Gary's Economics
#51
(08-05-2026, 02:49 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I don't think anyone would disagree with your protest commentary however the debate here is how to tax it. I'll ask for the umpteenth time, do you have a real solution to this problem or are you just gluing yourself to the road here?

I do think there’s an argument for saying that when a company is as shameless as Amazon (who I use, by the way) they should be subject to a sales tax, payable in the country where the sale arises; in other words, where the electronic purchase transaction is initiated. 

I also think that when your customer checks stock availability, initiates secure payment prior to receipt - using equipment and connections paid for by themselves - and when delivery is mostly effected via infrastructure which they and other customers have also funded, there is a certain moral incumbency to reciprocate. But we can probably discount the likelihood of moral incumbency being raised in the Amazon executive suite.

Amazon are just an example, by the way; there are others in a similar frame.
Reply
#52
I agree Oss but that sales tax would fall on the customer no doubt and not hit the profits. There was talk a few years ago about standardising taxation globally but that seemed to die a death. It is very easy for companies to move their profit making operations to a low tax company, Ireland used this approach very well recently.

Unfortunately that isn’t what Dekka is shouting into the void about - he wants a wealth tax and although the restrictions and problems that would arise have been pointed out by experts he doesn’t want to hear that and doesn’t have a solution at the same time.

(08-05-2026, 04:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-05-2026, 04:13 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-05-2026, 01:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Arf middle class posters that are clearly comfortably off, talking about their portfolios of investments. May I suggest they may be a tad out of touch with the reality for many in society. 

The idea that billionaires aren’t the problem, when it’s clear that many influence politics around the globe fit their benefit, no one else’s. Shifting work forces from one country to the next just to save them and their shareholders money. Influencing elections, being in control or influence over energy, water, transport and housing etc.

But you’re not talking about billionaires. You’re talking about people with more than £10 million in “wealth”.

If I had ‘wealth’ of over £10m I’d happily pay more tax. No one lives in a bubble, no one gets where they are without the help and hardwork of hundreds of thousands of others in the background. Be it the roads they use, the education they received, the protection they’ve had or the hard work of others. 

You see, I believe there is such a thing as society and that everyone for themselves leads to exactly where this country now finds itself, polarised, angry and unable to offer a place where people collectively are proud to call home. Instead the two main parties have presided over creating ghettos for the poor, leave millions reliant on creaking public service’s, put some of the worst people on pedestals because society is so base now that money ahem Trumps all else.

Oh good God, get out of the pulpit and tell us how to solve the problem or point to someone that knows how. By the way Proth was pointing out these your statement about posters saying that Billionaires  not being the problem, despite no-one saying that, wasn’t what was being talked about due to someone with £10m not being a billionaire.
Reply
#53
(08-05-2026, 05:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I agree Oss but that sales tax would fall on the customer no doubt and not hit the profits. There was talk a few years ago about standardising taxation globally but that seemed to die a death. It is very easy for companies to move their profit making operations to a low tax company, Ireland used this approach very well recently.

Unfortunately that isn’t what Dekka is shouting into the void about - he wants a wealth tax and although the restrictions and problems that would arise have been pointed out by experts he doesn’t want to hear that and doesn’t have a solution at the same time.

(08-05-2026, 04:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-05-2026, 04:13 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-05-2026, 01:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Arf middle class posters that are clearly comfortably off, talking about their portfolios of investments. May I suggest they may be a tad out of touch with the reality for many in society. 

The idea that billionaires aren’t the problem, when it’s clear that many influence politics around the globe fit their benefit, no one else’s. Shifting work forces from one country to the next just to save them and their shareholders money. Influencing elections, being in control or influence over energy, water, transport and housing etc.

But you’re not talking about billionaires. You’re talking about people with more than £10 million in “wealth”.

If I had ‘wealth’ of over £10m I’d happily pay more tax. No one lives in a bubble, no one gets where they are without the help and hardwork of hundreds of thousands of others in the background. Be it the roads they use, the education they received, the protection they’ve had or the hard work of others. 

You see, I believe there is such a thing as society and that everyone for themselves leads to exactly where this country now finds itself, polarised, angry and unable to offer a place where people collectively are proud to call home. Instead the two main parties have presided over creating ghettos for the poor, leave millions reliant on creaking public service’s, put some of the worst people on pedestals because society is so base now that money ahem Trumps all else.

Oh good God, get out of the pulpit and tell us how to solve the problem or point to someone that knows how. By the way Proth was pointing out these your statement about posters saying that Billionaires  not being the problem, despite no-one saying that, wasn’t what was being talked about due to someone with £10m not being a billionaire.

You never have an answer, all you do is parrot whatever Starmer and Reeve came up with. Which was essentially Sunak-lite! You seek to think trickle down economics has worked but at the same time can’t fathom why people are leaving the two main political parties.
Reply
#54
I’m not certain that I have ever said trickle down economics works, because I don’t believe that it does. I’d imagine I’ve said that very thing on here. You’re getting confused because you seem to have lost all sense of balance.
Reply
#55
(08-05-2026, 06:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I’m not certain that I have ever said trickle down economics works, because I don’t believe that it does. I’d imagine I’ve said that very thing on here. You’re getting confused because you seem to have lost all sense of balance.

