Young people opinion on Social Media
#31
(06-16-2026, 08:12 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Kids like the internet. The internet is fun. Therefore Dekka no likey. Pretty standard really.

In all seriousness, if it prevents one vulnerable child with fuckwit parents being groomed into killing themselves then it's worth it. How you doing this I've no idea.

You’re saying those parents who have lost their child to suicide are ‘fuckwits’?
Reply
#32
(06-16-2026, 08:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-16-2026, 08:12 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Kids like the internet. The internet is fun. Therefore Dekka no likey. Pretty standard really.

In all seriousness, if it prevents one vulnerable child with fuckwit parents being groomed into killing themselves then it's worth it. How you doing this I've no idea.

You’re saying those parents who have lost their child to suicide are ‘fuckwits’?

If you're a lazy enough parent to allow a child to have a completely free run of the internet that you pay for then yeah, probably a bit of an idiot. Same as those demanding that schools teach their kids who to brush their teeth or potty train them.
Reply
#33
(06-17-2026, 05:30 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(06-16-2026, 08:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-16-2026, 08:12 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Kids like the internet. The internet is fun. Therefore Dekka no likey. Pretty standard really.

In all seriousness, if it prevents one vulnerable child with fuckwit parents being groomed into killing themselves then it's worth it. How you doing this I've no idea.

You’re saying those parents who have lost their child to suicide are ‘fuckwits’?

If you're a lazy enough parent to allow a child to have a completely free run of the internet that you pay for then yeah, probably a bit of an idiot. Same as those demanding that schools teach their kids who to brush their teeth or potty train them.

Hang on, on the one hand we have middle aged blokes, who grew up with dial up internet connections saying young people will get around the restrictions and it’s not as bad as the 1990s, and 2000s (paha), but we have similar middle aged blokes saying it’s the parents fault that some young people spiral down the rabbit hole having got around restrictions, if they were even there in the first place. Despite the fact platforms and dodgy states are deliberately making their platforms addictive, allowing extreme views and bad actors.

Not quite the same as someone not knowing how to brush their teeth.
Reply
#34
"It is easier to regulate who gets in than to regulate what the platforms are allowed to do once people are there"
National Scot article was interesting. Won't link it as paywall
Reply
#35
I think the rise of the mobile phone has made comparisons to the internet of yore obsolete. Also, sites like 4chan, Something Awful and Rotten.com weren't purposely designed to keep you endlessly scrolling for hours. Social media very much is. None of the current social media sites were thrown together, they are designed to keep you scrolling and clicking. Their purpose is to be addictive and that addiction is clearly having a very negative impact on young people. Do we really think there's zero link between unfettered access to the internet and soaring rates of CAMHS referrals?

The other issue is the way that algorithms are designed to work, so that if you just click on one video about a topic, that's your feed now, 24/7. Maybe not so bad if it's knitting patterns, but considering all these very wealthy companies have woeful content moderation, it's meant some children have been able to watch content promoting eating disorders and self-harm, with very little way of turning that off. If that weren't dangerous enough, we now have AI. What we need is legislation akin to that of cookies, where all AI generated content is clearly labelled as such, but we don't.

I agree that far too many parents are far too lax about what their children get up to online, they seem to see it as akin to having a secret diary or chatting with friends. It really isn't. So yes, when parents can't protect children, the State steps in. It may not be perfect, but it's better than the current situation. For all the older people reading this, I'm sure not a single one of you wishes that social media existed when you were a teenager.
Reply
#36
(06-17-2026, 07:08 PM)Squid Wrote: I think the rise of the mobile phone has made comparisons to the internet of yore obsolete. Also, sites like 4chan, Something Awful and Rotten.com weren't purposely designed to keep you endlessly scrolling for hours. Social media very much is. None of the current social media sites were thrown together, they are designed to keep you scrolling and clicking. Their purpose is to be addictive and that addiction is clearly having a very negative impact on young people. Do we really think there's zero link between unfettered access to the internet and soaring rates of CAMHS referrals?

The other issue is the way that algorithms are designed to work, so that if you just click on one video about a topic, that's your feed now, 24/7. Maybe not so bad if it's knitting patterns, but considering all these very wealthy companies have woeful content moderation, it's meant some children have been able to watch content promoting eating disorders and self-harm, with very little way of turning that off. If that weren't dangerous enough, we now have AI. What we need is legislation akin to that of cookies, where all AI generated content is clearly labelled as such, but we don't.

I agree that far too many parents are far too lax about what their children get up to online, they seem to see it as akin to having a secret diary or chatting with friends. It really isn't. So yes, when parents can't protect children, the State steps in. It may not be perfect, but it's better than the current situation. For all the older people reading this, I'm sure not a single one of you wishes that social media existed when you were a teenager.

I can’t reply Squid, I’m waiting for AOL to start up…I might use my Blackberry instead.
Reply
#37
(06-17-2026, 07:08 PM)Squid Wrote: I think the rise of the mobile phone has made comparisons to the internet of yore obsolete. Also, sites like 4chan, Something Awful and Rotten.com weren't purposely designed to keep you endlessly scrolling for hours. Social media very much is. None of the current social media sites were thrown together, they are designed to keep you scrolling and clicking. Their purpose is to be addictive and that addiction is clearly having a very negative impact on young people. Do we really think there's zero link between unfettered access to the internet and soaring rates of CAMHS referrals?

The other issue is the way that algorithms are designed to work, so that if you just click on one video about a topic, that's your feed now, 24/7. Maybe not so bad if it's knitting patterns, but considering all these very wealthy companies have woeful content moderation, it's meant some children have been able to watch content promoting eating disorders and self-harm, with very little way of turning that off. If that weren't dangerous enough, we now have AI. What we need is legislation akin to that of cookies, where all AI generated content is clearly labelled as such, but we don't.

I agree that far too many parents are far too lax about what their children get up to online, they seem to see it as akin to having a secret diary or chatting with friends. It really isn't. So yes, when parents can't protect children, the State steps in. It may not be perfect, but it's better than the current situation. For all the older people reading this, I'm sure not a single one of you wishes that social media existed when you were a teenager.

Great post squid. The internet and social media in particular is undoubtedly a more insidious and damaging place than it was in the 90s and era shortly after. It’s endemic now, it was an accessory then.

Overall, having seen first hand the impact it’s had on young people for years now, I’m in favour of the ban as the #LeastWorst option
Raw Sausage
Reply
#38
(06-17-2026, 07:08 PM)Squid Wrote: I think the rise of the mobile phone has made comparisons to the internet of yore obsolete. Also, sites like 4chan, Something Awful and Rotten.com weren't purposely designed to keep you endlessly scrolling for hours. Social media very much is. None of the current social media sites were thrown together, they are designed to keep you scrolling and clicking. Their purpose is to be addictive and that addiction is clearly having a very negative impact on young people. Do we really think there's zero link between unfettered access to the internet and soaring rates of CAMHS referrals?

The other issue is the way that algorithms are designed to work, so that if you just click on one video about a topic, that's your feed now, 24/7. Maybe not so bad if it's knitting patterns, but considering all these very wealthy companies have woeful content moderation, it's meant some children have been able to watch content promoting eating disorders and self-harm, with very little way of turning that off. If that weren't dangerous enough, we now have AI. What we need is legislation akin to that of cookies, where all AI generated content is clearly labelled as such, but we don't.

I agree that far too many parents are far too lax about what their children get up to online, they seem to see it as akin to having a secret diary or chatting with friends. It really isn't. So yes, when parents can't protect children, the State steps in. It may not be perfect, but it's better than the current situation. For all the older people reading this, I'm sure not a single one of you wishes that social media existed when you were a teenager.

Yes, they do. But ultimately that does not uniquely or adversely effect young people. So instead of dealing with the addictive nature of algorithms and enforcing opt-out chronological feeds we have instead decided to implement a policy that is as robust as a fishing net with a giant hole in it that will not work, cut off information and resource sharing and risk private data being exposed by people who inevitably will bypass it. That is not a solution to the problem, this is pandering to sensibilities and special interests to avoid a proper solution while pretending they're doing something.
Reply
#39
(06-18-2026, 11:09 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-17-2026, 07:08 PM)Squid Wrote: I think the rise of the mobile phone has made comparisons to the internet of yore obsolete. Also, sites like 4chan, Something Awful and Rotten.com weren't purposely designed to keep you endlessly scrolling for hours. Social media very much is. None of the current social media sites were thrown together, they are designed to keep you scrolling and clicking. Their purpose is to be addictive and that addiction is clearly having a very negative impact on young people. Do we really think there's zero link between unfettered access to the internet and soaring rates of CAMHS referrals?

The other issue is the way that algorithms are designed to work, so that if you just click on one video about a topic, that's your feed now, 24/7. Maybe not so bad if it's knitting patterns, but considering all these very wealthy companies have woeful content moderation, it's meant some children have been able to watch content promoting eating disorders and self-harm, with very little way of turning that off. If that weren't dangerous enough, we now have AI. What we need is legislation akin to that of cookies, where all AI generated content is clearly labelled as such, but we don't.

I agree that far too many parents are far too lax about what their children get up to online, they seem to see it as akin to having a secret diary or chatting with friends. It really isn't. So yes, when parents can't protect children, the State steps in. It may not be perfect, but it's better than the current situation. For all the older people reading this, I'm sure not a single one of you wishes that social media existed when you were a teenager.

Yes, they do. But ultimately that does not uniquely or adversely effect young people. So instead of dealing with the addictive nature of algorithms and enforcing opt-out chronological feeds we have instead decided to implement a policy that is as robust as a fishing net with a giant hole in it that will not work, cut off information and resource sharing and risk private data being exposed by people who inevitably will bypass it. That is not a solution to the problem, this is pandering to sensibilities and special interests to avoid a proper solution while pretending they're doing something.

I would disagree that targeted algorithms do not adversely affect young people, I think they absolutely do.
Your major issue seems to be that children will bypass the policy. However, policies have impact on different levels and perfect is often the enemy of good. A major impact this policy has is stating categorically that social media is harmful for young people. That's an important public health message. The nature of the social media ban means it will have a very wide reach. Making mobile phones less appealing/addictive to children will also be beneficial.

What would you consider to be a proper solution?
Reply
#40
They absolutely do not adversely target young people, I wholly reject that premise. You need only look at the numbers of older people who have fallen into rabbit holes on social media. It's equally harmful to older people than it is younger people.

And my major contention is that this will not work, early reports from Australia are indicating it's failing (70% of parents knowing their kids still use social media their post-ban and that's only the parents that know) and the measures that are being used to bypass it are putting kids at greater risk either by going to sites that refuse to follow the law or by using dodgy services that expose their data.

I've also been talking about the solution, opt-out default to chronological feeds which renders feed algorithms null. That and parents showing some parental responsibility over access to tech.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: