Josh Griffiths
#21
I’ll go out on a limb and admit that, as much as I’d like him to be, I don’t think Griffiths is that good. He has all the attributes but lacks the application/ courage to be a top class Championship keeper.
Reply
#22
Whether O’Leary is better than Griffiths is immaterial, neither are good enough for a team trying to get into the Prem via the Play-offs. If our only aim is to muddle along in the Champ then either are good enough.

The whole team were better organised defensively under Morrison, so inevitably the keeper will look better, and yes he was part of that but he’s got glaring problems with commanding his area and I just don’t see he’s much of a step up in quality.

Full disclosure, I’ve never really rated Griffiths and never thought he would be an adequate replacement for Palmer.
Reply
#23
It's a tough one.

He can't sit warming the bench and hit the potential that many working with him, including his teammates, are sure he has. However, last season was not a good one for him, and enough of a concern to want someone more reliable as number 1. In which case, selling him, adding a sell on percentage and hoping it doesn't bite us in the ass is probably the best way to go.

I think he'll come good, as with many 'keepers in their late 20's and until then he probably isn't what a promotion-chasing team needs unless the defence is absolutely rock solid.
Reply
#24
What was overlooked after the pivotal sheff u game was as significant as George’s equaliser was, was that in the moments before O’Leary produced a wonder save from a point blank header. Absolutely critical to the momentum we then built.
Reply
#25
(05-31-2026, 04:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whether O’Leary is better than Griffiths is immaterial, neither are good enough for a team trying to get into the Prem via the Play-offs. If our only aim is to muddle along in the Champ then either are good enough.

The whole team were better organised defensively under Morrison, so inevitably the keeper will look better, and yes he was part of that but he’s got glaring problems with commanding his area and I just don’t see he’s much of a step up in quality.

Full disclosure, I’ve never really rated Griffiths and never thought he would be an adequate replacement for Palmer.

Simply not true that OLeary couldn’t keep goal in a top 6 side. He played in a run of ten games unbeaten where we sat 2nd in the form league

(05-31-2026, 03:39 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(05-31-2026, 01:39 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: As I’ve said before, anyone with a set of eyes could see that OLeary was a considerable improvement. Probably the critical difference in us staying up as far as decisions Mozza made went.

No way. O'Leary had the benefit of Mozza. Putting Campbell as cb, stopping the midfield being sliced like a knife through butter and having a proper right back. Griffiths was nothing like as bad as made out, in fact he probably did better than most would under Mason and Ramsay. Mozza was the reason we stayed up and that equaliser at Bramall Lane was the catalyst. We would need to buy amazingly well to replace Griffiths at the mentioned price.

On the  form that JG showed last season, somewhere in those ten games we end up at least 3 points worse off I’m afraid. Those were the margins
Raw Sausage
Reply
#26
(05-31-2026, 07:25 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(05-31-2026, 04:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whether O’Leary is better than Griffiths is immaterial, neither are good enough for a team trying to get into the Prem via the Play-offs. If our only aim is to muddle along in the Champ then either are good enough.

The whole team were better organised defensively under Morrison, so inevitably the keeper will look better, and yes he was part of that but he’s got glaring problems with commanding his area and I just don’t see he’s much of a step up in quality.

Full disclosure, I’ve never really rated Griffiths and never thought he would be an adequate replacement for Palmer.

Simply not true that OLeary couldn’t keep goal in a top 6 side. He played in a run of ten games unbeaten where we sat 2nd in the form league

(05-31-2026, 03:39 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(05-31-2026, 01:39 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: As I’ve said before, anyone with a set of eyes could see that OLeary was a considerable improvement. Probably the critical difference in us staying up as far as decisions Mozza made went.

No way. O'Leary had the benefit of Mozza. Putting Campbell as cb, stopping the midfield being sliced like a knife through butter and having a proper right back. Griffiths was nothing like as bad as made out, in fact he probably did better than most would under Mason and Ramsay. Mozza was the reason we stayed up and that equaliser at Bramall Lane was the catalyst. We would need to buy amazingly well to replace Griffiths at the mentioned price.

On the  form that JG showed last season, somewhere in those ten games we end up at least 3 points worse off I’m afraid. Those were the margins

Yes thanks to Morrison setting the team up in a pragmatic fashion, taking advice from people like Pulis who, whatever people think of him knows how to set-up a defensive unit from front to back. Before that our defence was aots particularly under the worst manager (Ramsay) we’ve had for years in charge (shakes head at the appointment). Suddenly players like Phillips looked like they knew what they were doing, so no I don’t think O’Leary is a top six keeper, I think we hit a rich vein of form, where everybody pulled together. 

Is he as good as Palmer, Foster, Hoult, Kiely, the Pig, Johnson? I don’t think he is.
Reply
#27
He isn’t as good as any of those but that wasn’t the point I was making. From what I’ve seen over a decent span of games he’s good enough to play in a top 6 side. Probably not top 2.
Raw Sausage
Reply
#28
(05-31-2026, 08:19 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: He isn’t as good as any of those but that wasn’t the point I was making. From what I’ve seen over a decent span of games he’s good enough to play in a top 6 side. Probably not top 2.

He’s average, and we need better than average if we are to move forward as a club.
Reply
#29
I don’t disagree, but again, that’s a different point
Raw Sausage
Reply
#30
(05-31-2026, 07:25 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(05-31-2026, 04:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whether O’Leary is better than Griffiths is immaterial, neither are good enough for a team trying to get into the Prem via the Play-offs. If our only aim is to muddle along in the Champ then either are good enough.

The whole team were better organised defensively under Morrison, so inevitably the keeper will look better, and yes he was part of that but he’s got glaring problems with commanding his area and I just don’t see he’s much of a step up in quality.

Full disclosure, I’ve never really rated Griffiths and never thought he would be an adequate replacement for Palmer.

Simply not true that OLeary couldn’t keep goal in a top 6 side. He played in a run of ten games unbeaten where we sat 2nd in the form league

(05-31-2026, 03:39 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(05-31-2026, 01:39 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: As I’ve said before, anyone with a set of eyes could see that OLeary was a considerable improvement. Probably the critical difference in us staying up as far as decisions Mozza made went.

No way. O'Leary had the benefit of Mozza. Putting Campbell as cb, stopping the midfield being sliced like a knife through butter and having a proper right back. Griffiths was nothing like as bad as made out, in fact he probably did better than most would under Mason and Ramsay. Mozza was the reason we stayed up and that equaliser at Bramall Lane was the catalyst. We would need to buy amazingly well to replace Griffiths at the mentioned price.

On the  form that JG showed last season, somewhere in those ten games we end up at least 3 points worse off I’m afraid. Those were the margins

That's completely hypothetical! Who is to say Griffiths wouldn't have saved either of those 2 at Hillsborough? Or wouldn't have dropped that one Derby scored at theirs?  Without thinking too hard that's a few hypothetical points the other way. I can agree to disagree with you about the ability of both but for me, Griffiths will get better with experience and O'Leary is probably at his peak.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)