Tielemans
#11
(07-15-2026, 07:31 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(07-15-2026, 07:27 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: Villa have done tremendous business there tbf. Bring a player in on a free, have 3 or so years of him at his peak and then move him on for a very healthy profit. As annoying as it is, their transfer dealings in recent years have by and large been very well managed and successful.

Irogbuenam to Everton for £9m was patently FFP Fraud.
Of course it was with Dobbin going the opposite way for the same fictional figure. If the rules are able to be manipulated in that way then why not do it? It’s not cheating, it’s just highlighting what a nonsense the system is.
Reply
#12
(07-15-2026, 07:41 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(07-15-2026, 07:31 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(07-15-2026, 07:27 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: Villa have done tremendous business there tbf. Bring a player in on a free, have 3 or so years of him at his peak and then move him on for a very healthy profit. As annoying as it is, their transfer dealings in recent years have by and large been very well managed and successful.

Irogbuenam to Everton for £9m was patently FFP Fraud.
Of course it was with Dobbin going the opposite way for the same fictional figure. If the rules are able to be manipulated in that way then why not do it? It’s not cheating, it’s just highlighting what a nonsense the system is.

Both of you are correct.

But with Dobbin just being transferred for £9m and Ireogbunum playing regularly for Everton last season, would be difficult to prove.
Reply
#13
(07-15-2026, 07:39 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-15-2026, 07:27 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: Villa have done tremendous business there tbf. Bring a player in on a free, have 3 or so years of him at his peak and then move him on for a very healthy profit. As annoying as it is, their transfer dealings in recent years have by and large been very well managed and successful.

Actually they haven't. 

Last season they relied too much on players who pre dated the Emery era.

Martinez,  Digne, Konsa, Kamara, McGinn, Watkins were all key cogs of Villa's team last season, all pre date Emery. And they have bought a lot of players in Emery's time at the club, and a lot of those have just not cut the mustard.

Tielemans has been a successful transfer, but successfully replacing him will probably cost them more than the money they received for him.

There's no doubt Emery is a fantastic coach, but Villa's recent transfer dealings have been sketchy at best, their squad is ageing and their wage bill is too high for a club of their resources.

They've done a very good job at selling at the right time, and extracting huge fees for them in fairness to the fishy f**kers. 

Emery's coaching has ensured they've managed to get performances out of players above their normal capabilities... banking 80M for Duran, 50M for Luiz for example and neither player has really done anything since departing.
Reply
#14
(07-15-2026, 07:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-15-2026, 07:39 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-15-2026, 07:27 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: Villa have done tremendous business there tbf. Bring a player in on a free, have 3 or so years of him at his peak and then move him on for a very healthy profit. As annoying as it is, their transfer dealings in recent years have by and large been very well managed and successful.

Actually they haven't. 

Last season they relied too much on players who pre dated the Emery era.

Martinez,  Digne, Konsa, Kamara, McGinn, Watkins were all key cogs of Villa's team last season, all pre date Emery. And they have bought a lot of players in Emery's time at the club, and a lot of those have just not cut the mustard.

Tielemans has been a successful transfer, but successfully replacing him will probably cost them more than the money they received for him.

There's no doubt Emery is a fantastic coach, but Villa's recent transfer dealings have been sketchy at best, their squad is ageing and their wage bill is too high for a club of their resources.

They've done a very good job at selling at the right time, and extracting huge fees for them in fairness to the fishy f**kers. 

Emery's coaching has ensured they've managed to get performances out of players above their normal capabilities... banking 80M for Duran, 50M for Luiz for example and neither player has really done anything since departing.

Plus in the region of £100m for the Ramsey brothers, Philogene and Archer. That’s not a bad return for players who cost them nothing.

Whilst it is fair to say that their squad is ageing and will need a restructure soon, at least those players have got them on to the Champions League gravy train to provide a whole lot of income to help finance what they need to do.
Reply
#15
(07-15-2026, 08:03 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(07-15-2026, 07:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-15-2026, 07:39 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-15-2026, 07:27 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: Villa have done tremendous business there tbf. Bring a player in on a free, have 3 or so years of him at his peak and then move him on for a very healthy profit. As annoying as it is, their transfer dealings in recent years have by and large been very well managed and successful.

Actually they haven't. 

Last season they relied too much on players who pre dated the Emery era.

Martinez,  Digne, Konsa, Kamara, McGinn, Watkins were all key cogs of Villa's team last season, all pre date Emery. And they have bought a lot of players in Emery's time at the club, and a lot of those have just not cut the mustard.

Tielemans has been a successful transfer, but successfully replacing him will probably cost them more than the money they received for him.

There's no doubt Emery is a fantastic coach, but Villa's recent transfer dealings have been sketchy at best, their squad is ageing and their wage bill is too high for a club of their resources.

They've done a very good job at selling at the right time, and extracting huge fees for them in fairness to the fishy f**kers. 

Emery's coaching has ensured they've managed to get performances out of players above their normal capabilities... banking 80M for Duran, 50M for Luiz for example and neither player has really done anything since departing.

Plus in the region of £100m for the Ramsey brothers, Philogene and Archer. That’s not a bad return for players who cost them nothing.

Whilst it is fair to say that their squad is ageing and will need a restructure soon, at least those players have got them on to the Champions League gravy train to provide a whole lot of income to help finance what they need to do.

Yup - Villa under Emery have shades of Klopp, in that the system and coaching brings far greater performances than the individuals ought to, hence Liverpool consistently sold players (usually to Bournemouth!) for vastly inflated fees only for them to fail or underperform elsewhere.

I mean Nat Phillips was playing Champs League football under Klopp.
Reply
#16
There's no doubt Emery has been a massive success for Villa.

But there are some definite dark clouds on horizon. No doubt it's an ageing squad. And the way things are going there will be a number of quality players Villa will need to find replacements for, and they probably won't be getting big fees for those players who need replacing. Mcginn, Martinez, Cash, Buendia, Watkins are not going to attract transfer fees big enough to secure replacements of the same quality.

And even if they did, Villa's recent record on signings has not been great. How many players signed in the last 3 seasons were definite first choice picks last season...Tielemans, Torres, Rogers, maybe Onana.

There's a reason why Villa struggled with psr regulations, and I don't think the new rules favour them.

Losing Tielemans s a blow...he went because Man U activated his release clause and he wanted to go. Nor because Villa wanted him to go...unless there's an underlying injury problem Utd haven't picked up on.

Qualifying for the Champions League will be difficult this season, especially for a side like Villa who have European football to contend with, unlike some of their rivals.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)