Tuchel
(07-16-2026, 02:25 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I haven't calmed down at all after last night. The Italy loss was much more gut wrenching, but last night was by far the bigger failure. For 60 minutes, we competed, kept in the game, scored a good goal and defended more than well enough. We didn't rise to their shithousery, and we were actually pretty street-wise.

Obviously Argentina were going to up the ante once we scored, and Tuchel got shit scared and completely fucked it up. The only way you can try and deal with Messi is to deny the ball to him. So what do we do? Camp the box, put loads of defenders on, ruined the defensive structure and LET THE GREATEST PLAYER EVER HAVE THE BALL IN ACRES OF SPACE. What fucking bullshit tactic was that?

Rice was knackered, so take him off, fine. But replace him with a midfielder with legs. If you don't trust Mainoo, then put Saka/Madueke on the wing, Rogers into 10 and Jude back in CM. Not ideal, but you've got a much better foothold in midfield, and Anderson, Jude and Rogers can all press and hary their ball carriers in the middle, and the two wingers can press their wing players and support the full backs.
Kane was knackered, so replace him with Watkins who would've run the rest of the game, pressed the fuck out of them and potentially caused them to make mistakes.
Gordon was playing well, but if you're taking him off, put Rashford on. They were shit scared of the pace of Gordon and Spence, so keep them scared with the pace of Rashford.

None of that is remotely complicated and it was obvious at the time. Tuchel was specifcally brought in to not do what Southgate did, and when it mattered the most, he was even worse.

And for all the talk of "semi-finals is great". That might apply to 2018 when we had only made 2 semi finals in 52 years. We've made 4 semis in the last 8 years, we need to be making that count and we haven't. Tuchel was brought in to win the World Cup and he shat the bed when it mattered most. He failed his remit. He has to go.

This is a good post.
Reply
He basically tried to defend for 45 mins including injury time. With a defence that has been shakey all tournament except for 45 mins v Mexico.
Reply
We aren’t good enough to win it. We are good enough to get to the semi-finals but beyond that I’m not buying the argument ‘we just need a better manager/tactics’. Top four yes, number one in the world? Not a chance.
Reply
(07-16-2026, 06:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We aren’t good enough to win it. We are good enough to get to the semi-finals but beyond that I’m not buying the argument ‘we just need a better manager/tactics’. Top four yes, number one in the world? Not a chance.

Totally agree!
Reply
(07-16-2026, 06:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We aren’t good enough to win it. We are good enough to get to the semi-finals but beyond that I’m not buying the argument ‘we just need a better manager/tactics’. Top four yes, number one in the world? Not a chance.

I think it's the manner we went out. Most people can accept we might well get beat by a team higher in the rankings. The last half hour disaster wasn't acceptable.
Reply
(07-16-2026, 06:59 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(07-16-2026, 06:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We aren’t good enough to win it. We are good enough to get to the semi-finals but beyond that I’m not buying the argument ‘we just need a better manager/tactics’. Top four yes, number one in the world? Not a chance.

I think it's the manner we went out. Most people can accept we might well get beat by a team higher in the rankings. The last half hour disaster wasn't acceptable.

This.

We were winning and playing well - then we imploded and it was completely self inflicted.
Reply
Last night showed we are unquestionably the weakest of the 4 teams in the semi final.
I can understand the anger directed towards Tuchel but he’s still done decent work to get us that far. He will have to lick his wounds after this and perhaps reflect on the squad and how he handled the game in those last 25 or so minutes.
However, Argentina are world champions for a reason and Spain are on a crazy 36 match unbeaten streak.
We are well behind both of them and depending on how the 3rd place playoff goes competition wise, we’re not in France’s quality either.
That’s why I’m more benevolent about the loss.
Reply
(07-16-2026, 06:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We aren’t good enough to win it. We are good enough to get to the semi-finals but beyond that I’m not buying the argument ‘we just need a better manager/tactics’. Top four yes, number one in the world? Not a chance.

This..maybe 3rd after the bronze final with France..what a waste of time.
Reply
(07-16-2026, 06:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We aren’t good enough to win it. We are good enough to get to the semi-finals but beyond that I’m not buying the argument ‘we just need a better manager/tactics’. Top four yes, number one in the world? Not a chance.

I know it's a big if, but I really think IF England had of made it to the final, it was 50:50 in terms of a match against Spain.  However thanks to Tuchel's bizarre retreat, well commented on in this thread, we will never find out which is a real shame.
Reply
This “we were never good enough” line is more than a little revisionist if you ask me.

We were comfortably the equals of Argentina for 60 minutes last night. We matched them in terms of physicality and workrate and neither keeper had a save of any note to make before we scored.

We were good enough until we imploded, that’s why it stings so much.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: