Tim Iroegbunam
#41
(05-06-2026, 07:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 06:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Like I said, I don't think we've missed out on any stars or similar, Field was an example of my wider point, which is if a players is regarded as ready, don't sign players ahead of them unnecessarily, make them part of the rotation with enough game time to see if they do step up. This is where we've sometimes struggled.

It's not an exact science, problem us, if a player struggles to play first team football after academy football, it stifles a key part of their development heavily, whether it's because of injury or over caution.

What I don't want to see is players signing to be underbelly, like Devante Cole, that's for academy players to fill.

Now I was one who never rated Caleb Taylor that highly when we was here but there is no way you can convince me that the 26 apps Mason Holgate made for us last season shouldn't have gone to him. Who knows, in a different world he really comes on across that half a season and we don't flog him to Millwall. Birdy is right, it's really poor squad management and for a team who've spoken at length about development and selling players for profit, I worry they don't realise you need to give players the opportunity to develop and show their value.

Exactly.

We aren't awful at it, we give plenty of debuts and such, but we need to do better at building on that. Yes, 90% will end up released, not achieving much and forgotten, but that 10% will either fill squad roles for years to come, or go on to do very well, be a star and possibly sold for pure FFP profit.
Reply
#42
bit late to the party but Izzy Brown!
Reply
#43
(05-06-2026, 07:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 07:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 06:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Like I said, I don't think we've missed out on any stars or similar, Field was an example of my wider point, which is if a players is regarded as ready, don't sign players ahead of them unnecessarily, make them part of the rotation with enough game time to see if they do step up. This is where we've sometimes struggled.

It's not an exact science, problem us, if a player struggles to play first team football after academy football, it stifles a key part of their development heavily, whether it's because of injury or over caution.

What I don't want to see is players signing to be underbelly, like Devante Cole, that's for academy players to fill.

Now I was one who never rated Caleb Taylor that highly when we was here but there is no way you can convince me that the 26 apps Mason Holgate made for us last season shouldn't have gone to him. Who knows, in a different world he really comes on across that half a season and we don't flog him to Millwall. Birdy is right, it's really poor squad management and for a team who've spoken at length about development and selling players for profit, I worry they don't realise you need to give players the opportunity to develop and show their value.

Exactly.

We aren't awful at it, we give plenty of debuts and such, but we need to do better at building on that. Yes, 90% will end up released, not achieving much and forgotten, but that 10% will either fill squad roles for years to come, or go on to do very well, be a star and possibly sold for pure FFP profit.

If I were our owner, I'd really be questioning the need for a Cat 1 academy... it costs us a huge amount of money and when I look at teams like Norwich, Hull, Blackburn, Swansea and Sheff Utd who seem to produce just as many, if not more first team players from their academy despite holding Cat 2 there seems little reason to spend so much. Admittedly, they are fishing in less competitive ponds for talent but I'm not sure maintaining that status is really leading to us generating better quality prospects... and it;s not like it gives us any protection from other clubs poaching our talent anyway.

I also think we have to improve our loan management... If feels to me that we have far fewer kids going out on loan compared with other clubs, or those loans are less successful. Our kids are going out at what feels like an older age, and generally end up warming the bench. 

We do not lack talent, we've produced plenty of players that are now in the academies of top 6 sides, or who are playing regularly in PL and Championship sides, but our pathway is still not right. We are seeing too many depart or flourish after leaving, and I think we are still way too reticent to give opportunities to younger players.
Reply
#44
(05-06-2026, 03:03 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 07:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 07:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 06:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Like I said, I don't think we've missed out on any stars or similar, Field was an example of my wider point, which is if a players is regarded as ready, don't sign players ahead of them unnecessarily, make them part of the rotation with enough game time to see if they do step up. This is where we've sometimes struggled.

It's not an exact science, problem us, if a player struggles to play first team football after academy football, it stifles a key part of their development heavily, whether it's because of injury or over caution.

What I don't want to see is players signing to be underbelly, like Devante Cole, that's for academy players to fill.

Now I was one who never rated Caleb Taylor that highly when we was here but there is no way you can convince me that the 26 apps Mason Holgate made for us last season shouldn't have gone to him. Who knows, in a different world he really comes on across that half a season and we don't flog him to Millwall. Birdy is right, it's really poor squad management and for a team who've spoken at length about development and selling players for profit, I worry they don't realise you need to give players the opportunity to develop and show their value.

Exactly.

We aren't awful at it, we give plenty of debuts and such, but we need to do better at building on that. Yes, 90% will end up released, not achieving much and forgotten, but that 10% will either fill squad roles for years to come, or go on to do very well, be a star and possibly sold for pure FFP profit.

If I were our owner, I'd really be questioning the need for a Cat 1 academy... it costs us a huge amount of money and when I look at teams like Norwich, Hull, Blackburn, Swansea and Sheff Utd who seem to produce just as many, if not more first team players from their academy despite holding Cat 2 there seems little reason to spend so much. Admittedly, they are fishing in less competitive ponds for talent but I'm not sure maintaining that status is really leading to us generating better quality prospects... and it;s not like it gives us any protection from other clubs poaching our talent anyway.

I also think we have to improve our loan management... If feels to me that we have far fewer kids going out on loan compared with other clubs, or those loans are less successful. Our kids are going out at what feels like an older age, and generally end up warming the bench. 

We do not lack talent, we've produced plenty of players that are now in the academies of top 6 sides, or who are playing regularly in PL and Championship sides, but our pathway is still not right. We are seeing too many depart or flourish after leaving, and I think we are still way too reticent to give opportunities to younger players.

No, we haven't.

PL: Chris Wood, Morgan Rogers, Tim Iroegbunam.

Championship: Tom Fellows, Caleb Taylor, Sam Field, O'Shea, Palmer.

That's not plenty, especially considering the time period those players cover.

I agree with the wider point about using an academy player instead of buying a Devante Cole, but as part of a sensible transfer we shouldn't be obtaining players like Devante Cole anyway.
Reply
#45
Our academy is in profit I believe, thanks Saido and Stoke..
Reply
#46
That is the very point  though Squid. We have signed players that proved no better than our academy products thus costing much money and blocking their pathway. Could Bostock have done worse than SIJ this year? If we'd looked at him over the same period he could've been loaned out in January  (assuming he wasn't ready for us).  Our problem has been this x 10. Those names mentioned by GzBaggy upthread are further examples.  We couldn't do anything about the un-neighbourly plundering by villa but I hope we've fixed that fence now and learned a lesson. With  9 subs named each game there must be room for a few of our own.
Reply
#47
(05-06-2026, 06:02 PM)Squid Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 03:03 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 07:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 07:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 06:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Like I said, I don't think we've missed out on any stars or similar, Field was an example of my wider point, which is if a players is regarded as ready, don't sign players ahead of them unnecessarily, make them part of the rotation with enough game time to see if they do step up. This is where we've sometimes struggled.

It's not an exact science, problem us, if a player struggles to play first team football after academy football, it stifles a key part of their development heavily, whether it's because of injury or over caution.

What I don't want to see is players signing to be underbelly, like Devante Cole, that's for academy players to fill.

Now I was one who never rated Caleb Taylor that highly when we was here but there is no way you can convince me that the 26 apps Mason Holgate made for us last season shouldn't have gone to him. Who knows, in a different world he really comes on across that half a season and we don't flog him to Millwall. Birdy is right, it's really poor squad management and for a team who've spoken at length about development and selling players for profit, I worry they don't realise you need to give players the opportunity to develop and show their value.

Exactly.

We aren't awful at it, we give plenty of debuts and such, but we need to do better at building on that. Yes, 90% will end up released, not achieving much and forgotten, but that 10% will either fill squad roles for years to come, or go on to do very well, be a star and possibly sold for pure FFP profit.

If I were our owner, I'd really be questioning the need for a Cat 1 academy... it costs us a huge amount of money and when I look at teams like Norwich, Hull, Blackburn, Swansea and Sheff Utd who seem to produce just as many, if not more first team players from their academy despite holding Cat 2 there seems little reason to spend so much. Admittedly, they are fishing in less competitive ponds for talent but I'm not sure maintaining that status is really leading to us generating better quality prospects... and it;s not like it gives us any protection from other clubs poaching our talent anyway.

I also think we have to improve our loan management... If feels to me that we have far fewer kids going out on loan compared with other clubs, or those loans are less successful. Our kids are going out at what feels like an older age, and generally end up warming the bench. 

We do not lack talent, we've produced plenty of players that are now in the academies of top 6 sides, or who are playing regularly in PL and Championship sides, but our pathway is still not right. We are seeing too many depart or flourish after leaving, and I think we are still way too reticent to give opportunities to younger players.

No, we haven't.

PL: Chris Wood, Morgan Rogers, Tim Iroegbunam.

Championship: Tom Fellows, Caleb Taylor, Sam Field, O'Shea, Palmer.

That's not plenty, especially considering the time period those players cover.

I agree with the wider point about using an academy player instead of buying a Devante Cole, but as part of a sensible transfer we shouldn't be obtaining players like Devante Cole anyway.
You omit Azaz and Griffiths.
You could argue that our academy in recent years has produced a PL/Championship player each year
Reply
#48
(05-06-2026, 07:03 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 06:02 PM)Squid Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 03:03 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 07:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 07:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Now I was one who never rated Caleb Taylor that highly when we was here but there is no way you can convince me that the 26 apps Mason Holgate made for us last season shouldn't have gone to him. Who knows, in a different world he really comes on across that half a season and we don't flog him to Millwall. Birdy is right, it's really poor squad management and for a team who've spoken at length about development and selling players for profit, I worry they don't realise you need to give players the opportunity to develop and show their value.

Exactly.

We aren't awful at it, we give plenty of debuts and such, but we need to do better at building on that. Yes, 90% will end up released, not achieving much and forgotten, but that 10% will either fill squad roles for years to come, or go on to do very well, be a star and possibly sold for pure FFP profit.

If I were our owner, I'd really be questioning the need for a Cat 1 academy... it costs us a huge amount of money and when I look at teams like Norwich, Hull, Blackburn, Swansea and Sheff Utd who seem to produce just as many, if not more first team players from their academy despite holding Cat 2 there seems little reason to spend so much. Admittedly, they are fishing in less competitive ponds for talent but I'm not sure maintaining that status is really leading to us generating better quality prospects... and it;s not like it gives us any protection from other clubs poaching our talent anyway.

I also think we have to improve our loan management... If feels to me that we have far fewer kids going out on loan compared with other clubs, or those loans are less successful. Our kids are going out at what feels like an older age, and generally end up warming the bench. 

We do not lack talent, we've produced plenty of players that are now in the academies of top 6 sides, or who are playing regularly in PL and Championship sides, but our pathway is still not right. We are seeing too many depart or flourish after leaving, and I think we are still way too reticent to give opportunities to younger players.

No, we haven't.

PL: Chris Wood, Morgan Rogers, Tim Iroegbunam.

Championship: Tom Fellows, Caleb Taylor, Sam Field, O'Shea, Palmer.

That's not plenty, especially considering the time period those players cover.

I agree with the wider point about using an academy player instead of buying a Devante Cole, but as part of a sensible transfer we shouldn't be obtaining players like Devante Cole anyway.
You omit Azaz and Griffiths.
You could argue that our academy in recent years has produced a PL/Championship player each year

Now compare ig blues / Sunderland that's what we and about 80 other clubs need to do. Also rans don t change a club.
Reply
#49
In my time watching the Albion we seemed to give two players a debut per season of which one made it in the first team the other disappeared for good.
We could never produce Centre Forwards or wingers, did ok with defenders but could produce midfielders.
Brown, Hope, Lovett, Hartford, Cantello, Trewick, Robson, Moses.
Reply
#50
(05-06-2026, 06:02 PM)Squid Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 03:03 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 07:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 07:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-06-2026, 06:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Like I said, I don't think we've missed out on any stars or similar, Field was an example of my wider point, which is if a players is regarded as ready, don't sign players ahead of them unnecessarily, make them part of the rotation with enough game time to see if they do step up. This is where we've sometimes struggled.

It's not an exact science, problem us, if a player struggles to play first team football after academy football, it stifles a key part of their development heavily, whether it's because of injury or over caution.

What I don't want to see is players signing to be underbelly, like Devante Cole, that's for academy players to fill.

Now I was one who never rated Caleb Taylor that highly when we was here but there is no way you can convince me that the 26 apps Mason Holgate made for us last season shouldn't have gone to him. Who knows, in a different world he really comes on across that half a season and we don't flog him to Millwall. Birdy is right, it's really poor squad management and for a team who've spoken at length about development and selling players for profit, I worry they don't realise you need to give players the opportunity to develop and show their value.

Exactly.

We aren't awful at it, we give plenty of debuts and such, but we need to do better at building on that. Yes, 90% will end up released, not achieving much and forgotten, but that 10% will either fill squad roles for years to come, or go on to do very well, be a star and possibly sold for pure FFP profit.

If I were our owner, I'd really be questioning the need for a Cat 1 academy... it costs us a huge amount of money and when I look at teams like Norwich, Hull, Blackburn, Swansea and Sheff Utd who seem to produce just as many, if not more first team players from their academy despite holding Cat 2 there seems little reason to spend so much. Admittedly, they are fishing in less competitive ponds for talent but I'm not sure maintaining that status is really leading to us generating better quality prospects... and it;s not like it gives us any protection from other clubs poaching our talent anyway.

I also think we have to improve our loan management... If feels to me that we have far fewer kids going out on loan compared with other clubs, or those loans are less successful. Our kids are going out at what feels like an older age, and generally end up warming the bench. 

We do not lack talent, we've produced plenty of players that are now in the academies of top 6 sides, or who are playing regularly in PL and Championship sides, but our pathway is still not right. We are seeing too many depart or flourish after leaving, and I think we are still way too reticent to give opportunities to younger players.

No, we haven't.

PL: Chris Wood, Morgan Rogers, Tim Iroegbunam.

Championship: Tom Fellows, Caleb Taylor, Sam Field, O'Shea, Palmer.

That's not plenty, especially considering the time period those players cover.

I agree with the wider point about using an academy player instead of buying a Devante Cole, but as part of a sensible transfer we shouldn't be obtaining players like Devante Cole anyway.

By adding Wood to the mix you really do extend the time period Squid.. 

In the last 6 years we’ve had Griffith, Palmer, O’Shea, Ferguson and Fellows come into the first team and play meaningful roles, and we’ve also had Rogers, Iroegbunam, Azaz all leave and breakthrough elsewhere, along with players like Lino Sousa and the Sealcunt Louie Barry making their way up the leagues on loan from the Seals. Prior to this we had players like Field, Harper, Thorne and Berahino make meaningful contributions to our first team even if their careers never truly took off to a level we expected.

For a club of our size, for 10 years that’s a very good return… we producing a PL standard player seemingly every season, and actually, the players who go on to better things after leaving us hasn’t been  due to lack of opportunities, but because of us selling them when we need to, or through then being poached.

I do think we need to be less risk adverse with some of our youth, and we’ve certainly wasted money on squad players when youth could have been given those minutes, and we should definitely introduce a no loans from Villa, ever, rule, but there are very few players going on to better things because we’ve not given them a chance.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)