Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests
Anderson as bowling coach?

He is still our best bowler and should be playing.
Reply
(06-30-2026, 11:11 AM)yeoman lai Wrote: Anderson as bowling coach?

He is still our best bowler and should be playing.

Yes but that isn't realistic.
Reply
I've been banging on since the Ashes debacle we need Alec Stewart. Everything about him screams professionalism. He has list of honours, titles, promotions and always led by example. Further he will most likely stand up to the ECB regarding their greedy scheduling. Losing in India was no disgrace although some of the prep was suspect, but losing to an understrength Australia was unforgivable and now this is compounded by defeat to a half strength NZ. (Who showed that grit and determination can actually go a long way). The Bazball experiment was a bold approach let down by cronyism and ego.
Reply
(06-30-2026, 11:42 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: I've been banging on since the Ashes debacle we need Alec Stewart. Everything about him screams professionalism. He has list of honours, titles, promotions and always led by example. Further he will most likely stand up to the ECB regarding their greedy scheduling. Losing in India was no disgrace although some of the prep was suspect, but losing to an understrength Australia was unforgivable and now this is compounded by defeat to a half strength NZ. (Who showed that grit and determination can actually go a long way). The Bazball experiment was a bold approach let down by cronyism and ego.

Very good comment, especially the bold
Reply
(06-30-2026, 11:11 AM)yeoman lai Wrote: Anderson as bowling coach?

He is still our best bowler and should be playing.

How is he our best bowler?

Anderson was ace but do his championship figures this season really make him better than Atkinson and Robinson right now?? Surely not.
Reply
Cricket is cyclical, as with any sport, really. We're currently as close to rock bottom as you could get in international cricket.

We'll sack people, bring people in, change things up, and we'll see improvement.

We may well get back to being one of the best, and if/when that happens, it won't last, and we'll find ourselves in a mess and need of another change. Rinse and repeat.
Reply
(06-30-2026, 12:45 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Cricket is cyclical, as with any sport, really. We're currently as close to rock bottom as you could get in international cricket.

We'll sack people, bring people in, change things up, and we'll see improvement.

We may well get back to being one of the best, and if/when that happens, it won't last, and we'll find ourselves in a mess and need of another change. Rinse and repeat.

Whilst agreeing that it's cyclical, I think saying we are as close to rock bottom as could be is an exaggeration. We have dropped to 5th in Test rankings, dropping from 2nd in 2025. We had won 1 in 17 just before McCullum took over in 2022. That was rock bottom stuff.

That's not to say that things are good. It's been a mess this past 12 months and change is required.
Reply
(06-30-2026, 12:36 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 11:11 AM)yeoman lai Wrote: Anderson as bowling coach?

He is still our best bowler and should be playing.

How is he our best bowler?

Anderson was ace but do his championship figures this season really make him better than Atkinson and Robinson right now?? Surely not.

An attempt at humour mate, like saying Bomber should be in our team.  Big Grin
Reply
(06-30-2026, 12:56 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 12:45 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Cricket is cyclical, as with any sport, really. We're currently as close to rock bottom as you could get in international cricket.

We'll sack people, bring people in, change things up, and we'll see improvement.

We may well get back to being one of the best, and if/when that happens, it won't last, and we'll find ourselves in a mess and need of another change. Rinse and repeat.

Whilst agreeing that it's cyclical, I think saying we are as close to rock bottom as could be is an exaggeration. We have dropped to 5th in Test rankings, dropping from 2nd in 2025. We had won 1 in 17  just before McCullum took over in 2022. That was rock bottom stuff.

That's not to say that things are good. It's been a mess this past 12 months and change is required.

That's fair - what I'm trying to get at, however, is that we're pretty poor right now, and in need of a reset, which will come sooner or later. That reset will work, and we'll hopefully get somewhere near to the top, but then it'll go tits up again, at some point. 

I get invested and frustrated with us being poor and on the downward cycle, but I I try to remind myself that it'll only be temporary, and try (and fail) to not let it bother me too much.
Reply
(06-30-2026, 01:57 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 12:56 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(06-30-2026, 12:45 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Cricket is cyclical, as with any sport, really. We're currently as close to rock bottom as you could get in international cricket.

We'll sack people, bring people in, change things up, and we'll see improvement.

We may well get back to being one of the best, and if/when that happens, it won't last, and we'll find ourselves in a mess and need of another change. Rinse and repeat.

Whilst agreeing that it's cyclical, I think saying we are as close to rock bottom as could be is an exaggeration. We have dropped to 5th in Test rankings, dropping from 2nd in 2025. We had won 1 in 17  just before McCullum took over in 2022. That was rock bottom stuff.

That's not to say that things are good. It's been a mess this past 12 months and change is required.

That's fair - what I'm trying to get at, however, is that we're pretty poor right now, and in need of a reset, which will come sooner or later. That reset will work, and we'll hopefully get somewhere near to the top, but then it'll go tits up again, at some point. 

I get invested and frustrated with us being poor and on the downward cycle, but I I try to remind myself that it'll only be temporary, and try (and fail) to not let it bother me too much.

I think we would all agree that the issue isn't so much the lack of success, but the rampant unprofessional-ism and seeming lack of application this England team has portrayed. There is plenty of talent in the team, but they're not applying (or being given the chance to apply it) that talent.

Compare us to the New Zealand team of this series, their application was on another planet, and it's why they won the last two Tests convincingly.

If the England were shite, but tried hard, trained well, and applied themselves, I think we'd be a lot more sanguine about it all.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: