Unsurprising revelations...
#41
Nope, it's not down to how hospices are funded, and no the proportion of state funding has not been increasing year on year.

You're conflating much bigger state failure issues to suit your argument. So, maybe you can tell me:

"So what would you cut to increase the grant to hospices? Or what taxes would you increase on whom? And how would this directly translate into additional cash for hospices rather than say, welfare or defence?"

Andy will have the answers if you don't, I'm sure.
Reply
#42
I'm not conflating anything. The proportion of funding has risen from 2012 to 2024 to 30% across both children and adult hospices, driven by funding to children hospices. And the notion that a lack of funding (corroborated by the funding shortfall analysis) doesn't contribute to the lack of capacity in hospices is laughable quite frankly, it absolutely contributes to the bed blocking issue. Unless you think groups like Hospice UK are lying, and my conversations with people work for Myton hospice.

And what I would do is cut funding for operational hospital care, and reportion that to cover funding in primary and social care - hospices falling under the branch of the latter - as that is what is driving hospital numbers as per multiple independent reports. I'm pretty sure I've mentioned or at least implied that multiple times on here, a.k.a. the Abraham Wald problem.
Reply
#43
The proportion of funding did not "increase year on year" between 2012 - 2024. It fell to near 20% for several years before peaking during Covid (unsurprisngly) then falling again. It's up from 27% to 30% over the whole period.

Of course a lack of funding doesn't help alleviate bed blocking - as I know only too well from Mrs P's mother's awful death in hospital. However you need to look at that in the context of a multiplicity of issues in the useless NHS, coupled with both societal changes that mean less kids look after their parents and many more do so at huge costs to themselves.

This isn't directed at you, but I find the attitude on this board incredible at times. The NHS is an absolute shambles and bottomless pit, yet some dismiss and belittle the efforts of voluntary individuals and groups to keep one of the best things in our country going, and keep it independent - and would prefer for it to become state provided. I find that bewildering.
Reply
#44
Proth ignoring the association that supports hospices and the CEO of a hospice when they say they need state support for stability and sustainable. Good to see that facts aren’t needed anymore… keeping up the grand traditions of ‘we’ve had enough of experts’ Brexiteer shite he’s peddled for years.
Reply
#45
(07-20-2026, 11:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Proth ignoring the association that supports hospices and the CEO of a hospice when they say they need state support for stability and sustainable. Good to see that facts aren’t needed anymore… keeping up the grand traditions of ‘we’ve had enough of experts’ Brexiteer shite he’s peddled for years.

Like I said earlier Dekka. Hospices are under THE SAME pressures as every other branch of healthcare provision.

As you couldn't be arsed last time:

"So what would you cut to increase the grant to hospices? Or what taxes would you increase on whom? And how would this directly translate into additional cash for hospices rather than say, welfare or defence?"
Reply
#46
(07-20-2026, 11:15 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2026, 11:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Proth ignoring the association that supports hospices and the CEO of a hospice when they say they need state support for stability and sustainable. Good to see that facts aren’t needed anymore… keeping up the grand traditions of ‘we’ve had enough of experts’ Brexiteer shite he’s peddled for years.

Like I said earlier Dekka. Hospices are under THE SAME pressures as every other branch of healthcare provision.

As you couldn't be arsed last time:

"So what would you cut to increase the grant to hospices? Or what taxes would you increase on whom? And how would this directly translate into additional cash for hospices rather than say, welfare or defence?"

No you said hospices didn’t need money from the state, I pointed out they do and you do the classic… but, but, but, what would you do argument when you’ve ran out of wriggle room.
Reply
#47
(07-20-2026, 11:21 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: No you said hospices didn’t need money from the state, I pointed out they do and you do the classic… 

The only "classic" is you never having any answer on where this additional money may come from.

Personally I think hospices ought to pull out all of the stops to ensure they retain their independence, and continue to rely on individuals and organisations for the majority of their funding - as has always been the case. I do my bit after the superb care my parents received at Marie Curie.
Reply
#48
(07-20-2026, 11:33 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2026, 11:21 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: No you said hospices didn’t need money from the state, I pointed out they do and you do the classic… 

The only "classic" is you never having any answer on where this additional money may come from.

Personally I think hospices ought to pull out all of the stops to ensure they retain their independence, and continue to rely on individuals and organisations for the majority of their funding - as has always been the case. I do my bit after the superb care my parents received at Marie Curie.

Your personal opinion is not supported by those working in the sector, so I would suggest you’re wrong.
Reply
#49
(07-20-2026, 12:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Your personal opinion is not supported by those working in the sector, so I would suggest you’re wrong.

Hmm. Having not been able to name a single hospice that had closed after claiming "hospices are closing" earlier on the thread, would you like to name a single hospice leader calling for state control of hospices?

I'll wait.

If you're saying that hospice leaders are lobbying for more funding, well duh - that's good marketing for donations and the voluntary buildings and maintenance project I was involved in the other week. I'll pick you up next time if you like, though I'm not sure I'd trust you to hold the ladder.
Reply
#50
(07-20-2026, 12:47 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2026, 12:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Your personal opinion is not supported by those working in the sector, so I would suggest you’re wrong.

Hmm. Having not been able to name a single hospice that had closed after claiming "hospices are closing" earlier on the thread, would you like to name a single hospice leader calling for state control of hospices? 

I'll wait.

If you're saying that hospice leaders are lobbying for more funding, well duh - that's good marketing for donations and the voluntary buildings and maintenance project I was involved in the other week. I'll pick you up next time if you like, though I'm not sure I'd trust you to hold the ladder.

So you’re now arguing that the hundreds of beds lost and the deficit that hospices are facing is just for marketing  and lobbying reasons. According to Proth this is just ‘marketing’

Btw just like your ‘look at me, I do things for charity’ boasting is an akin to when you posted the plate of food during Eat Out to Help Out. I imagine when you’re up that ladder, you would insist on a photographer following you.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: