Ben Stokes
#51
(06-11-2026, 08:45 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-11-2026, 07:28 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: It genuinely amazes me people can't grasp the problem with what happened. So let's flip it a bit.

You've fucked up at work. Your employer gives you a verbal warning.
You manage to fuck up again in the same way, so you get a written warning.
You fuck up for a third time, the same indiscretion again, you get a final warning.

And then you fuck up again. What exactly do you think happens to you?

This is the stage we're at with this nonsense. They could celebrate in their hotel bar together with a few pints and retire to the room. They could even play a bit of poker or whatever, and actually celebrate as a team. But for some reason, as supposed adults and professional athletes, they ignored all previous warnings and disciplinary measures, and went out to a club on a Sunday night, and then stayed out past the time they knew they shouldn't.

It's immature, unprofessional and disrespectful. Especially from the team captain, as it allows all the others to completely disregard any rules.

Good post. 

People aren't looking at this in terms of employer/employee, though. Yes, I know 9-5 work life isn't the best analogy for. Sports team, but I think it's relevant here. Ultimately employer/line manager has set rules for employees to followers. Those rules were breached. Its that simple.

And therein lies the problem. It is exactly an employer/employee relationship, and they've already been way too lenient.

Where's the personal accountability from Stokes et al? Do they have no shame? It's pathetic behaviour.
Reply
#52
(06-11-2026, 08:59 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-11-2026, 08:45 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-11-2026, 07:28 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: It genuinely amazes me people can't grasp the problem with what happened. So let's flip it a bit.

You've fucked up at work. Your employer gives you a verbal warning.
You manage to fuck up again in the same way, so you get a written warning.
You fuck up for a third time, the same indiscretion again, you get a final warning.

And then you fuck up again. What exactly do you think happens to you?

This is the stage we're at with this nonsense. They could celebrate in their hotel bar together with a few pints and retire to the room. They could even play a bit of poker or whatever, and actually celebrate as a team. But for some reason, as supposed adults and professional athletes, they ignored all previous warnings and disciplinary measures, and went out to a club on a Sunday night, and then stayed out past the time they knew they shouldn't.

It's immature, unprofessional and disrespectful. Especially from the team captain, as it allows all the others to completely disregard any rules.

Good post. 

People aren't looking at this in terms of employer/employee, though. Yes, I know 9-5 work life isn't the best analogy for. Sports team, but I think it's relevant here. Ultimately employer/line manager has set rules for employees to followers. Those rules were breached. Its that simple.

And therein lies the problem. It is exactly an employer/employee relationship, and they've already been way too lenient.

Where's the personal accountability from Stokes et al? Do they have no shame? It's pathetic behaviour.
Not being controversial or anything but where has Stokes fucked up before. So for me this is his first offence. I could be wrong and will gladly hold my hands up if so.

https://s.yimg.com/ny/api/res/1.2/ZCa3Dg...1d106b61a5
Reply
#53
(06-11-2026, 12:24 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-11-2026, 08:59 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-11-2026, 08:45 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-11-2026, 07:28 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: It genuinely amazes me people can't grasp the problem with what happened. So let's flip it a bit.

You've fucked up at work. Your employer gives you a verbal warning.
You manage to fuck up again in the same way, so you get a written warning.
You fuck up for a third time, the same indiscretion again, you get a final warning.

And then you fuck up again. What exactly do you think happens to you?

This is the stage we're at with this nonsense. They could celebrate in their hotel bar together with a few pints and retire to the room. They could even play a bit of poker or whatever, and actually celebrate as a team. But for some reason, as supposed adults and professional athletes, they ignored all previous warnings and disciplinary measures, and went out to a club on a Sunday night, and then stayed out past the time they knew they shouldn't.

It's immature, unprofessional and disrespectful. Especially from the team captain, as it allows all the others to completely disregard any rules.

Good post. 

People aren't looking at this in terms of employer/employee, though. Yes, I know 9-5 work life isn't the best analogy for. Sports team, but I think it's relevant here. Ultimately employer/line manager has set rules for employees to followers. Those rules were breached. Its that simple.

And therein lies the problem. It is exactly an employer/employee relationship, and they've already been way too lenient.

Where's the personal accountability from Stokes et al? Do they have no shame? It's pathetic behaviour.
Not being controversial or anything but where has Stokes fucked up before. So for me this is his first offence. I could be wrong and will gladly hold my hands up if so.

The 2017 nightclub incident in Bristol. Several other incidents in Wellington and Noosa that have lead to this curfew being put into effect.
Reply
#54
(06-11-2026, 12:27 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-11-2026, 12:24 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-11-2026, 08:59 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-11-2026, 08:45 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-11-2026, 07:28 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: It genuinely amazes me people can't grasp the problem with what happened. So let's flip it a bit.

You've fucked up at work. Your employer gives you a verbal warning.
You manage to fuck up again in the same way, so you get a written warning.
You fuck up for a third time, the same indiscretion again, you get a final warning.

And then you fuck up again. What exactly do you think happens to you?

This is the stage we're at with this nonsense. They could celebrate in their hotel bar together with a few pints and retire to the room. They could even play a bit of poker or whatever, and actually celebrate as a team. But for some reason, as supposed adults and professional athletes, they ignored all previous warnings and disciplinary measures, and went out to a club on a Sunday night, and then stayed out past the time they knew they shouldn't.

It's immature, unprofessional and disrespectful. Especially from the team captain, as it allows all the others to completely disregard any rules.

Good post. 

People aren't looking at this in terms of employer/employee, though. Yes, I know 9-5 work life isn't the best analogy for. Sports team, but I think it's relevant here. Ultimately employer/line manager has set rules for employees to followers. Those rules were breached. Its that simple.

And therein lies the problem. It is exactly an employer/employee relationship, and they've already been way too lenient.

Where's the personal accountability from Stokes et al? Do they have no shame? It's pathetic behaviour.
Not being controversial or anything but where has Stokes fucked up before. So for me this is his first offence. I could be wrong and will gladly hold my hands up if so.

The 2017 nightclub incident in Bristol. Several other incidents in Wellington and Noosa that have lead to this curfew being put into effect.

2017 proven to be innocent, the other incidents are not Ben Stokes incidents but other players.
I have amended my last post just to show that not everything is Stokes fault.
Reply
#55
My issue isn't with Stokes, personally. He's very much the scapegoat. My issue is that this incident, together with previous incidents involving varying squad members, highlights the mentality of the squad, and that they clearly don't respect any rules that are set.

The culture within English cricket is embarrassing & infuriating. It needs a total reset and overhaul. It's as if the players don't take their responsibility of representing their country at the biggest stage in cricket seriously. It's all a bit of a laugh. It's very much a clique culture to the detriment of on field performances and results. That's what this incident represents for me.

In isolation, meh, move on. But it's not an isolated incident, and it says a lot about the awful culture and mentality around the squad and ECB set up. This lot are really unlikeable - to the point I avoid watching England Tests, because I can't stand what this squad, the ECB, and the coaches, represent and bring to the game.
Reply
#56
(06-11-2026, 12:36 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: My issue isn't with Stokes, personally. He's very much the scapegoat. My issue is that this incident, together with previous incidents involving varying squad members, highlights the mentality of the squad, and that they clearly don't respect any rules that are set.

Precisely. But the bold part comes from the leadership team of Stokes, McCullum and Key. So he is ultimately culpable for all of the mentioned incidents, especially his involvement in the latest one. If the captain ignores the rules, why should anyone adhere to them?
Reply
#57
(06-11-2026, 12:40 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-11-2026, 12:36 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: My issue isn't with Stokes, personally. He's very much the scapegoat. My issue is that this incident, together with previous incidents involving varying squad members, highlights the mentality of the squad, and that they clearly don't respect any rules that are set.

Precisely. But the bold part comes from the leadership team of Stokes, McCullum and Key. So he is ultimately culpable for all of the mentioned incidents, especially his involvement in the latest one. If the captain ignores the rules, why should anyone adhere to them?

So he fucked up at work so he should get a verbal warning. This is what you said.
Has he fucked up a second Third and even fourth time NO
Look I’m not trying to defend Stokes over this incident but it’s his first incident, the others are other players who you cannot keep an eye on 24/7. Why should he carry the can for other incidents.For me that’s wrong.
Reply
#58
I think he has the grey matter of a Goldfish. And similarly coloured hair.
Reply
#59
(06-11-2026, 01:30 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I think he has the grey matter of a Goldfish. And similarly coloured hair.

wba13?
Reply
#60
(06-11-2026, 02:12 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(06-11-2026, 01:30 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I think he has the grey matter of a Goldfish. And similarly coloured hair.

wba13?

This is only his first offense despite evidence to the contrary. So he only gets a verbal warning.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)