Posts: 293
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
Billionaire wealth has more than doubled over the last 10 years. That is not just from holding assets - that is from aquiring more. Assets are not an infinate thing so the more they own and compete for them, the higher the price goes and the less that the rest are able to aquire. The two things that convince me that Zucman is correct are if you compare the Sunday times rich list and tax list the most wealthy dont pay their fair share or anywhere near, the other is during the Gary Stevenson documentary 2 of the wealthy people he interviewed said if a wealth tax came in the would sell their assets - even if it was at a loss which is the essence of the start of a redistribution. Remeber Zucman is not proposing to tax anyone who already pays the right tax -it is just to tax those who sit on wealth and contribute very little
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Don't feed the troll ps. For the record I have no argument against a wealth tax and think a workable one is welcome to most people. I also think it would raise some taxes although probably not as much as is being quoted for the reasons already stated.
A couple of points that your statement needs to be clear on. Your opening statement of 'Billionaire wealth has more than doubled in the last 10 years', can you get me a link to check that. I have no doubt that there are more Billionaires than there were 10 years ago but that doesn't mean that their wealth has doubled. If an individual has £900,000,000,000 in 2025 and £1Bn in 2026 there is 1 more Billionaire to measure that wasn't being measured before but that individual's wealth has not doubled. And also are we talking about UK Billionaires only here, I've never understood why there are different ways of measuring Bn between UK and US.
Secondly don't confuse solid assets (buildings, cars etc) which will make up some of their wealth, but I would guess at being a small part percentagewise, with the share type wealth that will make up the majority of their wealth. If they simply sell the latter type of assets then that won't be a redistributable asset and it will likely devalue the business or fund that they held it in.
And going back to the opening point, I am not arguing against a wealth tax I am asking for a workable one. Zucman has said that in order for this to work effectively there would need to be a coordinated global wealth tax and we are a billion miles off that at the moment. This is a good debating point but realistically wouldn't work in the UK at this point in time.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
A degree of sympathy with Dekka here. I don't think we should be arguing for a wealth tax, what he's saying is that those who are wealthy (I've seen £10m plus) should stop being such selfish pricks and realise that a couple of extra quid to them means nothing whereas it would help someone who really needs it. Oh well, people should just work harder or something like that.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
He's just arguing with himself on that one Ted as no-one has disagreed with the principle
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
I’m arguing against a wealth tax because it’s stupid and counter productive. I’m also really keen to hear what the “right amount” of tax is. I pay the “right amount” of tax - that which is legally due. Like any other rational human being I also adopt fully legal avoidance techniques designed by the Treasury no less to encourage “good behaviour”.
I am very far from even the £10 million “wealth” that Gaz wants to tax, but I’m really keen to understand what amount of money PS and Dekka believe the state is entitled to and why (beyond the fact that they may own more).
The suggestion that assets “are not infinite” - which suggests they’re finite is one of the most cretinous remarks I’ve ever read on here (in a crowded field).
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
'Wealth tax' is the new Brexit. No-one can define it or what the benefits will be but they just want it.
There is a massive misunderstanding in how wealth actually materialises here - taking the most well known one, Elon Musk, for example. His wealth is created by the value of his shares going up and, if he were in the UK, he would pay a tax on that if he ever realised them. That is a wealth tax. If he owned two houses and sold his second home, he would pay tax on that. That is a wealth tax. When he dies and he passes his wealth onto other individuals there is a tax at that point. All of these are taxes on wealth.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
Switzerland's wealth tax is balanced by it's low top rate income tax rate, we don't have that.