Big keepers/small keepers
#21
The popular opinion seems to be that Pickford should have saved the first because, as Jude mouthed in our beloved accent, “it’s the middle of the goal”.

It’s a fair reaction in the heat of the moment but Pickford’s line of sight and consequently, his positioning, was compromised by a line of at least three England players. Argentina had four players outside of the box in attacking positions: Messi (on the ball), De Paul (supporting), Fernandez (central) and Alvarez (left). Spence picked up Messi, Anderson covered Fernandez but got dragged to support Spence in case of a pass to De Paul who could cross first time or feed Messi through to the byline. This opened up tonnes of space for Fernandez and by the time the ball got to him, it was too late for any of ours to react, despite Jude’s best efforts. Had Fernandez passed to Alvarez, he too would have got a shot off. It’s a case of poor defensive shape.

If Anderson held his position, someone else supported Spence on Messi/De Paul and another picked up Alvarez, we’d have had two fewer players in that crowded area - the shot doesn’t get through and even if it does, Pickford has a better line of sight to save it.

Pickford’s been immense for us and I can only remember a very small handful of goals conceded where he was at fault.
He’s gorra gew, Franksy!
Reply
#22
The shot was struck extremely well. My blame lies with the outfield players switching off, and failing to close down the shot quickly, rather than Pickford.

As for tipping over the shot prior - yes it's going over, but it's not reasonable to expect Pickford to know that. I'm happy for him to take no chances and tip it over for a corner. Especially given the fact that the chances of the opposition scoring from a corner is extremely low (usually!).

I'm all for bashing English players, but Pickford doesn't deserve any criticism for the first goal.
Reply
#23
Not reasonable to expect a keeper to know that it was going over?
Piss off Big Grin Big Grin
Reply
#24
(07-18-2026, 09:55 AM)KRO Wrote: Not reasonable to expect a keeper to know that it was going over?
Piss off Big Grin Big Grin

Stop acting like it was going well over. It was close. It's easy to judge a slow mo replay and say 'that's going over', when you're facing it, the ball is travelling quickly, and you have a split second to make a decision, it's not so black and white. 

To criticise Pickford for making that choice is utter nonsense. I'm happy for my GKs to tip a shot over if they're not 100% confident it's going over.
Reply
#25
I thought Pickford was one of our better players over the tournament, and he's never really impressed me before. Being a bit harsh on him, and it probably is because he looks relatively small.
Reply
#26
Not a big Pickford fan but rarely let England down until this tournament, the problem I have are Henderson or Trafford better.
Trafford could be in a couple of years of regular 1st team football. But Henderson never will be for me.
Reply
#27
Pickford has been England’s #1 for the best part of a decade now, and throughout most of that time he’s been absolutely fine. Has rarely cost us in the past and before this World Cup has rarely let us down. This World Cup he has been shakey to say the least.

The bigger issue has been the complete lack of competition for him over the last few years, he has the gloves because there’s literally nobody else to challenge him.

Would be interested to see what Trafford could do with regular football somewhere.
Reply
#28
(07-18-2026, 10:01 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(07-18-2026, 09:55 AM)KRO Wrote: Not reasonable to expect a keeper to know that it was going over?
Piss off Big Grin Big Grin

Stop acting like it was going well over. It was close. It's easy to judge a slow mo replay and say 'that's going over', when you're facing it, the ball is travelling quickly, and you have a split second to make a decision, it's not so black and white. 

To criticise Pickford for making that choice is utter nonsense. I'm happy for my GKs to tip a shot over if they're not 100% confident it's going over.

Watching live I thought it might be hitting the bar, after that it could go anywhere... So yep, keeper should tip it over for sure.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)