Keef
(05-11-2026, 02:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I'd be nationalising the water companies using their own money. Instead of fining them for each breach of the rules around sewage or failure in other area, I would be explaining to them that they won't have to pay the fine, they will be required to give the government shares to the value of that fine, starting with the shares of the largest shareholders.

That's an interesting idea. Keir may have some spare time over the next few years to pursue all our pension funds through the court.
Reply
Proth in far from true facts again, and a liberal use of the word 'our' I see.
Reply
(05-11-2026, 02:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-11-2026, 02:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I'd be nationalising the water companies using their own money. Instead of fining them for each breach of the rules around sewage or failure in other area, I would be explaining to them that they won't have to pay the fine, they will be required to give the government shares to the value of that fine, starting with the shares of the largest shareholders.

That's an interesting idea. Keir may have some spare time over the next few years to pursue all our pension funds through the court.

The water companies are the perfect example of trading while insolvent. There must surely be someone with enough nous to snatch them back into public ownership at no cost and no paying off the vulture capitalists. Maybe start by threatening jail for those overseeing the pollution debacles.
Reply
(05-11-2026, 02:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I listened to that speech in its entirety. I heard exactly what I expected to hear - nothing new and nothing novel.

The PLP is also damned by its inaction. I'm increasingly of the opinion that being elected was seen as an end in itself rather than a means to an end.

We / they all know the fundamental problems we face:

Lack of housing
Energy prices
AI / Employment Prospects
and of course massive and rising Public Debt

A bit more Europe is not going to tip the scale. Nor is a lot more Europe. Nationalising a vital but moribund steel plant isn't going to shift the dial.

The Kings Speech will delivered in days. It was written months ago. We will see then the paucity of substance Labour is suggesting for the next Parliamentary session, along with the odd self-defeating policy like RRA or VAT on school fees. All the effort to get elected, all the strength of a huge if shallow majority - for this.

Talking of Public Debt. For me, the country seems hopelessly divided, with many calling for an election. Will never happen, but paying off all MP's and Ministers in advance for the next three years if they stood down, would cost less than what we pay in daily interest off the National Debt at around £300Million. It's a colossal problem for any political party to deal with, but it needs sorting urgently.
Reply
(05-11-2026, 02:57 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Proth in far from true facts again, and a liberal use of the word 'our' I see.

I'd be surprised if anyone's pension fund on here wasn't at least partly invested in a water company, directly or indirectly via a fund or ETF. I'd also be keen to understand how it'll make the average Joe feel better off over the next 3 years.
Reply
It’s about time we started realising that we are not going to solve the problems of 40 odd years in 1 parliament
Reply
(05-11-2026, 12:19 PM)baggy1 Wrote: That's where my worries lie as well, you can see a coalition headed up by Farage with those two as the leading share. I would hope that by then there is a large enough Lib / Lab share to be the alternative. Depends if Zac can continue with his drive to get enough to support his crashing the economy manifesto.

I was never optimistic that one term could turn this around. All that door knocking and election agenting by Proth produced some shit show. One that he takes no responsibilty at all for btw.

I said from day one Labour needed to do more and faster. The country and now even Keef agree.

I'm torn between "we still have 3 years to achieve stuff" and " we are fucked already, whomever is Labour PM"

It's great to see some London Boroughs where the fascists havent had a look in. Even leafy Surrey has told the far right fuckers to fuck off.
Reply
(05-11-2026, 05:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It’s about time we started realising that we are not going to solve the problems of 40 odd years in 1 parliament

They could at least stop making things worse.

Though when you have the calibre of MPs such as Paula Barker whose employment history is 30 years in local government and union agitating, opining that the markets would have to “fall in line” when presented with even more borrowing under a Burnham government you just know we're truly fucked.
Reply
57 (of his own) MPs now calling on him to resign. Nothing from cabinet yet though, it was Sunak's resignation that eventually saw to Boris. Will Mahmood or Streeting blink?
Reply
It’s like when we left Mason in charge for months but everyone knew he was on the clock. It just doesn’t work once you’re at that point
Raw Sausage
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)