Young people opinion on Social Media
#41
They definitely do adversely target young people. That they also do that (with different content and intent) to older people is neither here nor there
Raw Sausage
Reply
#42
They don't. Most recent internet users in this country are over 75 not under 12 and in the US 90% of over 50s use the internet frequently. The algorithms designed to lock people in and create echo chambers to reinforce opinion effect older people the exact same way as younger people. Things like the Cambridge Analytica scandal were not targeting kids.
Reply
#43
You’re talking about stuff that doesn’t target kids. That doesn’t mean that there isn’t (different) stuff that does.

And yes, I’m well aware of what targets older people, I hear it every time I visit my old man
Raw Sausage
Reply
#44
Borin trying to argue his Internet Explorer years were a riot of debauchery?
Reply
#45
It's all here. It was only a week or so ago ffs sake.
Reply
#46
I’m not really a believer that banning stuff is the solution. But equally the companies allowing access to content that is clearly unsuitable for young people need holding to account the same way other areas of society are or would be if they put kids in harms way. Unfortunately, for now at least, it may be a sledgehammer is needed to crack the nut. Hopefully, in the end, we have a better balance in the middle.

You only have to look at Jacko going after brown and disabled people to see how vulnerable some users are to indoctrination.
Raw Sausage
Reply
#47
Asking the social media companies to make their product less addictive would only lead to something exactly akin to the gambling companies getting around advertising bans with that "Take a pause" nonsense to try and claim that they are being socially responsible. We didn't ask Big Tobacco to make cigarettes less addictive, we instead put in place societal measures to make smoking less attractive. Which btw, was a colossal success and probably the greatest achievement in public health since mass immunisation.

Borin keeps saying "What about the older generation?". That will be coming next. We can't keep having mass social unrest every time someone with skin darker than milk commits a violent crime. It's also a very obvious fact that Facebook and X in particular are massively infiltrated by bot accounts from hostile nations (mostly Russia).
We are now 10 years post Brexit. Those companies have had all that time to clean house. Instead they are worse than ever. Eventually, something will happen and some form of legislation will become necessary. It's just a matter of time.
Reply
#48
(06-18-2026, 08:12 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: You’re talking about stuff that doesn’t target kids. That doesn’t mean that there isn’t (different) stuff that does.

And yes, I’m well aware of what targets older people, I hear it every time I visit my old man

Social media doesn't just target kids. The algorithms that are designed to addict people to social media do not just target kids. The vulnerabilities caused by social media effect older people just as much as younger people. The content being pushed onto kids is as result of the same design that pushes content onto older people, in fact if anything older people are a more captive target as they have better returns for advertisers on a platform and are less likely to adopt new platforms. If harm prevention is your justification for banning under-16s from using social media then any argument that does not result in a total ban is inconsistent quite frankly.

(06-18-2026, 10:21 PM)Squid Wrote: Asking the social media companies to make their product less addictive would only lead to something exactly akin to the gambling companies getting around advertising bans with that "Take a pause" nonsense to try and claim that they are being socially responsible. We didn't ask Big Tobacco to make cigarettes less addictive, we instead put in place societal measures to make smoking less attractive. Which btw, was a colossal success and probably the greatest achievement in public health since mass immunisation.

Borin keeps saying "What about the older generation?". That will be coming next. We can't keep having mass social unrest every time someone with skin darker than milk commits a violent crime. It's also a very obvious fact that Facebook and X in particular are massively infiltrated by bot accounts from hostile nations (mostly Russia).
We are now 10 years post Brexit. Those companies have had all that time to clean house. Instead they are worse than ever. Eventually, something will happen and some form of legislation will become necessary. It's just a matter of time.

You do not ask, you regulate. We did it with tracking cookies. We did it with data retention with Imgur. Though it's good for you to admit you want to ban social media in its entirety for everyone instead of hiding behind the Helen Lovejoy defence, finally being consistent.
Reply
#49
(06-18-2026, 10:50 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-18-2026, 08:12 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: You’re talking about stuff that doesn’t target kids. That doesn’t mean that there isn’t (different) stuff that does.

And yes, I’m well aware of what targets older people, I hear it every time I visit my old man

Social media doesn't just target kids. The algorithms that are designed to addict people to social media do not just target kids. The vulnerabilities caused by social media effect older people just as much as younger people. The content being pushed onto kids is as result of the same design that pushes content onto older people, in fact if anything older people are a more captive target as they have better returns for advertisers on a platform and are less likely to adopt new platforms. If harm prevention is your justification for banning under-16s from using social media then any argument that does not result in a total ban is inconsistent quite frankly.

(06-18-2026, 10:21 PM)Squid Wrote: Asking the social media companies to make their product less addictive would only lead to something exactly akin to the gambling companies getting around advertising bans with that "Take a pause" nonsense to try and claim that they are being socially responsible. We didn't ask Big Tobacco to make cigarettes less addictive, we instead put in place societal measures to make smoking less attractive. Which btw, was a colossal success and probably the greatest achievement in public health since mass immunisation.

Borin keeps saying "What about the older generation?". That will be coming next. We can't keep having mass social unrest every time someone with skin darker than milk commits a violent crime. It's also a very obvious fact that Facebook and X in particular are massively infiltrated by bot accounts from hostile nations (mostly Russia).
We are now 10 years post Brexit. Those companies have had all that time to clean house. Instead they are worse than ever. Eventually, something will happen and some form of legislation will become necessary. It's just a matter of time.

You do not ask, you regulate. We did it with tracking cookies. We did it with data retention with Imgur. Though it's good for you to admit you want to ban social media in its entirety for everyone instead of hiding behind the Helen Lovejoy defence, finally being consistent.

I said legislation is inevitable. Not a total ban.

Also, making an action only available to those mature enough to use it, is a very common form of regulation. By your argument, as older people also have issues consuming alcohol safely, there's no point to banning under 18s from purchasing alcohol. Ditto gambling. Ditto the age of consent. Or maybe you disagree with those pieces of legislation too.

It is not being "Helen Lovejoy" to think that children and young people are a category of society who are worthy of protection. Hence the three P's of the UNCRC Convention on the Rights of the Child being Provision, Participation and Protection.
Reply
#50
Social media does not have physiological effects on development like drugs and alcohol do, I very much support much stricter regulations on gambling advertising for all ages due to its addictive effects on both younger and older people and laws and regulations on what constitutes consent do not just apply to under 16s, even that is contextual e.g. a 15 year old and 16 year olds in a relationship, people older than the 16 not being able to give consent etc.

I have stated very clearly that I do not believe that children are adversely effected by social media than older people. I have stated very clearly the exact regulation I want to be brought in. I've stated very clearly that children are going to use it anyway as do the vast majority of people. I've stated very clearly that this is reinforced by evidence coming out of Australia where it looks to have failed to achieve anything. I have stated very clearly that the routes that people will use to get around this will put them in more vulnerable positions. Nobody has addressed any of those points on here, so why would I bother to change my opinion. Do you and everyone else on here support children's private data being harvested by the methods that will be using to circumvent this? I don't believe you do, what I do believe is that you haven't seriously thought of it as an issue for whatever reason but they're already using free VPNs in Australia to get around this and the reasons why they're free.

As a result, my position is always going to be that advocates for a ban on children getting access should be consistent and call for a total ban if they want to protect children as otherwise it fails to address the equivalent harms on older people or the significant issues, even more problematic, of children's data privacy.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)