Posts: 293
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
If they already pay more than the 2% then there is no extra tax. As for unlisted business assets - where is the proof of that and if it is the case and you know then so will others. It is difficult to implement but not thaty difficult if the will is there. My belief is that it is necessary otherwise eventually the super rich will own everything
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
There is no evidence that the super rich will “own everything” - I’ve heard this claptrap from Gary for years. His juvenile and shallow contentions aim at the wrong target; the only issue that matters is successive governments persistent rationing of housebuilding. Houses have essentially become a luxury good. That is not the fault of the super rich, it’s the fault of 50 years poor governance.
A Wealth Tax will do NOTHING to increase access to affordable housing or any other assets. All it Will do s reduce investment - probably including investment in housing development.
If you really want to understand Gary’s motivation look at how much he’s grifting from Patreon alone - largely from those who can’t afford it. He has no practical solutions, his contentions on inequality are simply wrong all of which make him part of the problem in my book.
Posts: 293
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
If growth is 2% and the super rich grow wealth/assets by 10% then how can they not be aggressivly aquiring assets, that is simple maths. Gary is a protester and a populist who offers simple solutions to complex problems - this does not mean the problem does not exist. Zucman offers a workable solution. I also agree that a LVT will be a driver to growth and development and poor governance is a massive factor.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Economic growth and asset growth are two very different things. An example is my own pensions have grown at around 12% in the last year, my cash based investments have grown at about 5% - I'm not super rich.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(08-05-2026, 07:48 AM)petty sniper Wrote: If growth is 2% and the super rich grow wealth/assets by 10% then how can they not be aggressivly aquiring assets, that is simple maths. Gary is a protester and a populist who offers simple solutions to complex problems - this does not mean the problem does not exist. Zucman offers a workable solution. I also agree that a LVT will be a driver to growth and development and poor governance is a massive factor.
It’s not simple maths at all. Even a modest balanced portfolio should have achieved 8% growth in the last year. That does not mean you own “more” of an asset - it’s simply grown in value. Which of course brings up another problem - wealth comprises largely unrealised gains. Can taxpayers expect a rebate for realised or even unrealised losses?
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
That is exactly one of the points that i have made in the past on here. The practicality of implementing the wealth tax is near on impossible.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
08-05-2026, 01:30 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-05-2026, 01:30 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
Arf middle class posters that are clearly comfortably off, talking about their portfolios of investments. May I suggest they may be a tad out of touch with the reality for many in society.
The idea that billionaires aren’t the problem, when it’s clear that many influence politics around the globe fit their benefit, no one else’s. Shifting work forces from one country to the next just to save them and their shareholders money. Influencing elections, being in control or influence over energy, water, transport and housing etc.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Once again Dekka you just make a statement with no substance in it, you are the archetypal protest voter. PS combined the concept of a country's economic growth with that of investments, they are two very different concepts, I gave an example of the difference as I understand it, if I'm wrong point it out. If you think that anybody with a pension is out of touch then you have just grouped three quarters of the adult population into that group.
You constantly call me condescending because I talk to you in a certain way. That way is brought about by you just shouting slogans without substance from the sidelines and mocking people who ae pointing out inconvenient facts to your theories.
And I don't think anyone would disagree with your protest commentary however the debate here is how to tax it. I'll ask for the umpteenth time, do you have a real solution to this problem or are you just gluing yourself to the road here?
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(08-05-2026, 01:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Arf middle class posters that are clearly comfortably off, talking about their portfolios of investments. May I suggest they may be a tad out of touch with the reality for many in society.
The idea that billionaires aren’t the problem, when it’s clear that many influence politics around the globe fit their benefit, no one else’s. Shifting work forces from one country to the next just to save them and their shareholders money. Influencing elections, being in control or influence over energy, water, transport and housing etc.
But you’re not talking about billionaires. You’re talking about people with more than £10 million in “wealth”.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(08-05-2026, 04:13 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (08-05-2026, 01:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Arf middle class posters that are clearly comfortably off, talking about their portfolios of investments. May I suggest they may be a tad out of touch with the reality for many in society.
The idea that billionaires aren’t the problem, when it’s clear that many influence politics around the globe fit their benefit, no one else’s. Shifting work forces from one country to the next just to save them and their shareholders money. Influencing elections, being in control or influence over energy, water, transport and housing etc.
But you’re not talking about billionaires. You’re talking about people with more than £10 million in “wealth”.
If I had ‘wealth’ of over £10m I’d happily pay more tax. No one lives in a bubble, no one gets where they are without the help and hardwork of hundreds of thousands of others in the background. Be it the roads they use, the education they received, the protection they’ve had or the hard work of others.
You see, I believe there is such a thing as society and that everyone for themselves leads to exactly where this country now finds itself, polarised, angry and unable to offer a place where people collectively are proud to call home. Instead the two main parties have presided over creating ghettos for the poor, leave millions reliant on creaking public service’s, put some of the worst people on pedestals because society is so base now that money ahem Trumps all else.
|