens to your overall tax take? There is no "shortfall" for the rest of us to make up.

It's exactly the same effect with Corporation Tax.

The removal of non-dom status, for instance, is right up there with Milibands 6th form performative garbage from earlier this week.
Reply
#56
I understand what you are saying in your patronising way. I’m just saying that not every human behaviour and choice is down to taxation. If you don’t think that you are brainwashed look at the phraseology you use when describing something you agree with compared with something you don’t.
Reply
#57
(09-12-2026, 07:35 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I understand what you are saying in your patronising way. I’m just saying that not every human behaviour and choice is down to taxation. If you don’t think that you are brainwashed look at the phraseology you use when describing something you agree with compared with something you don’t.

That isn't just what you were saying B1, you stated if they reduced the tax rate for these HNWs then everyone else would have to pay more. Which is patently not true if the reduction has the desired effect of attracting more of them (the premise). It's why debates on here always crumble into pettiness. There's very little good faith.
Reply
#58
Cracktits lecturing on debates turning petty. Just when you think you’ve seen it all.
Raw Sausage
Reply
#59
(09-12-2026, 08:25 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Cracktits lecturing on debates turning petty. Just when you think you’ve seen it all.

Here he is, tHE gENOcIDE. Nurse!!
Reply
#60
(09-11-2026, 11:10 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(09-11-2026, 07:25 AM)Øssian Wrote:
(09-11-2026, 05:51 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(09-10-2026, 12:44 PM)Øssian Wrote: So, if I'm interpreting these exchanges correctly, there's an argument to be had that fiscal drag is actually a good thing as it progressively pulls more low-end earners into paying tax to relieve some of the disproportionate burden on high-earners?

No, because Fiscal drag impacts on high earners as well. But taxes on low and middle earners in the UK are low compared to many OECD countries.

Yes, I get that frozen allowances pass all the way up the line to the top rate payers, but what are the alternatives? Raising the bottom rate would be electoral suicide; is the gap between the base and 40% rate wide enough to insert an intermediate (30% say) band? And middle earners are already vocal about being a squeezed demographic. 

I do remember colleagues in Belgium having about 5 bands, fairly tightly spaced: the bottom rate was similar to ours, but there were increments all the way up to about 55%. Employer's Social Security (as they called it - the equivalent of our employer's NI) was up around 30%, so sick pay, maternity pay, lay-off and redundancy compensation were all far more generous than UK equivalents; things like housing and public transport were also much cheaper. But anyway, this was all a long time ago and none of those options look viable for the UK as things presently stand.

Addendum: And anything any government does - however well intentioned - which is perceived as protecting the wealthy at the expense of the lower and middle demographics is a hard sell politically. That said, I think we're at the point where there are no easy sells.

Yep, tax reform is difficult. We already essentially have a 32% band with NICs. What the Tories were doing was quite sensible... lower the NICs, fiscal drag for income tax. That meant the pensioners were starting to pay more - seems fair given many of them voted for Brexit and most of our taxes go to pay their health care because they didn't pay enough over their lifetimes (child benefit for everyone, no VAT on private schools etc..............................).

It was not sensible. They weren't raising income tax to compensate for NIC reductions, they were pursuing unfunded tax cuts. Fiscal drag was not sufficient to cover the lost revenue to the Exchequer.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: