FAO any of the Jackos or Tippo
#61
OMFG!
Reply
#62
(05-24-2026, 08:26 PM)Tippobaggie Wrote: So how long has France been a war torn country?

They’re not French are they? And you have to understand that the next part of this debate will be me explaining why being in the EU meant we could send them back to France or whichever EU country they arrived in 1st, but because of the decision to leave the EU we can’t do that anymore. 

We are a sovereign nation apparently and because of that when people arrive here we’re not part of a bigger club that shares them out.

However this slightly distracts from the reasons we can’t get back to your childhood England which have got nothing to do with immigration. I don’t remember the need for all those flags in that version of England either.
Reply
#63
(05-24-2026, 10:54 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-24-2026, 08:26 PM)Tippobaggie Wrote: So how long has France been a war torn country?

They’re not French are they? And you have to understand that the next part of this debate will be me explaining why being in the EU meant we could send them back to France or whichever EU country they arrived in 1st, but because of the decision to leave the EU we can’t do that anymore. 

We are a sovereign nation apparently and because of that when people arrive here we’re not part of a bigger club that shares them out.

However this slightly distracts from the reasons we can’t get back to your childhood England which have got nothing to do with immigration. I don’t remember the need for all those flags in that version of England either.

Haven't commented in this thread despite the name check because net migration -shrugs shoulders. But now you've piqued my interest, don't tell me you're on about the Dublin Convention?
Reply
#64
I am Jacko, I feel I’m about to learn something.
Reply
#65
(05-25-2026, 07:50 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I am Jacko, I feel I’m about to learn something.

If you want to learn something, Chris Philp admitted the Tories surpressed knowledge that at 40% to half of all the small boat arrivals could have been returned under Dublin III a year ago by virtue of having rejected asylum applications in an EU or EEA member state.
Reply
#66
I didn’t know that BB so I have learned something. I was expecting the Dave down the pub question of why didn’t they claim asylum in the 1st country they arrived in.

Luckily people can see how shite at all of the immigration malarkey the Tories were and will be voting for the same people under the Reform banner.
Reply
#67
Well the key word is could. The Dublin Convention did not help with the issue as it worked both ways. For example in 2018 we made 5500 requests under the convention. 209 transfers were agreed. During the same period we accepted over 1200 transfers. Net recipients of the scheme to the tune of 1000.

Not the silver bullet Remainers think it is, yet it is constantly brought up.
Reply
#68
Net recipients were higher because numbers were lower in the UK relative to EU and EEA member states, that has consistently not been the case since 2021 so that logic doesn't apply (going from ~5k to 40k+ if we work on the basis of 40% of arrivals through irregular means as per Chris Philp which is a very conservative estimate). The fundamental basis of the Dublin Regulation is that all members party to it share the number of asylum cases across the jurisdiction. There's also the issue of the removal of those who have already had claims refused by other member states which is a lot more slam-dunk than removal to the first country of entry.
Reply
#69
Here you go Jacko, take a look at Figure 3 here: https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/re...om-the-uk/

This clearly shows the number of returns of refused asylum seekers since 2010. It isn't rocket science that putting more resource into the home office (Fig.2) results in more processing of applications. You can clearly see why the austerity years made us a soft touch for asylum seekers.

In each of the graphs you will see an increase in returns since Labour have come to power. Fig. 5 small boat returns, Fig 6 Foreign National offenders, which is why it is surprising that you wouldn't be more supportive of this government seeing as they are doing what you want.
Reply
#70
I work in Immigration Enforcement, my above inflation pay rises have been much appreciated (fig.2).

Fig 5 is merely the nature of the work, small boat crossings weren't a thing prior to 2018. The increase seen in the last 3 years would have happened sooner if not for Covid, but returns dropped off a cliff between March 2020 and February 2022. 2 or 3 years is simply the lifespan of an asylum claim from Eastern Europe where they are largely inadmissible.

In the period that graph covers (approx 7500 returns) 200 thousand economic migrants have landed on our southern shores in dinghies.

I'll bow out there, I only dipped a toe in when you erroneously brought up Dublin (again).
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)