Doing the same thing as we’ve done for the past 40-50 years has got us to where we are economically and socially, whether that is good or bad is open to debate. It is however why we have a splintered political system now, and why many people are fed up and looking towards simple answers, because 40 yrs doing pretty much the same thing has brought nothing but broken public services, contemptible politicians and inequality and in my opinion a dysfunctional society.
Reply
#56
Let me try and explain a bit about the problem as I see it. If you get a 5% pay rise and inflation is at 6% then the money that you get in your pay packet will buy you less each year, therefore you are poorer even though you earn more. This isn’t anything to do with somebody that is rich, no matter how you define that, they are not taking that 1% away from you. In a lot of cases and up until recently a lot of the country were not getting pay rises at all and inflation continued to push prices up.

Herein lies the biggest problem of the last few years, a lot of the causes of inflation have been outside the control of anyone in this country, with one obvious exception. Covid, oil prices, Ukraine war, Iran, Trump, crop failures and many other things have all contributed to inflation. The only issue that has made things worse in this area that is self inflicted is Brexit, which is why I am so striongly against it still.

That is why we are poorer, and blaming the ‘rich’ or threatening to tax them randomly will not solve the 1st problem. Taxing the rich won’t feed into your pay packet it will go towards increasing government spending. Eventually that pot will run dry, especially if you are proposing taxing wealth and not wealth growth, as it will simply eat into the asset that is creating the wealth. I’m not even considering the portability of that wealth as a problem but if you proposed a tax on beards tomorrow what do you think would happen?

I could then go into why Austerity has fucked us and why we needed a stable government for at least a decade to try and rebuild the country, but that ship has sailed already because well, he wasn’t exciting enough really and didn’t sell the dream.

And it’s probably worth pointing out that the person you deride so much, Reeves, was the one that actually found a way to tax wealth and implemented it. This fact appears to be ignored completely.
Reply
#57
(08-05-2026, 05:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I agree Oss but that sales tax would fall on the customer no doubt and not hit the profits. There was talk a few years ago about standardising taxation globally but that seemed to die a death. It is very easy for companies to move their profit making operations to a low tax company, Ireland used this approach very well recently. 

There's no doubt that businesses would do everything possible to maintain their margins, but there is at least an element of choice for the consumer, insofar as there is competition. I do also wonder just how effective HMRC are when it comes to collecting tax from those organisations with sufficient clout to indulge in aggressive lobbying. Our main CT rate is not out of line with comparable G7 and OECD economies; maybe their citizens also see them as soft touches when pressurised by the mega conglomerates.

Incidentally, I owe HMRC a relatively small amount arising from a fixed bond maturing during the 2024/25 tax year, which took me over the £1,000 allowance. I waited, and waited, for the assessment and coding change to arrive until eventually, in December 2025, I called them (because, notwithstanding the system, the ultimate responsibility remains with me). I was assured that I owed no tax as the account in question was closed: I tried multiple times to explain that the account had matured with interest, but was informed - also multiple times - that my file had been assessed and no tax was due. I have a record of the date, time and name of HMRC employee (who has probably already left). Did make me wonder though.

It wouldn't have paid for a Eurofighter.
Reply
#58
I would hazard a guess at next to useless and they place massive reliance on the Accountants deriving the correct amount for taxation. I can’t imagine that there are many cases where the revenue actually look beyond the figures presented. It’s a shame in one sense that working in the revenue was seen as a viable route into a career that was worthwhile 40 years ago, now I can’t imagine that it is much more than a route in for apprentices to get tax expertise before going to a firm of accountants.
Reply
#59
(08-05-2026, 06:40 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Let me try and explain a bit about the problem as I see it. If you get a 5% pay rise and inflation is at 6% then the money that you get in your pay packet will buy you less each year, therefore you are poorer even though you earn more. This isn’t anything to do with somebody that is rich, no matter how you define that, they are not taking that 1% away from you. In a lot of cases and up until recently a lot of the country were not getting pay rises at all and inflation continued to push prices up.

Herein lies the biggest problem of the last few years, a lot of the causes of inflation have been outside the control of anyone in this country, with one obvious exception. Covid, oil prices, Ukraine war, Iran, Trump, crop failures and many other things have all contributed to inflation. The only issue that has made things worse in this area that is self inflicted is Brexit, which is why I am so striongly against it still.

That is why we are poorer, and blaming the ‘rich’ or threatening to tax them randomly will not solve the 1st problem. Taxing the rich won’t feed into your pay packet it will go towards increasing government spending. Eventually that pot will run dry, especially if you are proposing taxing wealth and not wealth growth, as it will simply eat into the asset that is creating the wealth. I’m not even considering the portability of that wealth as a problem but if you proposed a tax on beards tomorrow what do you think would happen?

I could then go into why Austerity has fucked us and why we needed a stable government for at least a decade to try and rebuild the country, but that ship has sailed already because well, he wasn’t exciting enough really and didn’t sell the dream.

And it’s probably worth pointing out that the person you deride so much, Reeves, was the one that actually found a way to tax wealth and implemented it. This fact appears to be ignored completely.

So you’re ignoring the financial crisis caused by millionaire bankers irresponsibility with your  rather selective history lesson. No mention of Thatcher creating a greed is good society either? As I said if you’re happy to plod along thinking Tory Sunak-lite policies under Starmer and Reeves were the answer then you’re still very much in denial where the country was heading. 

There really isn’t anything between your position and Proth’s which is a perfect example of why nothing really ever changes. Just more of the same punching and talking down to people.
Reply
#60
There really is no helping you. Read what has been said there about inflation and wages. And whilst you’re at it why don’t you offer a realistic solution that isn’t a transparently thin three word slogan. Stop the boats, get brexit done, tax the rich.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: