Happy Brexit Day
#41
(06-30-2026, 12:03 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: What is your opinion on the Millennium bug? Was that needless?

Oh please go away with your false equivalence.

There was absolutely no need for monetary stimulus after the Brexit vote. Performative counter productive nonsense from Carney - like so much of his tenure.
Reply
#42
It's not a false equivalence. There was loads of prep to avoid cascading problems caused by the Millennium Bug. The cut to interest rates was in direct response to the measured response by the BoE on bank funding cuts post-Brexit vote that needed to be mitigated to smooth the impact to prevent cascading effects on the wider economy, which objectively worked. This is outlined explicitly in the BoE's credit conditions review, which you can read for yourself and look at the measured quantifiable data that underlined that decision.

That was not performative, as much as you want to delude yourself into believing it to be so you can avoid admitting how fucking stupid leaving the EU was and is, and ignore the measures taken to mitigate the impact of said stupid decision.
Reply
#43
(06-30-2026, 12:15 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Start with the first bit Proth - admit the mistake

@Neverwrong
Reply
#44
Proth will never admit he’s wrong about Brexit… there will always be a but.
Reply
#45
(06-30-2026, 12:15 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Start with the first bit Proth - admit the mistake

I have admitted that I was mistaken in my belief that Parliament was capable of statecraft.
Reply
#46
(06-30-2026, 07:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 12:15 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Start with the first bit Proth - admit the mistake

I have admitted that I was mistaken in my belief that Parliament was capable of statecraft.

There was no good deal, we did not hold all the cards, how many fugging times do you want to pretend otherwise? It’s embarrassing.
Reply
#47
The issue with precautionary interventions is that the more successful they are the more the case is made for them being unnecessary in the first place.

That is, were the outcomes due to the intervention working or were the 'fears', for want of a better term, that initiated the measures, exaggerated?
Reply
#48
(06-30-2026, 08:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 07:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 12:15 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Start with the first bit Proth - admit the mistake

I have admitted that I was mistaken in my belief that Parliament was capable of statecraft.

There was no good deal, we did not hold all the cards, how many fugging times do you want to pretend otherwise? It’s embarrassing.

Our membership of the EU was about far more than trade in goods, how any times would you like to pretend otherwise.
Reply
#49
And how exactly were we harmed by being part of it?
Reply
#50
(06-30-2026, 01:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's not a false equivalence. There was loads of prep to avoid cascading problems caused by the Millennium Bug. The cut to interest rates was in direct response to the measured response by the BoE on bank funding cuts post-Brexit vote that needed to be mitigated to smooth the impact to prevent cascading effects on the wider economy, which objectively worked. This is outlined explicitly in the BoE's credit conditions review, which you can read for yourself and look at the measured quantifiable data that underlined that decision.

That was not performative, as much as you want to delude yourself into believing it to be so you can avoid admitting how fucking stupid leaving the EU was and is, and ignore the measures taken to mitigate the impact of said stupid decision.

If you suppress wages for ordinary folk, let the guilty off the hook for financial impropriety and set in train an asset price boom that benefits only the already wealthy then I suspect the public might vote for change.

Hand in glove with the Treasury, our "independent" central bank helped to create the very market conditions that led to the UK leaving the EU. 

So yes, completely performative art. I bet you believe the BoE view that inflation will be down to 2% target again shortly don't you? We have a BoE "economist" as Chancellor. How's that going for us? 

The former Chief Economist at the BoE said “I consider myself moderately financially literate — yet I confess to not being able to make the remotest sense of pensions.”  That makes him an idiot in my book, as pensions are remarkably simple. Guess who's now advising Smart Casual Starmer on things like pensions. Perhaps he should look in the mirror and consider a decade or more of loose monetary policy so distorted market returns that it is still hard to find a chart that isn’t hinting at a bubble.

A healthy scepticism of authority is an exceptionally good character trait in my book. Feel free to swallow the lines of the BoE whose actions have been nothing but disastrous for the young, low paid and asset poor in this country for the thick end of 20 years. I shan't.

Brexit was a consequence of those very institutions.

(06-30-2026, 10:15 PM)baggy1 Wrote: And how exactly were we harmed by being part of it?

I prefer to vote for who governs. But maybe that's just me.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)