Jason Arday
An irony of this thread that I hadn’t missed.
Raw Sausage
Reply
(08-16-2026, 06:59 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: It’s a good job being a fantasist about your level of expertise isn’t a death sentence for everyone, that’s for sure.


Leave Mowbray out of this
Reply
Surely the whole point of debate is that it's opposing sides? Agree of not, Squid and Proth have at least shared their thoughts and why. It's miles better than some of the shit we have on here whether you agree or not.
Reply
(08-16-2026, 08:34 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Surely the whole point of debate is that it's opposing sides? Agree of not, Squid and Proth have at least shared their thoughts and why. It's miles better than some of the shit we have on here whether you agree or not.

Proth's thoughts are blinkered by being focused solely on Arday and not the wider narrative of targeting of all non-white people in academic institutions as referenced by B68 by trying to pretend as though just because Arday was a charlatan every non-white academic is a fraudster which was the purpose of the blog post by the overtly racist person who "broke" the story (not the THE who were SLAPPed by Carter Fuck as they are affectionately known in Private Eye), as shown by Pindgill trying to act like Malala getting into Oxford wasn't on merit with an entirely unsourced claim that is directly contradicted by every account of her A-Level results (and curiously far more tentative a link than Oxbridge colleges being lenient to admissions on postgraduate courses to help them in the Boat Race).
Reply
As I stated in the OP, this is tragedy for his family.

I also believe the media feeding frenzy has an awful lot to do with Arday employing a legal approach beloved of Russian Oligarchs, sex offenders and fraudsters. That was of course after he played the race card and began threatening then actually reporting people to the police.

Clearly having built a persona, reputation and livelihood on a tissue of lies, the personal cost of this coming crashing down must have felt unbearable. The last weeks of his life must have been intolerable. However the denials, accusations of harassment and extreme legal action were his choices.

What may appear a racist witch hunt could’ve been dealt with by Cambridge, or by engaging within the questions being raised by other academics in the field years ago. Arday, apparently chose an alternative route. That’s the root of this tragedy.
Reply
(08-16-2026, 09:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote: As I stated in the OP, this is tragedy for his family.

I also believe the media feeding frenzy has an awful lot to do with Arday employing a legal approach beloved of Russian Oligarchs, sex offenders and fraudsters. That was of course after he played the race card and began threatening then actually reporting people to the police.

Clearly having built a persona, reputation and livelihood on a tissue of lies, the personal cost of this coming crashing down must have felt unbearable. The last weeks of his life must have been intolerable. However the denials, accusations of harassment and extreme legal action were his choices.

What may appear a racist witch hunt could’ve been dealt with by Cambridge, or by engaging within the questions being raised by other academics in the field years ago. Arday, apparently chose an alternative route. That’s the root of this tragedy.

You are yet again choosing to ignore the wider context as to Cofnas' blog post which is what B68 directly referred to and has been quoted in regards to things unrelated to Arday.
Reply
(08-16-2026, 06:39 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(08-16-2026, 11:11 AM)Squid Wrote:
(08-16-2026, 09:36 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: As I said a while back, everyone has to have an “opinion” on Arday, and not being able to step back and see the wider thing for what it is, is being blind to the actual important stuff that is going on.

Again, this is a claim that could be made about any thread discussing current affairs, so why make it here?

FWIW, the higher education sector is in massive financial trouble and if any university collapses, it will have an economic and societal impact far beyond the students and staff. The very last thing the sector needs is a scandal like this, but pretending there's nothing to see here and it's all the fault of the wicked, nasty media is the very last response that needs to happen. Both Cambridge and LJMU have significant questions to answer.

I haven't seen anyone disagree with that.
Do you agree that a black bloke was hounded far more than a white bloke?
Not just by the right wing media either. The Grauniad happily dived in

If you are referring to this:

https://www.theguardian.com/education/ng...ason-arday

Which is an excellent piece of investigative journalism, that is deeply concerning. It is an excellent overview of events, it makes very clear why this is newsworthy,  it speaks to a very broad range of sources and it isn't behind a paywall.
How is that disgusting? If you want to dissuade that type of journalism, it is very obvious how any type of "anti-witch hunt" legislation will be very quickly seized upon by bad actors. 

