The State Of Labour MPs
#1
As if the Tory intake in 2019 wasn't bad enough, backbench Labour MPs are attempting to rewrite the origin of markets / laws of economics:

"Public sector workers use their income to pay FOR the private sector. The state is one of the biggest procurers of the private sector. It [the private sector] wouldn’t exist without taxpayers. People creating the divide between public and private genuinely don’t understand how an economy works." 

Jonathan Brash, Labour - Hartlepool
Reply
#2
When you say MPs, you mean an MP I assume
Reply
#3
Crikey, what a prize berk. Exports (service and ideally goods) and natural resource are among the best wealth creators. Human capital, innovation and development being a huge part of this.

The public sector is an essential collective of entities that underpins this. Few would argue how vital a good public sector is. All part of the same money merry-go-round. It could be argued - yes - that publicly funded education enables a private sector workforce, protects it and services it, keeps it healthy (ideally) amongst a whole host of other essential services. And yes, a lot of public money goes to private companies. Always wisely, though? And saying that it alone pays for the private sector? Seldom before have I heard such bollocks.

What about all the private sector employees and companies who buy stuff from private companies also? Is he ignoring those?

And, erm, back to those exports?

Also, 90% of millionaires are so through real estate. Was that bought with public money? That being said, I know of a lot of GPs who got rich and bought land by - yep - selling out to the private sector.

I am, however, taking these comments at face-value as his be-all, end-all mantra. If there is a context to all of this; i.e. were the comments made with regard to something specific, then that changes things a bit.
Reply
#4
(08-21-2026, 01:07 PM)baggy1 Wrote: When you say MPs, you mean an MP I assume

Is that a challenge?
Reply
#5
This MP is an idiot, but I still think Labour under Burnham represents the best option at the moment is Farage and Badenoch are the only other answers.
Reply
#6
(08-24-2026, 10:18 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: This MP is an idiot, but I still think Labour under Burnham represents the best option at the moment is Farage and Badenoch are the only other answers.

What has Burnham done so far, or said he's going to do that makes you think that?

He appears to me to be one of those people who's desperate to by liked. He's saying a lot of things to a lot of people and groups, but has faced zero direct scrutiny by either the media or in Parliament so far. When he does I expect we'll find he's as thin-skinned and chippy as Starmer (and Farage).

Short videos of him in the pub or Angela Rayner telling us what her quiz team would be will not save the hospitality industry or build 1.5 million homes. There's a £3 Trillion debt problem which remains wholly unaddressed too.

If Burnham is the best option, the question is - best option for what?
Reply
#7
#LeastWorst
Reply
#8
(08-24-2026, 11:09 AM)baggy1 Wrote: #LeastWorst

Ah. "Best option" = #LeastWorst.

Why didn't he say that then?
Reply
#9
Here to help
Reply
#10
(08-24-2026, 10:30 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-24-2026, 10:18 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: This MP is an idiot, but I still think Labour under Burnham represents the best option at the moment is Farage and Badenoch are the only other answers.

What has Burnham done so far, or said he's going to do that makes you think that?

He appears to me to be one of those people who's desperate to by liked. He's saying a lot of things to a lot of people and groups, but has faced zero direct scrutiny by either the media or in Parliament so far. When he does I expect we'll find he's as thin-skinned and chippy as Starmer (and Farage).

Short videos of him in the pub or Angela Rayner telling us what her quiz team would be will not save the hospitality industry or build 1.5 million homes. There's a £3 Trillion debt problem which remains wholly unaddressed too.

If Burnham is the best option, the question is - best option for what?

Erm being PM?

He's hardly going to turn the country around in a couple of weeks. Perhaps stability and us inching forward. He's inherited a shit tip. 

The most important thing I think at the minute is quelling the hatred and extremism of Reform.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)