Posts: 7,724
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(05-12-2026, 01:02 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Agree with that GD, my solution would be to have someone primed and ready for taking over at the end of this parliament. Bring them up to deputy leader and announce a timescale for them stepping up in time for a leadership election, or coronation, for then run up to the next GE.
We need stability and boring, anything else fucks everyone.
(05-12-2026, 01:01 PM)Jacko Wrote: You still think he's doing well given the circumstances. Bless.
I'm not certain if bless is meant as some form on condescension but it fails massively and makes you sound like a prick tbh (that's not me being condescending, that's just you being a prick I'm afraid).
You really need to read my posts as it appears your limited understanding is this. Disagree with Jacko = Support for Starmer.
Behave, all you've done for 23 months is defend Starmer at every turn. Tone deaf.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(05-12-2026, 12:53 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (05-12-2026, 12:38 PM)Jacko Wrote: Cheers. But surely you agree, given his position is untenable, that a prolonged and messy process of indeterminate length doesn't settle markets, rather it creates an ongoing drag?
It doesn't make a rats arse difference if he stays because we have no money, and no matter how many great ideas this bored comes up with they are fantasy politics (much like someone saying we should play Mikey Johnson up front alongside Dike) because they will never be implemented.
It really is about time the country woke up to us being fucked and nothing can be done about it because of the debt situation. The only solutions will upset someone, and not just Dekka, and that will be politicised by someone generally in Reform whilst we are told to blame the 40k that arrive on a boat in this population of 70M.
What we do need is to let them get on with running the country and slowly rebuilding the foundations (which will take years after the destruction of the last 4 decades), and stop wanting to change the driver of this driverless train as if it will make a difference. The only difference, that is negative and on the horizon, is Reform who will not only change the driver they will take up the tracks as well.
What would playing Mikey as a wingback equate as??!!
Posts: 6,722
Threads: 355
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
(05-12-2026, 01:02 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Agree with that GD, my solution would be to have someone primed and ready for taking over at the end of this parliament. Bring them up to deputy leader and announce a timescale for them stepping up in time for a leadership election, or coronation, for then run up to the next GE.
3 more years of the same will not cut it.
Posts: 7,462
Threads: 373
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
(05-12-2026, 01:08 PM)Jacko Wrote: (05-12-2026, 01:02 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Agree with that GD, my solution would be to have someone primed and ready for taking over at the end of this parliament. Bring them up to deputy leader and announce a timescale for them stepping up in time for a leadership election, or coronation, for then run up to the next GE.
We need stability and boring, anything else fucks everyone.
(05-12-2026, 01:01 PM)Jacko Wrote: You still think he's doing well given the circumstances. Bless.
I'm not certain if bless is meant as some form on condescension but it fails massively and makes you sound like a prick tbh (that's not me being condescending, that's just you being a prick I'm afraid).
You really need to read my posts as it appears your limited understanding is this. Disagree with Jacko = Support for Starmer.
Behave, all you've done for 23 months is defend Starmer at every turn. Tone deaf.
He’s right though, you are a prick.
Raw Sausage
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
05-12-2026, 01:56 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-12-2026, 02:00 PM by baggy1.)
(05-12-2026, 01:08 PM)Jacko Wrote: (05-12-2026, 01:02 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Agree with that GD, my solution would be to have someone primed and ready for taking over at the end of this parliament. Bring them up to deputy leader and announce a timescale for them stepping up in time for a leadership election, or coronation, for then run up to the next GE.
We need stability and boring, anything else fucks everyone.
(05-12-2026, 01:01 PM)Jacko Wrote: You still think he's doing well given the circumstances. Bless.
I'm not certain if bless is meant as some form on condescension but it fails massively and makes you sound like a prick tbh (that's not me being condescending, that's just you being a prick I'm afraid).
You really need to read my posts as it appears your limited understanding is this. Disagree with Jacko = Support for Starmer.
Behave, all you've done for 23 months is defend Starmer at every turn. Tone deaf.
Again, you really should learn to read what people post and realise that not everything is as black and white as you need it to be. I've explained how the changes in leadership damage the whole economy and why we had to get off the Tory merry go round. And also why we now need to stop repeating the mistakes of the past. The longer we play this media (both traditional and social) game of i need to shout about something and be angry / upset / furious / shocked about the latest noise, which never seems to be about Farage though I note, then the longer we will be fucked.
