Keef
Strangely I don’t get wound up very much on here Jacko, I will point out the obvious though. I must be doing something right though if I can manage to be accused of punching down on benefit claimants and punishing those over £100k on the same thread.

And then if you don’t agree there is a very strong probability that I’m right.

Holy shitballs indeed
Reply
If you were right then I’m sure we’d all be feeling far better off and Labour would’ve romped home in Wales, Scotland the Midlands & North. I tend to think you’re the James O’Brien of this board tbh.
Reply
Do me a favour Proth and try and keep on one tack rather than flailing around trying to win a point. The ‘I’m right’ comment was obviously aimed at the wind up merchant that is Jacko and was not meant to be taken literally.

Let’s recap - Fido moaned about MTD and blamed Labour, I corrected him; you moaned about this like it is the most onerous piece of work that anyone has to do when for most it will be the click of a button, and for the rest instead of spending 8 hours on their books once a year they will spend 2 hours four times a year. It also improves productivity in the civil service which is exactly what you cry out for; and fuck knows why Dekka got involved.

And after all that I’m accused of defending Starmer when the subject is nothing to do with him.
Reply
(05-14-2026, 06:36 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Do me a favour Proth and try and keep on one tack rather than flailing around trying to win a point. The ‘I’m right’ comment was obviously aimed at the wind up merchant that is Jacko and was not meant to be taken literally.

Let’s recap - Fido moaned about MTD and blamed Labour, I corrected him; you moaned about this like it is the most onerous piece of work that anyone has to do when for most it will be the click of a button, and for the rest instead of spending 8 hours on their books once a year they will spend 2 hours four times a year. It also improves productivity in the civil service which is exactly what you cry out for; and fuck knows why Dekka got involved.

And after all that I’m accused of defending Starmer when the subject is nothing to do with him.

B1, I apologise for yesterday. I shouldn’t have got involved.
Reply
Nice one Dekka, and I don’t take these things personally don’t worry.
Reply
(05-14-2026, 06:36 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Do me a favour Proth and try and keep on one tack rather than flailing around trying to win a point. The ‘I’m right’ comment was obviously aimed at the wind up merchant that is Jacko and was not meant to be taken literally.

Let’s recap - Fido moaned about MTD and blamed Labour, I corrected him; you moaned about this like it is the most onerous piece of work that anyone has to do when for most it will be the click of a button, and for the rest instead of spending 8 hours on their books once a year they will spend 2 hours four times a year. It also improves productivity in the civil service which is exactly what you cry out for; and fuck knows why Dekka got involved.

And after all that I’m accused of defending Starmer when the subject is nothing to do with him.

If Labour is serious about HMRC productivity, and that of sole traders - then it would stop adding to the Tax Code and instead begin shredding large parts of it. Many of us would pay more tax, but that would be offset in a huge reduction in the hours wasted and accountancy fees.
Reply
(05-14-2026, 07:50 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 06:36 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Do me a favour Proth and try and keep on one tack rather than flailing around trying to win a point. The ‘I’m right’ comment was obviously aimed at the wind up merchant that is Jacko and was not meant to be taken literally.

Let’s recap - Fido moaned about MTD and blamed Labour, I corrected him; you moaned about this like it is the most onerous piece of work that anyone has to do when for most it will be the click of a button, and for the rest instead of spending 8 hours on their books once a year they will spend 2 hours four times a year. It also improves productivity in the civil service which is exactly what you cry out for; and fuck knows why Dekka got involved.

And after all that I’m accused of defending Starmer when the subject is nothing to do with him.

If Labour is serious about HMRC productivity, and that of sole traders - then it would stop adding to the Tax Code and instead begin shredding large parts of it. Many of us would pay more tax, but that would be offset in a huge reduction in the hours wasted and accountancy fees.

A completely separate point to the one being discussed. In true Proth style, when he has had an argument pulled apart he changes tack. No recognition, just a refusal to admit he might not have been right and might have overreacted like a fanny.

In this thread we've had Fido say 'fair enough' and recognise he'd not known all the info, we've had Dekka apologise, a tad formally, when all it needs is a 'yeah sorry', but you just plough on as if you were right all along by pointing in another direction. Start being a grown up and having proper discussion. Cue another distraction or misdirection.
Reply
(05-14-2026, 06:36 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Do me a favour Proth and try and keep on one tack rather than flailing around trying to win a point. The ‘I’m right’ comment was obviously aimed at the wind up merchant that is Jacko and was not meant to be taken literally.

Let’s recap - Fido moaned about MTD and blamed Labour, I corrected him; you moaned about this like it is the most onerous piece of work that anyone has to do when for most it will be the click of a button, and for the rest instead of spending 8 hours on their books once a year they will spend 2 hours four times a year. It also improves productivity in the civil service which is exactly what you cry out for; and fuck knows why Dekka got involved.

And after all that I’m accused of defending Starmer when the subject is nothing to do with him.

I'll admit I didn't realize it was the Conservatives that first brought the idea in and, as I say, for someone who works in financial systems I like the idea of keeping things nice and tidy. But there are four quarterly reports and one year-end for self-assessment and to me that seems like complete overkill, especially if the threshold will get down to £20k per annum, just a smidge over the taxable level for employment. 

I'm not sure what happens with these quarterly reports; if anyone ever asked me to build a report for them my first question would be "What decisions will you make off the back of this?" and if they didn't give me an answer or said "i just want to see the figures" I wouldn't build it. So if nothing happens then it's pointless, if something does happen then it's more bureaucracy and red tape, something this government says it will reduce but my bet is that either nothing happens or the exact reverse.
Reply
It's digitising it all Fido, instead of having one analyst have a workload of looking through x number of returns, it's using analytics to highlight any anomalies. It also reduces fraud with having more frequent reporting that will easily show trends or again anomalies. And it will give better budgeting and faster data so that things can get recognised earlier. It has many benefits and is ultimately bringing business into the digital age. One final benefit is that it will ultimately remove the need for accountants to charge for basic form filling.

And the four quarterly reports feed into the year end assessment. HMRC will add in any other data, bank interest, PAYE etc that they know about automatically.
Reply
Here's an example of what they are trying to do Fido: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c7v9ld262n4o

Fraud is a massive problem in the UK and they are taking steps to remove as much as possible through automation and analytics. The reality is that most people will be doing this to one extent or another with their tax affairs, but the one thing it will make a little more difficult is the manipulation of figures at year end to get under a threshold.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)