Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
You pair of goons still going on about the centrist dad's are you? Not certain he had a pop at the Green voters at all but I suppose you hear what you want - for all of Zac's noise Greens didn't exactly pull any trees up, as a lot of voters nationally will realise that voting Green will be a wasted vote (they're still the 5th largest party based on those election results) and as for him saying two party politics "dead and buried", whilst that being accurate, doesn't point to a new world including them.
And imagine setting out a manifesto and implementing half of them at about the half way point is deemed a 'box ticking exercise' like it wasn't what they were voted into deliver. "Can you give us some nice words" seems to be the message needed apparently. ('Sitting on your hands for two years' and 'Implementing 21 of 40 election promises' in the same post does make me wonder if you read your own posts)
The underlying 'getting closer to the EU' is what has been said out loud now which was there all along and Nationalising Steel are the two takeaways from today, and if that changes the mindset then so be it, but those were in place to happen before today.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(05-11-2026, 11:26 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: It's as if a policy of sitting on your hands for 2 years, trumpeting that it's all the Tories fault, isn't convincing the public somehow.
A grown up told me recently that Labour had already implemented 21 of its 40 odd election promises. That summed up the centrist dads for me. It's just a box ticking exercise.
Labour have not been AS BAD as the general consensus sees it IMO - they have done some good, and made some progress in areas, but they haven't meaningfully benefitted enough people, and with the mainstream media being so in bed with Nige and Kemi, they can't rely on their positives being amplified to a wider audience.
The only way Labour get people back on side is by making people feel wealther than they did 2 years ago (giving them some job security, making homes affordable, getting interest rates down, curtailing inflation, getting petrol down), making their streets feel safer (both seeing police on the streets and actually responding to 999 calls), making it easier to get a GP and Dental appointment, getting their kids into a school without 40 other people in the class, and not feeling like there's someone in a headscarf with broken English ahead of them in the queue.
Nationalising one or 2 failing rail lines, taxing private schools, sustainable air fuel regulation and making it impossible for anyone under 17 to buy fags isn't quite moving the dial enough!
Posts: 6,722
Threads: 355
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
For the millionth time, I am not a Green. I am someone who expects Labour to do some Labouring.
And for the millionth and first time, you dont need to listen to me, see the election results.
Carry on with the Reform enabling.
Fiddle
Rome
Burning
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
05-11-2026, 11:53 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-11-2026, 11:54 AM by baggy1.)
(05-11-2026, 11:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-11-2026, 11:26 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: It's as if a policy of sitting on your hands for 2 years, trumpeting that it's all the Tories fault, isn't convincing the public somehow.
A grown up told me recently that Labour had already implemented 21 of its 40 odd election promises. That summed up the centrist dads for me. It's just a box ticking exercise.
Labour have not been AS BAD as the general consensus sees it IMO - they have done some good, and made some progress in areas, but they haven't meaningfully benefitted enough people, and with the mainstream media being so in bed with Nige and Kemi, they can't rely on their positives being amplified to a wider audience.
The only way Labour get people back on side is by making people feel wealther than they did 2 years ago (giving them some job security, making homes affordable, getting interest rates down, curtailing inflation, getting petrol down), making their streets feel safer (both seeing police on the streets and actually responding to 999 calls), making it easier to get a GP and Dental appointment, getting their kids into a school without 40 other people in the class, and not feeling like there's someone in a headscarf with broken English ahead of them in the queue.
Nationalising one or 2 failing rail lines, taxing private schools, sustainable air fuel regulation and making it impossible for anyone under 17 to buy fags isn't quite moving the dial enough!
Agreed SW4 - the housebuilding promise is the biggest failing. Why spend so much of the campaigning bigging this up and the dragging your feet in delivering if the most frustrating part of it all.
(05-11-2026, 11:51 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: For the millionth time, I am not a Green. I am someone who expects Labour to do some Labouring.
And for the millionth and first time, you dont need to listen to me, see the election results.
Carry on with the Reform enabling.
Fiddle
Rome
Burning
Who said you were? And if you think Reform are getting in with 25% (IMO they have peaked now) then you are wrong. There will need to be a coalition at worst but as the date gets nearer the electorate will get more nervous. Reform have peaked too soon.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-11-2026, 11:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (05-11-2026, 11:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-11-2026, 11:26 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: It's as if a policy of sitting on your hands for 2 years, trumpeting that it's all the Tories fault, isn't convincing the public somehow.
A grown up told me recently that Labour had already implemented 21 of its 40 odd election promises. That summed up the centrist dads for me. It's just a box ticking exercise.
Labour have not been AS BAD as the general consensus sees it IMO - they have done some good, and made some progress in areas, but they haven't meaningfully benefitted enough people, and with the mainstream media being so in bed with Nige and Kemi, they can't rely on their positives being amplified to a wider audience.
The only way Labour get people back on side is by making people feel wealther than they did 2 years ago (giving them some job security, making homes affordable, getting interest rates down, curtailing inflation, getting petrol down), making their streets feel safer (both seeing police on the streets and actually responding to 999 calls), making it easier to get a GP and Dental appointment, getting their kids into a school without 40 other people in the class, and not feeling like there's someone in a headscarf with broken English ahead of them in the queue.
Nationalising one or 2 failing rail lines, taxing private schools, sustainable air fuel regulation and making it impossible for anyone under 17 to buy fags isn't quite moving the dial enough!
Agreed SW4 - the housebuilding promise is the biggest failing. Why spend so much of the campaigning bigging this up and the dragging your feet in delivering if the most frustrating part of it all.
(05-11-2026, 11:51 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: For the millionth time, I am not a Green. I am someone who expects Labour to do some Labouring.
And for the millionth and first time, you dont need to listen to me, see the election results.
Carry on with the Reform enabling.
Fiddle
Rome
Burning
Who said you were? And if you think Reform are getting in with 25% (IMO they have peaked now) then you are wrong. There will need to be a coalition at worst but as the date gets nearer the electorate will get more nervous. Reform have peaked too soon.
Where did I insult you in my post B1? Any criticism of Starmer see’s you jump to his defence like the very worst of the cultists that followed Boris Johnson.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
And where in that post have I insulted you?
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(05-11-2026, 11:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (05-11-2026, 11:49 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-11-2026, 11:26 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: It's as if a policy of sitting on your hands for 2 years, trumpeting that it's all the Tories fault, isn't convincing the public somehow.
A grown up told me recently that Labour had already implemented 21 of its 40 odd election promises. That summed up the centrist dads for me. It's just a box ticking exercise.
Labour have not been AS BAD as the general consensus sees it IMO - they have done some good, and made some progress in areas, but they haven't meaningfully benefitted enough people, and with the mainstream media being so in bed with Nige and Kemi, they can't rely on their positives being amplified to a wider audience.
The only way Labour get people back on side is by making people feel wealther than they did 2 years ago (giving them some job security, making homes affordable, getting interest rates down, curtailing inflation, getting petrol down), making their streets feel safer (both seeing police on the streets and actually responding to 999 calls), making it easier to get a GP and Dental appointment, getting their kids into a school without 40 other people in the class, and not feeling like there's someone in a headscarf with broken English ahead of them in the queue.
Nationalising one or 2 failing rail lines, taxing private schools, sustainable air fuel regulation and making it impossible for anyone under 17 to buy fags isn't quite moving the dial enough!
Agreed SW4 - the housebuilding promise is the biggest failing. Why spend so much of the campaigning bigging this up and the dragging your feet in delivering if the most frustrating part of it all.
(05-11-2026, 11:51 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: For the millionth time, I am not a Green. I am someone who expects Labour to do some Labouring.
And for the millionth and first time, you dont need to listen to me, see the election results.
Carry on with the Reform enabling.
Fiddle
Rome
Burning
Who said you were? And if you think Reform are getting in with 25% (IMO they have peaked now) then you are wrong. There will need to be a coalition at worst but as the date gets nearer the electorate will get more nervous. Reform have peaked too soon.
I don't see Reform winning a majority in the next election, I think you're right that they have peaked too soon, and come 2029/30, I think there will have been more than enough scandal and ineptness emanating from their existing MPs, candidates and local council operations to curtail their appeal. There will of course be a last minute boost from bot-farms going into overdrive on right wing propaganda, the last valiant attempts from the Daily Mail and co, and I am sure the MAGA playbook will manufacture several migrant crises or an assassination attempt on Nige by an ethnic minority to embolden support at the death, but overall I do believe the British public is too discerning to fall entirely for these charlatans,
My concern is the very real prospect of a Tory+Reform coalition, or even Reform being in opposition to a very weak Labour (or Lab+Green+Lib) government clinging onto a narrow majority with us having to give airtime to the SNP or DUP again to get things over the line.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
That's where my worries lie as well, you can see a coalition headed up by Farage with those two as the leading share. I would hope that by then there is a large enough Lib / Lab share to be the alternative. Depends if Zac can continue with his drive to get enough to support his crashing the economy manifesto.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
I listened to that speech in its entirety. I heard exactly what I expected to hear - nothing new and nothing novel.
The PLP is also damned by its inaction. I'm increasingly of the opinion that being elected was seen as an end in itself rather than a means to an end.
We / they all know the fundamental problems we face:
Lack of housing
Energy prices
AI / Employment Prospects
and of course massive and rising Public Debt
A bit more Europe is not going to tip the scale. Nor is a lot more Europe. Nationalising a vital but moribund steel plant isn't going to shift the dial.
The Kings Speech will delivered in days. It was written months ago. We will see then the paucity of substance Labour is suggesting for the next Parliamentary session, along with the odd self-defeating policy like RRA or VAT on school fees. All the effort to get elected, all the strength of a huge if shallow majority - for this.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
I'd be nationalising the water companies using their own money. Instead of fining them for each breach of the rules around sewage or failure in other area, I would be explaining to them that they won't have to pay the fine, they will be required to give the government shares to the value of that fine, starting with the shares of the largest shareholders.
|