This is how ludicrous, callous and broken the benefits system is for the disabled
#1
Whilst bellends wang on about what they’ve heard in GP waiting rooms about how easy it is to defraud the system. You see situations like this families linked below, that shows how truly abysmal, adversarial and broken the system is for people who will never work and their families, because they are completely incapable of doing so. The families save the state millions by looking after their loved ones at home, but are treated like shit by people who have zero understanding, empathy or even logic to accept the systems they have created, manage and work within don’t even make sense from a logical perspective, let alone ethical one.

I do wonder what kind of person works in this sector, because by and large they seem at best obsessed with box ticking, at worst actively enjoy making people’s lives a misery and more and more difficult.

As I’ve said multiple times, just remove the need for full time carers and the loved they look after from the current UC and PIP system. It’s obvious who these people are and how they are different from others who could work with the right help and support in place. Constantly assessing them, putting their families through hell in the process costs money, and brings families to breaking point. 

Ludicrous

Oh and to the ableist’s amongst us… I appreciate this is a post about disability.
Reply
#2
100% agree
Reply
#3
Bellends? - you can fuck right off an'all.

The example you have shown is terrible but it is not the system that is at fault here it is the individuals that are managing it (or mismanaging it in this case). There is no part of the rules and regs that would take more than a one off review of this case to show that this one doesn't need any future reviews, and UC (as a minimum) should be ongoing. I would also expect that there should be many more benefits and support that is available in this case.
Reply
#4
(07-09-2026, 10:45 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Bellends? - you can fuck right off an'all.

The example you have shown is terrible but it is not the system that is at fault here it is the individuals that are managing it (or mismanaging it in this case). There is no part of the rules and regs that would take more than a one off review of this case to show that this one doesn't need any future reviews, and UC (as a minimum) should be ongoing. I would also expect that there should be many more benefits and support that is available in this case.

The system is fucked and is festooned with twats (I’m being polite) who make the families like the ones in the news articles lives an absolute misery, with long drawn out battles for every ‘benefit’ they get.

Many aren’t interested in making people’s lives better, they are more concerned with setting up barriers to help, with opaque decision making. 

If you think this is an isolated incident, and that it’s just a few ignorant employees then you need to spend a day with a disability charity or family in a similar situation.

The system is not fit for purpose and if you’re genuinely interested in real reform of welfare, then you’d be in favour of genuine reform, rather than pretend it’s just badly administrated by a handful of rogue managers and employees. Or perhaps your not, and you simply want to cut money without any real change to a system your post suggested is fit for purpose…

Something today’s report highlights… Oh you mean proper reform, not just pretending proposed cuts were genuine reform!
Reply
#5
Have a look at the actual policy and tell me where that treatment of people is caused from that. Those cases, and probably many more, are caused by the recruitment of entry level staff to follow tick box exercises and not exercise any judgement. This comes from outsourcing contracts like these that rely on getting people in cheap to maximise the profit margin. This has happened across the civil services for decades and is why we are where we are - this is little or nothing to do with the actual policies as they are laid out.
Reply
#6
(07-09-2026, 11:14 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Have a look at the actual policy and tell me where that treatment of people is caused from that. Those cases, and probably many more, are caused by the recruitment of entry level staff to follow tick box exercises and not exercise any judgement. This comes from outsourcing contracts like these that rely on getting people in cheap to maximise the profit margin. This has happened across the civil services for decades and is why we are where we are - this is little or nothing to do with the actual policies as they are laid out.

Hi Ian Duncan-Smith
Reply
#7
And the usual Dekka response when cornered into actually doing some research. Pathetic.

As for the system, I'm now on my third adult that I've had to work through the system to find the help needed so you don't need to tell me where the problems lie as I'm dealing with it. Last night I had to explain to a nurse in my MILs care home that we have had it agreed that they can dish out a controlled drug on demand as is prescribed. This is the third time in 4 weeks we have had this discussion and she responded that she couldn't because she might get arrested. That is down to the individual not reading the care notes, not policy or rules, just laziness.

Here you go Dekka, I'll do your work for you:

https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/benefi...ssessment/

There is no way on this planet that this individual can be assessed as being capable for work and would fall under the full amount of UC and other support with a reassessment in 3 years if at all, in this case I would expect no need to be applied. In three years, I would imagine that with nothing likely to change then it'll be thankyou and see you in three years.

The system spells out the rules and how this person should be treated, the individual's involved are to blame for their appalling treatment of this lad.

"Check what happens after the decision

The DWP will usually reassess your LCW or LCWRA in future, unless your health condition or disability is permanent.

They might reassess you every 1, 2 or 3 years. They might also reassess you if you start work - this depends on the type of work you do and the reasons they agreed you have LCW or LCWRA.

If your health condition changes, you should tell the DWP. You might be able to ask for a new assessment."
Reply
#8
(07-09-2026, 11:22 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And the usual Dekka response when cornered into actually doing some research. Pathetic.

As for the system, I'm now on my third adult that I've had to work through the system to find the help needed so you don't need to tell me where the problems lie as I'm dealing with it. Last night I had to explain to a nurse in my MILs care home that we have had it agreed that they can dish out a controlled drug on demand as is prescribed. This is the third time in 4 weeks we have had this discussion and she responded that she couldn't because she might get arrested. That is down to the individual not reading the care notes, not policy or rules, just laziness.

Here you go Dekka, I'll do your work for you:

https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/benefi...ssessment/

There is no way on this planet that this individual can be assessed as being capable for work and would fall under the full amount of UC and other support with a reassessment in 3 years if at all, in this case I would expect no need to be applied. In three years, I would imagine that with nothing likely to change then it'll be thankyou and see you in three years.

The system spells out the rules and how this person should be treated, the individual's involved are to blame for their appalling treatment of this lad.

"Check what happens after the decision

The DWP will usually reassess your LCW or LCWRA in future, unless your health condition or disability is permanent.

They might reassess you every 1, 2 or 3 years. They might also reassess you if you start work - this depends on the type of work you do and the reasons they agreed you have LCW or LCWRA.

If your health condition changes, you should tell the DWP. You might be able to ask for a new assessment."

I haven’t been cornered by anything the system isn’t working, did you design or work for the DWP? Because you sure are trying hard on their behalf to justify it. Whilst nearly every independent expert says isn’t fit for purpose. You can blame individuals, but that is a cop out for a broken system. Just having a rule book and saying things shouldn’t happen, is not addressing the problems that do happen, not just occasionally but all the time to thousands of people.
Reply
#9
(07-09-2026, 09:52 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whilst bellends wang on about what they’ve heard in GP waiting rooms about how easy it is to defraud the system. You see situations like this families linked below, that shows how truly abysmal, adversarial and broken the system is for people who will never work and their families, because they are completely incapable of doing so. The families save the state millions by looking after their loved ones at home, but are treated like shit by people who have zero understanding, empathy or even logic to accept the systems they have created, manage and work within don’t even make sense from a logical perspective, let alone ethical one.

I do wonder what kind of person works in this sector, because by and large they seem at best obsessed with box ticking, at worst actively enjoy making people’s lives a misery and more and more difficult.

As I’ve said multiple times, just remove the need for full time carers and the loved they look after from the current UC and PIP system. It’s obvious who these people are and how they are different from others who could work with the right help and support in place. Constantly assessing them, putting their families through hell in the process costs money, and brings families to breaking point. 

Ludicrous

Oh and to the ableist’s amongst us… I appreciate this is a post about disability.

With respect, it would be better to go to your MP than The Mirror.

But you're right, this also illustrates the nature of our process-obsessed bureaucracy. The difference between the public and private sector is that one of them depends on good outcomes for its survival. The other, does not.
Reply
#10
(07-09-2026, 12:31 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-09-2026, 09:52 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whilst bellends wang on about what they’ve heard in GP waiting rooms about how easy it is to defraud the system. You see situations like this families linked below, that shows how truly abysmal, adversarial and broken the system is for people who will never work and their families, because they are completely incapable of doing so. The families save the state millions by looking after their loved ones at home, but are treated like shit by people who have zero understanding, empathy or even logic to accept the systems they have created, manage and work within don’t even make sense from a logical perspective, let alone ethical one.

I do wonder what kind of person works in this sector, because by and large they seem at best obsessed with box ticking, at worst actively enjoy making people’s lives a misery and more and more difficult.

As I’ve said multiple times, just remove the need for full time carers and the loved they look after from the current UC and PIP system. It’s obvious who these people are and how they are different from others who could work with the right help and support in place. Constantly assessing them, putting their families through hell in the process costs money, and brings families to breaking point. 

Ludicrous

Oh and to the ableist’s amongst us… I appreciate this is a post about disability.

With respect, it would be better to go to your MP than The Mirror.

But you're right, this also illustrates the nature of our process-obsessed bureaucracy. The difference between the public and private sector is that one of them depends on good outcomes for its survival. The other, does not.

Whilst I agree the agree the system is broken, the idea that private sector systems are better given the outsourcing to third party companies who deliver substandard service on behalf of the public sector, does fly in the face of reality. 

Btw the MPs I know who have been asked to help locally (Tory) with this type of thing, are about as helpful as a chocolate teapot at an open air summer fete during a heat wave.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)