Gary's Economics
#81
You can avoid higher CGT by not selling assets. Even the OBR says this will happen.

You can avoid the ludicrous levels of SDLT by not buying assets. SDLT receipts for the most valuable properties has collapsed.

You can avoid the rising cost of employing people by not employing people. Unemployment is rising.

You can avoid the ludicrous tax cliff edges by not taking that promotion or going down to 4 days. There has never been such a ridiculous set of disincentives to earning more.

You can wholly avoid IHT incredibly easily.

You can leave the country for a more attractive jurisdiction. We now have the ridiculous situation where thousands of BTL companies are being established in Dubai FFS.

In the pursuit of more money you make the tax code stupid, complex and counter productive and don’t expect massive negative behavioural change.

Meanwhile ignore that NHS productivity is still 5.8% below its pre covid level. Productivity across swathes of the public sector is risible.

Gary says he’s not a tax expert as if it gives him some sort of get out of jail free card for such stupid ideas.

There’s a very simple solution that economists of the left and right agree on. It’s also pro-growth unlike ALL of the taxes listed above. So why isn’t Burnham considering a Land Value Tax?
Reply
#82
Proth - you appear to be making many of the same arguments that Zucman makes. The issue is that research shows that the tax take from those with assets over 100m drops off a cliff so a 2% minimum tax rate against asset value would go someway to help this.

If you think it is fine that the 0.1% with the broadest shoulders can get away with contributing very little then thats fine. There is no doubt that the tax system requires reform but it is such a massive task that would cost so much political capital and that is down to people who spout the same shit that the daily mail et all print when any suggestion is made that may affect the very well off. They somehow manage to rattle the cages of their readers ito thinking that the socialists are coming for their money.

I agree with the LVT, take a look at the headlines that has already generated as to why it is currently on the backburner.
Reply
#83
I get the concept PS. But no one (particularly Stevenson) seems to be able to explain how to value privately held business assets - which make up the vast majority of HNW portfolios. Let alone how to collect it.

If you look for instance at the record of former superstar fund manager Neil Woodford and the demise of his huge fund you’ll see how problematic it is valuing illiquid investments. Furthermore no one seems to be able to provide a moral argument for the double taxation of business assets.

And the absolute killer for a Wealth Tax is the chilling effect it would have on investment at a time when we need growth from productive assets.

Now contrast that with LVT which directly penalises unproductive assets. LVT, combined with the scrapping of SDLT could act as a force multiplier for growth.
Reply
#84
You can(and should) have both. You can value a business based on its turnover. What evidence do you have for privatley held business assets making up the vast majority of HNW individuals portfolios. That just seems like defeatism. It is difficult, like stopping the boats is difficult but it does not mean it cant be done.

The absolute killer of growth is that people have fuck all to spend because assets such as housing are really scare and leave them with little disposable income. I would also argue that an asset hoarded by someone with a huge wealth is less likley to be productive than an asset held by someone who needs to make income from said asset.

If a billionaire grows his wealth at a really modest 5% thats 50m per year. They are not going to be increasing their net spend but instead be buying assets that are more likley to sit idle. Now if through their activities they pay over 20m in tax then they are golden and will not be affected but if they just sit on their assets, watch them grow and hoover up more without a wealth tax what is the eventual outcome?

Eventually the middle and upper class will be competing in a game they cannot win as they will always be beaten by the super rich, unfortunatley the Government and the working class have lost. We have become an inheritocracy and if the well off (not super rich) dont see that eventually they will have to compete with billionaires and will lose then more fool them.
Reply
#85
Firstly - why are you talking about billionaires? Stevenson is proposing a Wealth Tax on assets in excess of £10m.

Second, the contentions you make about the composition of wealth and this bizarre idea of competition with the middle and working classes don’t pass muster. The Fed and UBS found that 85-90% of HNWs holdings are in private businesses. Business has always been the fastest way to grow wealth - or indeed to lose it.

I just don’t buy this contention that the poor cannot accumulate assets because the rich are buying them all. It simply isn’t true. If Gary was any sort of economist he’d know that if you ration housebuilding in an era of mass immigration and record household formation then the price of housing or rent will increase.

Home ownership is the absolute key metric as it enables future borrowing for consumption or investment. The rich and super rich are not to blame for 50 years of rationing in housing. This simple point eludes Gary despite him continually talking about his parents generations and their access to housing.

The super rich are not competing with you to buy three bed semis - middle class landlords are. The super rich are not preventing anyone from accumulating wealth in a pension or ISA. The cost of living - principally housing drives a lack of excess income to invest.

Gary’s focus is all wrong. Sort out the housing crisis and everything else looks after itself.

It isn’t the super rich who’ve increased the average cost of building a housing unit by £76,000 in just 6 years. It’s inflation and government edict.

This is why LVT is such a compelling argument. Combine it with scrapping SDLT and you have a force multiplier for housing development.

This isn’t complex. And it makes economic sense unlike most of Gary’s ideas.
Reply
#86
Great debate both, i do feel that the LVT point should be explored 1st before any sort of wealth tax. This is the point that everyone seems to agree with.
Reply
#87
(08-11-2026, 10:36 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Firstly - why are you talking about billionaires? Stevenson is proposing a Wealth Tax on assets in excess of £10m.

Second, the contentions you make about the composition of wealth and this bizarre idea of competition with the middle and working classes don’t pass muster. The Fed and UBS found that 85-90% of HNWs holdings are in private businesses. Business has always been the fastest way to grow wealth - or indeed to lose it.

I just don’t buy this contention that the poor cannot accumulate assets because the rich are buying them all. It simply isn’t true. If Gary was any sort of economist he’d know that if you ration housebuilding in an era of mass immigration and record household formation then the price of housing or rent will increase.

Home ownership is the absolute key metric as it enables future borrowing for consumption or investment. The rich and super rich are not to blame for 50 years of rationing in housing. This simple point eludes Gary despite him continually talking about his parents generations and their access to housing.

The super rich are not competing with you to buy three bed semis - middle class landlords are. The super rich are not preventing anyone from accumulating wealth in a pension or ISA. The cost of living - principally housing drives a lack of excess income to invest.

Gary’s focus is all wrong. Sort out the housing crisis and everything else looks after itself.

It isn’t the super rich who’ve increased the average cost of building a housing unit by £76,000 in just 6 years. It’s inflation and government edict.

This is why LVT is such a compelling argument. Combine it with scrapping SDLT and you have a force multiplier for housing development.

This isn’t complex. And it makes economic sense unlike most of Gary’s ideas.

The super rich are a problem, they disproportionately have access to governments, they dictate and arguably influence the decisions they make and those decisions do affect communities. Not necessarily for for the better. It should not be case that the super rich are allowed do what they want, moving from country to country to avoid tax, keep wages low, buy up more and more companies to the point it becomes a monopoly in all but name. One look at the US shows exactly where giving free rein to billionaires leads a country, corruption, political interference.
Reply
#88
But that’s a completely different point. Rich people buy influence. Bears shit in woods.
Reply
#89
This is the problem with trying to debate anything on here. That statement might be true Dekka but it has nothing to do with the discussion. Do you think that a wealth tax in the UK would impact a Thai based crypto billionaire and stop him having influence over politicians?
Reply
#90
(08-11-2026, 10:36 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Firstly - why are you talking about billionaires? Stevenson is proposing a Wealth Tax on assets in excess of £10m.

Second, the contentions you make about the composition of wealth and this bizarre idea of competition with the middle and working classes don’t pass muster. The Fed and UBS found that 85-90% of HNWs holdings are in private businesses. Business has always been the fastest way to grow wealth - or indeed to lose it.

I just don’t buy this contention that the poor cannot accumulate assets because the rich are buying them all. It simply isn’t true. If Gary was any sort of economist he’d know that if you ration housebuilding in an era of mass immigration and record household formation then the price of housing or rent will increase.

Home ownership is the absolute key metric as it enables future borrowing for consumption or investment. The rich and super rich are not to blame for 50 years of rationing in housing. This simple point eludes Gary despite him continually talking about his parents generations and their access to housing.

The super rich are not competing with you to buy three bed semis - middle class landlords are. The super rich are not preventing anyone from accumulating wealth in a pension or ISA. The cost of living - principally housing drives a lack of excess income to invest.

Gary’s focus is all wrong. Sort out the housing crisis and everything else looks after itself.

It isn’t the super rich who’ve increased the average cost of building a housing unit by £76,000 in just 6 years. It’s inflation and government edict.

This is why LVT is such a compelling argument. Combine it with scrapping SDLT and you have a force multiplier for housing development.

This isn’t complex. And it makes economic sense unlike most of Gary’s ideas.

Point 1 - my prefered tax would be the one proposed by Gabriel Zucman those with over 100m assets must pay at least 2% of their asset value in tax per year or will be taxed to that notrional amount

Point 2 - Valuing business is not that daunting - the Sunday Times manage it every year! What do those business do - rent houses, own offices, make electric, lease cars. All of that affects those with less.

Point 3 - Blackrock? Greystar, sigma etc etc.

Stevenson is a campaigner and is pretty damn good at it - a wealth tax is now a national debate

I STILL agree that a LVT is needed and will discourage land banking and holding empty property.

Zucmans tax is a tax of fairness.  The data shows that at 100m of assets the tax take in many casees drops to almost nothing and this addresses it. 

You dont want it and your rational argument is that it will kill investment - I totally disagree.  Those who are super rich are more likley to bank assets rather than invest.  You want your investors to be millionaires/multi millionaires with less investments and more focus

If you think about it this is very much like the Brexit debate.  Those that wanted it had different vision of what it would look like.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)