Which Baggies team was better?
#1
Big Dave’s or Slavs? 

Johnstone 
Holgate Dawson Hegazi Gibbs 
Livermore Barry 
Phillips Jay-Rod Barnes 
Gayle 

Vs 

Johnstone 
Furlong Bartley Ajai Townsend 
Krovinovic Sawyers 
Robinson Periera Diangana 
Austin/HRK
Reply
#2
Put it like this, Slav would’ve won the title with a crack at Big Dave’s squad and season
Raw Sausage
Reply
#3
Dave had a better defence and strike force... Slav had MP... My God, how many would J Rod have got with MP setting him up.... if only.
Reply
#4
I don't know if Slav's team was actually better, but it was certainly more enjoyable.
Reply
#5
(08-04-2026, 11:03 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't know if Slav's team was actually better, but it was certainly more enjoyable.

It's going take some serious increase in play style and verve to ever hit the heights that Slav gave (even if it only lasted up until Covid), most enjoyable football I've ever seen us play...
Reply
#6
Yep, that season before COVID closed it down was probably amongst my favourites. It was a joy.
Reply
#7
When Moore had Barnes, his side was better IMO and had we kept him for the full season we’d have made the autos.

Slav’s team had more balance.
Reply
#8
(08-04-2026, 11:11 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(08-04-2026, 11:03 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't know if Slav's team was actually better, but it was certainly more enjoyable.

It's going take some serious increase in play style and verve to ever hit the heights that Slav gave (even if it only lasted up until Covid), most enjoyable football I've ever seen us play...

I agree with this. 

Especially with how Slav picked us up from play off defeat the season before and injected fresh blood with Periera, Krovi, Ferguson, Furlong, Austin, etc….

But that front 3 of Gayle, Jay Rod and Barnes for half a season was outrageous. We should have comfortably been promoted that year and when we beat Villa easily at Villa park in the February, I was adamant we would be.
Reply
#9
Big Dave had the better team
Slav was the better manager
Reply
#10
What I wouldn't have given to have had Carlos in charge of either of those sides. We'd be looking at Championship record points totals.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: