Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
08-12-2026, 09:29 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-12-2026, 09:39 AM by Shabby Russian.)
(08-11-2026, 03:46 PM)baggy1 Wrote: This is the problem with trying to debate anything on here. That statement might be true Dekka but it has nothing to do with the discussion. Do you think that a wealth tax in the UK would impact a Thai based crypto billionaire and stop him having influence over politicians?
Well that's easily solved if you have the political will to do it.
Cap political donations to a maximum of£1k per year (other figures could be debated).
And a total ban on political donations from people who do not pay tax in UK.
(08-11-2026, 10:36 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Firstly - why are you talking about billionaires? Stevenson is proposing a Wealth Tax on assets in excess of £10m.
Second, the contentions you make about the composition of wealth and this bizarre idea of competition with the middle and working classes don’t pass muster. The Fed and UBS found that 85-90% of HNWs holdings are in private businesses. Business has always been the fastest way to grow wealth - or indeed to lose it.
I just don’t buy this contention that the poor cannot accumulate assets because the rich are buying them all. It simply isn’t true. If Gary was any sort of economist he’d know that if you ration housebuilding in an era of mass immigration and record household formation then the price of housing or rent will increase.
Home ownership is the absolute key metric as it enables future borrowing for consumption or investment. The rich and super rich are not to blame for 50 years of rationing in housing. This simple point eludes Gary despite him continually talking about his parents generations and their access to housing.
The super rich are not competing with you to buy three bed semis - middle class landlords are. The super rich are not preventing anyone from accumulating wealth in a pension or ISA. The cost of living - principally housing drives a lack of excess income to invest.
Gary’s focus is all wrong. Sort out the housing crisis and everything else looks after itself.
It isn’t the super rich who’ve increased the average cost of building a housing unit by £76,000 in just 6 years. It’s inflation and government edict.
This is why LVT is such a compelling argument. Combine it with scrapping SDLT and you have a force multiplier for housing development.
This isn’t complex. And it makes economic sense unlike most of Gary’s ideas.
How's the market doing in solving the housing problem.
It's in the best interests of private landlords and house builders that there is a shortage of housing available to buy or rent.
Unless the Govt step in and start building houses, there will be a continuing housing shortage.
Plus the housing market also proves one of Stevensons beliefs, that there has been a transfer of assets from the state and the economically well off. 40% of council houses sold are now in the hands of private landlords. For a brief period these assets were held by those who lived in them, but no longer.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Luckily they all play by the rules don't they, the point of the statement was more to do with Dekka's response to a question about wealth tax in the UK with a rant about rich people globally. He may as well have just posted 'Free Palestine', it was about as relevant.
And on the political donations point, I agree.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
There is no such thing as a “market” for housing when planning rations provision and the sheer cost of complying with modern building regulations rations provision, when SDLT so distorts and disincentivises movement of labour or downsizing. Liberalise planning, ditch SDLT, ditch the lunacy of insulating houses within an inch of their lives in a heating world.
Ex-Council Houses are not owned by people with more than £10 million in assets. They’re owned by people like me and my business partner. We have two in the portfolio.
I have no problem with Councils building more homes. I have no problem with developers building more homes. Real house prices have FALLEN over 6 years - hardly surprising when inflation is over 30% cumulatively. Gary would be far better off campaigning about things that are a) matter and are b) likely to benefit anyone.
He doesn’t. And I can’t work out why.
Posts: 293
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
Proth, say, god forbid, something happens to you and your kids inherit your business but have no interest in running it and need to sell it to pay IHT. If the best price is offered by someone looking to grow their bosses portfolio in an easy to run business with a decent yield rather than selling each property individualy will they do it, is it impossible to imagine. How about if its an investment vehicle of someone they do not know. That is assets being transfered to HNW individuals and it can and does happen.
As for why GS doesnt campaign on housing policy - that is because he is an inequality economist and he believes the best way to address it is wealth tax.
If you want to look at some housing campaigners I can find you some but the reason there is no threads on this group about them is they are not as effective as GS
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
08-12-2026, 02:33 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-12-2026, 02:36 PM by Protheroe.)
We bought both the ex-Council house off other small investors. Corporate investors fund new buy to rent schemes in lots of tens or even hundreds of units. It not in their interests to buy small and geographically dispersed lot sizes with varied maintenance regimes like our holdings - it’s a completely different market.
I’m a surveyor by profession, I was a commercial developer for 15 years and have been a property investor for 20. This is what I find incredible about Gary’s bullshit. He doesn’t know what he’s talking about I’m afraid.
And if Gary is truly an “inequality economist” he’d know that on the key measure inequality has not materially increased in 20 years. The guys a grifter making £20K a month from Patreon alone.
Posts: 7,862
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
(08-12-2026, 02:33 PM)Protheroe Wrote: We bought both the ex-Council house off other small investors. Corporate investors fund new buy to rent schemes in lots of tens or even hundreds of units. It not in their interests to buy small and geographically dispersed lot sizes with varied maintenance regimes like our holdings - it’s a completely different market.
I’m a surveyor by profession, I was a commercial developer for 15 years and have been a property investor for 20. This is what I find incredible about Gary’s bullshit. He doesn’t know what he’s talking about I’m afraid.
And if Gary is truly an “inequality economist” he’d know that on the key measure inequality has not materially increased in 20 years. The guys a grifter making £20K a month from Patreon alone.
He makes more than that on the interest on his bank balance ffs!
In the form of his life.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(08-12-2026, 03:40 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: He makes more than that on the interest on his bank balance ffs!
And?
He's grifting around £250K from the gullible on Patreon, without even considering the rest of the money from You Tube, media, that risible "documentary".
He's never even explained what "trades" he made on "increasing inequality" when at work. I can only assume he bet on asset prices increasing - which in an era of zero real interest rates is hardly genius levels of foresight.
For someone who's supposedly so talented to retreat behind the excuse that "I'm not a tax expert, I'm an inequality economist" is pathetic. If you're making arguments that will have massive effects on incentives and behaviour shouldn't you at least have a rudimentary knowledge of incentives and behaviour? He's got a Masters degree in Economics FFS. Economics is all about incentives and behaviour...
100% shameless grift.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(08-13-2026, 06:57 AM)Protheroe Wrote: 100% shameless grift.
Find me an influencer in any field you can't level this accusation at!
Posts: 293
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
Why is he grifting? He asks for support and people pay him. His quest is to stop the transfer of assets from the government and the citizens to the super rich. He tried by working for think tanks and he tried by lobbying, nothing worked so he worked out the only way to get anywhere was social media and populism. Even you, Proth, must admit that he has done this pretty damn well, after all he got a C4 documentary
His prediction was that Labour would win the last election, do nothing on wealth transfer and become unpopular very quickly, Farage or a hard right coalition would win next because they blame the countries ills on migration, they will fail on the economy, one of the usual 2 will win next and then a shift further right because the previous right were too weak on imigration.
He quotes Milton Friedman regularly - Only a crisis - actual or perceived - produces real change. When that crisis occurs, the actions that are taken depend on the ideas that are lying around. He has made sure his is one of the ideas.
His knows his real mission is to turn people like proth - who has assets but I would imagine is nowehere near 10m or 100m. He needs to convince him that he is also vulnerable to the asset grab by the super rich - probably not him personally but without check almost certainly generationaly. This is the real challenge and something that GS admitts it is unlikley to win.
If you watch anything other than the documentary you will not know that when Dan Needle shot him down he asked him to help design a tax that would work - that bit didnt make the cut.
Again I refer back to brexit - those who sold us Brexit never sold us the outcome, GS message is do the tax - my view is the Zucmans tax is the best idea lying around at the moment
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
08-13-2026, 08:19 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-13-2026, 08:26 AM by Protheroe.)
(08-13-2026, 07:53 AM)petty sniper Wrote: Why is he grifting? He asks for support and people pay him. His quest is to stop the transfer of assets from the government and the citizens to the super rich. He tried by working for think tanks and he tried by lobbying, nothing worked so he worked out the only way to get anywhere was social media and populism. Even you, Proth, must admit that he has done this pretty damn well, after all he got a C4 documentary
His prediction was that Labour would win the last election, do nothing on wealth transfer and become unpopular very quickly, Farage or a hard right coalition would win next because they blame the countries ills on migration, they will fail on the economy, one of the usual 2 will win next and then a shift further right because the previous right were too weak on imigration.
He quotes Milton Friedman regularly - Only a crisis - actual or perceived - produces real change. When that crisis occurs, the actions that are taken depend on the ideas that are lying around. He has made sure his is one of the ideas.
His knows his real mission is to turn people like proth - who has assets but I would imagine is nowehere near 10m or 100m. He needs to convince him that he is also vulnerable to the asset grab by the super rich - probably not him personally but without check almost certainly generationaly. This is the real challenge and something that GS admitts it is unlikley to win.
If you watch anything other than the documentary you will not know that when Dan Needle shot him down he asked him to help design a tax that would work - that bit didnt make the cut.
Again I refer back to brexit - those who sold us Brexit never sold us the outcome, GS message is do the tax - my view is the Zucmans tax is the best idea lying around at the moment
He's grifting because he isn't telling you the truth. There's no point continuing this conversation if you're convinced by his comforting lies. Nothing worked with think-tanks because they all know he's wrong too.
He's objectively incorrect on the growth (or lack of it) in inequality. He is objectively incorrect on the proven effect of Wealth Taxes on behaviour. He is objectively incorrect on the premise that assets are in some way "finite" and that they will all be swallowed by the mega rich.
Dan Neidle's response would have been Land Value Tax by the way. He's done plenty of work on it. It's problematic, but far more achievable than the vague bullshit GS spouts:
https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2026/07/12/what...tually-do/
Why do you listen to Gary, and not Dan? One's an expert. One clearly isn't.
And Milton Friedmann is right about a crisis causing real change. Except the crisis isn't one of inequality - it's an affordability crisis in housing, and an approaching debt crisis for western governments.
(08-13-2026, 07:43 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-13-2026, 06:57 AM)Protheroe Wrote: 100% shameless grift.
Find me an influencer in any field you can't level this accusation at!
Martin Lewis? Rob Burgess? Just two I've taken valuable advice from this morning.
|