In response to your question, I think the Arday case shows the double edged sword of race. To some he could only ever be an innocent victim, to others his race made him a poster boy for so many they dislike. At the same time, Arday himself used race to deflect the criticism against him.

I think this quote by another Black academic, Tyler Austin sums up the issue with both sides of the coverage here:

What I propose is that the public give Arday a courtesy in death that he was often denied in life: Let’s treat him like a person. Not like Cambridge’s magical negro, or like Simon & Schuster’s golden goose, or like the fetish object of internet racists, but like a flawed human being who should still be alive but is not. That requires being honest about who Arday was, not despite his tragic death but because of it. After all, it was systemic, ritualized dishonesty—his own and others’—that undid him.

His article is worth reading in full: https://archive.is/b8QaG
Reply
(08-16-2026, 09:11 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-16-2026, 06:39 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(08-16-2026, 11:11 AM)Squid Wrote:
(08-16-2026, 09:36 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: As I said a while back, everyone has to have an “opinion” on Arday, and not being able to step back and see the wider thing for what it is, is being blind to the actual important stuff that is going on.

Again, this is a claim that could be made about any thread discussing current affairs, so why make it here?

FWIW, the higher education sector is in massive financial trouble and if any university collapses, it will have an economic and societal impact far beyond the students and staff. The very last thing the sector needs is a scandal like this, but pretending there's nothing to see here and it's all the fault of the wicked, nasty media is the very last response that needs to happen. Both Cambridge and LJMU have significant questions to answer.

I haven't seen anyone disagree with that.
Do you agree that a black bloke was hounded far more than a white bloke?
Not just by the right wing media either. The Grauniad happily dived in

If you are referring to this:

https://www.theguardian.com/education/ng...ason-arday

Which is an excellent piece of investigative journalism, that is deeply concerning. It is an excellent overview of events, it makes very clear why this is newsworthy,  it speaks to a very broad range of sources and it isn't behind a paywall.
How is that disgusting? If you want to dissuade that type of journalism, it is very obvious how any type of "anti-witch hunt" legislation will be very quickly seized upon by bad actors. 

In response to your question, I think the Arday case shows the double edged sword of race. To some he could only ever be an innocent victim, to others his race made him a poster boy for so many they dislike. At the same time, Arday himself used race to deflect the criticism against him.

I think this quote by another Black academic, Tyler Austin sums up the issue with both sides of the coverage here:

What I propose is that the public give Arday a courtesy in death that he was often denied in life: Let’s treat him like a person. Not like Cambridge’s magical negro, or like Simon & Schuster’s golden goose, or like the fetish object of internet racists, but like a flawed human being who should still be alive but is not. That requires being honest about who Arday was, not despite his tragic death but because of it. After all, it was systemic, ritualized dishonesty—his own and others’—that undid him.

His article is worth reading in full: https://archive.is/b8QaG

Hopefully that post and the pertinent quote wraps this whole thread up.
Reply
I could not agree more with Tyler Austin.
Reply
(08-16-2026, 05:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(08-16-2026, 05:26 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(08-16-2026, 05:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(08-16-2026, 04:56 PM)pindgill Wrote: He embellished and did what he had to do to get the position at Cambridge!!..
Most people get to Oxford or Cambridge by word of mouth paying or just because it’s good publicity Malala Yousafzai got piss pot poor A level grades from her Birmingham private school ( paid for by Birmingham rate payers ) but Oxford took her!!.
Lad was bullied to suicide just so tragic.

Malala got a conditional offer at the exact same terms as everyone else at 3 As (still the conditional requirements now) and she got a 2:1 in an essay-based arts subject in her second language, what the hell are you on about?

Her A level results were bang average nowhere near 3 As!!!…You’re misinformed.
Oxford took her because of the good publicity!!.

It was widely reported that she met the conditions of her offer which was 3 As, what is your source?
When you know, you know. If you are saying it was widely reported it would be interesting to see if there was a definitive report detailing her academic exploits.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)