(05-12-2026, 01:39 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: (05-12-2026, 01:02 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Agree with that GD, my solution would be to have someone primed and ready for taking over at the end of this parliament. Bring them up to deputy leader and announce a timescale for them stepping up in time for a leadership election, or coronation, for then run up to the next GE.
3 more years of the same will not cut it.
Sorry MICS but you really aren't understanding the wider picture and damage that will be done to everyone with a change now. Change in leader now means the country is fucked even further with increased borrowing costs which will lead to either more taxes, as if things aren't bad enough, or when Reform arrive, a ready made excuse to cut services and spend massively - and those cuts will impact the working class more than anyone.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(05-12-2026, 11:55 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (05-12-2026, 10:48 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-12-2026, 06:39 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (05-11-2026, 09:47 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (05-11-2026, 09:39 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You missed the difference in the negative reporting from the start, the focus elsewhere at every policy launch. The attempts at distracting and negative reporting at every stem.
If there's nothing good about a policy you can't expect positive coverage.
Is there anyone on here who believes the outcomes from the past 22 months have been positive for them?
The irony of you posting it will get missed, however you actually called this before the election as you, and I, knew that this parliament was about steadying the ship as best as possible.
Indeed, and he hasn't done that. Those things that ARE in his control, he has made worse.
Once again, you don't appear to paying attention to the markets. Fears of a leadership change leading to more spending have made investors nervous, getting on with the mundane is what they want for a while. You do have a very parochial view when it comes to politics and life in general if what you say on here is a reflection. Uncertainty causes instability - after years of football style managerial changes, it's about time the merry go round stopped and we started giving ministers the time we voted them in for, unless they do something seismically bad.
The markets want private sector growth to enable debt interest payments to be made from tax receipts. They've seen precious little of that in 22 months. Given that the PLP is allergic to voting for anything that might encourage growth, productivity or private profit they're right to be nervous of a change. We're about to be hit by another inflationary tidal wave and the kingmakers are talking about changing the fiscal rules to suit them. It's beyond parody.
If Labour wanted to rule as a progressive social democratic government them the PLP needed to understand the weight of the contradictions that would throw up in a period of huge debt and high & rising taxation. They didn't and they don't. That won't change whether Tweedledum or Tweedledumber takes over from Starmer. This government is toast, and will usher in something far worse simply because the governing party is incapable of facing hard truths.
Posts: 7,724
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(05-12-2026, 01:44 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: (05-12-2026, 01:08 PM)Jacko Wrote: (05-12-2026, 01:02 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Agree with that GD, my solution would be to have someone primed and ready for taking over at the end of this parliament. Bring them up to deputy leader and announce a timescale for them stepping up in time for a leadership election, or coronation, for then run up to the next GE.
We need stability and boring, anything else fucks everyone.
(05-12-2026, 01:01 PM)Jacko Wrote: You still think he's doing well given the circumstances. Bless.
I'm not certain if bless is meant as some form on condescension but it fails massively and makes you sound like a prick tbh (that's not me being condescending, that's just you being a prick I'm afraid).
You really need to read my posts as it appears your limited understanding is this. Disagree with Jacko = Support for Starmer.
Behave, all you've done for 23 months is defend Starmer at every turn. Tone deaf.
He’s right though, you are a prick.
Badge of honour coming from a wrongun like you CF.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
05-12-2026, 03:41 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-12-2026, 03:43 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
Labour won the last election by default, they had two tactics being as bland as possible and at the same time saying they were the party of change, those two positions don’t work in practice. Over the last 18mths all we have seen is them offer is Sunakism-lite which the electorate rejected previously.
I said before the election they were storing up problems with this lack of ambition and awful messaging of ‘things might get a bit better, but they are awful’, ‘if you don’t like the party leave’ and ‘hi Reform types, vote for us’ The usual centrist dads amongst us dismissed this with condescension and still do, whilst making themselves look further and further out of touch, and cultist in their support for a floundering PM.
Starmer has alienated the left of his party, which is where the majority of Labour votes were lost to in the local elections not my words but those of Professor Curtis but I’m sure some will argue that’s not true. Chasing Reform and Tory voters was idiotic and has now created a party that stands for who exactly? Some well/comfortably off, middle class, white collar, middle aged blokes, who are stuck in 1997. Again various Labour politicians have alluded to this themselves over the last few days.
The situation Labour find themselves in, is because they are a vacuum of political conviction, principles, ambition, and ideas. Getting elected holding the Ming vase seems to be only political objective they had, beyond that they simply dusted off Sunak’s IPad and carried popped the vase on a very wobbly table with no firm foundations.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
05-12-2026, 03:48 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-12-2026, 03:51 PM by Protheroe.)
(05-12-2026, 03:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Labour won the last election by default, they had two tactics being as bland as possible and at the same time saying they were the party of change, those two positions don’t work in practice. Over the last 18mths all we have seen is them offer is Sunakism-lite which the electorate rejected previously.
I said before the election they were storing up problems with this lack of ambition and awful messaging of ‘things might get a bit better, but they are awful’, ‘if you don’t like the party leave’ and ‘hi Reform types, vote for us’ The usual centrist dads amongst us dismissed this with condescension and still do, whilst making themselves look further and further out of touch, and cultist in their support for a floundering PM.
Starmer has alienated the left of his party, which is where the majority of Labour votes were lost to in the local elections not my words but those of Professor Curtis but I’m sure some will argue that’s not true. Chasing Reform and Tory voters was idiotic and has now created a party that stands for who exactly? Some well/comfortably off, middle class, white collar, middle aged blokes, who are stuck in 1997. Again various Labour politicians have alluded to this themselves over the last few days.
The situation Labour find themselves in, is because they are a vacuum of political conviction, principles, ambition, and ideas. Getting elected holding the Ming vase seems to be only political objective they had, beyond that they simply dusted off Sunak’s IPad and carried popped the vase on a very wobbly table with no firm foundations.
Quite. You've just described what a deeply unserious Party Labour actually is. It is about to retreat, one way or another, into its wholly undeliverable comfort zone. Nothing of any substance will be delivered for the next 3 years setting the scene for an exceptionally toxic election in 2029 where they will face wipe out.
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
It's all very well debating the rights and wrongs of Labour's first two years. I'd have liked to see a proper clampdown on the abuse of the welfare system, particularly bogus awards of PIP for largely non-existent mental health conditions - trashed by the PLP of course. I'd like to see 1% on the basic rate of income tax - huge increase in revenue for a relatively minor hit on everyone except those in poverty - but Labour allowed themselves to be browbeaten into promising not to raise Income Tax - feeble effort IMO. I think they've done well to keep the markets stable, but this has stymied any serious efforts to cream some tax off the super-wealthy or tax-dodging big businesses. Too many U-turns for sure, but that's the PLP for you, guaranteed to shit all over a Labour Prime Minister. In the current climate (pardon the pun) we should back off on the managed decline of any energy industry based on gas or oil - we can't afford to neglect available resources and we will never see the end of the oil industry because we won't ever replace plastics.
But never mind about that, this is all about the PLP thinking a change in PM will somehow claw back voters from Reform. Yes, a bigger personality would help. Is there one? Angela Rayner, looking and sounding like she just crawled out of a Stockport nightclub at 3.00am? Andy Burnham - get some new glasses FFS sake, you look a right twat. Wes Streeting - far too creepy.
OK, maybe they need to sharpen up their policies. Will a new PM "stop the boats"? Will a new PM talk up closer contacts with the EU - that won't get anyone back from Reform? They can't out-Green the Greens and they can't out-Welsh PC or out-Jock SNP.
This is all about Labour MPs and activists who are tired of hearing voters say they "don't like Starmer". People whose mates have just lost their cosy council seats. MPs who see the prospect of having to get a proper job again - although so many of the new MPs never had one of those in the first place. The awful prospect of the end of a career in politics - because these people are largely there to serve themselves, not the people they are meant to represent.
If a new Labour leader can stimulate growth while also increasing tax revenues, make more noise about the 14 year shitshow that led us to where we are, spell out the damage done by Brexit, go on the offensive against Reform and burst the improbable bubble of respectability and popularity that surrounds the abysmal Farage, keep the markets steady and the poison press establishment quiet, if they can do this, they'll be better than Starmer. I guess old Keir isn't a very good boss, but I don't see where the James Morrison transformation is coming from for Labour.
|