Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(05-05-2026, 10:30 AM)fbaggy3 Wrote: Not heard much about Williams after he got injured playing for Wales after a bright debut for the first team, is he in contention for next year at all?
He had a couple of run outs in the reserves towards the end of the season. I'd expect him to be fit for next season and, if he continues to develop, be pushing for a first team place.
Or a loan at Midland Combination level.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
05-05-2026, 05:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-05-2026, 05:39 PM by Birdman1811.)
I've said before, well, I say it too many times.
We can produce them, our problem is integration, we seem to be able to do two things:
1. Future star, comes in, does amazingly well, sell for good money. Ferguson, O'Shea, Fellows.
2. Makes debut, can't hold down place, disappears, not even squad cover, just... Disappears. Almost all others.
The better clubs than us, use the not quite good enough youth for squad cover rather than use expensive players who probably still aren't good enough. Prime example was Field. He was ready to step up when Fletcher left, we didn't need Barry at all, and the tourist wasn't really needed. So he dropped down, and his career then stop starts. All because Pulis was terrified of the lack of experience, players and coaches, Megson especially, wanted Field to be in that standard midfield rotation.
I don't disagree with Lurker, none of the current crop are stars, but we should use them more rather than signing average squad fillers, restricting us fir the star players we do need.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(05-05-2026, 12:03 PM)MrBater Wrote: (05-05-2026, 11:57 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: There is a difference of opinion on here, I am in the school of thought that we aways seem reluctant to give our kids a go, the Sheff Wed game being a prime example.
I think that Aziz, Field, Taylor and Cleary would improve our squad, they would all cost more to buy than what we received for them in transfer fees.
Next season I hope we give our kids a chance, but suspect we will not. We have a weaker team than when we loaned Dawson, O'Shea and Fellows out, so the kids need not be as good. We also need to keep a close eye on our finances.
I liked Field, but he is mid-level Champ at best and always was. As his career is showing.
Cleary, I've no view on as I've never seen him play at Champ level, and at the time there was no point holding onto him. A season of 7 goals in 42 games and 13 assists in League One, does that really make him better than we have? I have my doubts.
Azaz to me seems to have come a bit out of nowhere after floundering a lot, it took him 4 years after leaving us to actually start to show much of anything. We simply couldn't wait that long and had better options than him.
I can't even remember Taylor 
Field was better than that. Megson was a big, big fan of him, as was Pulis tbf, but he just had his usual fears. Problem was we had Barry who was a 'leader' which Moore preferred, and Moore, wrongly imo, preferred the athleticism of Harper, so Field went on loan to Charlton, which was awful for him, awful training and recovery meant he picked up a recurring injury that affected him badly, and still does. An injury he might well have never had if he'd been here playing.
Posts: 612
Threads: 53
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
Would love Harry Whitwell to be given a chance.A real talent with good ability,Fellows was the last one who had loan at Crawley and kicked on.I know Forest Green raved about Whitwell and I think our situation and us switching to 442 might of gone against Whitwell getting game time.Whitwell is probably best suited in an attacking role behind the forward.
Also I like the centre back who was on loan at Worcester and add Suley and Mandy to that as well.Bostock will need a loan but even then I have my doubts.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(05-05-2026, 05:44 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (05-05-2026, 12:03 PM)MrBater Wrote: (05-05-2026, 11:57 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: There is a difference of opinion on here, I am in the school of thought that we aways seem reluctant to give our kids a go, the Sheff Wed game being a prime example.
I think that Aziz, Field, Taylor and Cleary would improve our squad, they would all cost more to buy than what we received for them in transfer fees.
Next season I hope we give our kids a chance, but suspect we will not. We have a weaker team than when we loaned Dawson, O'Shea and Fellows out, so the kids need not be as good. We also need to keep a close eye on our finances.
I liked Field, but he is mid-level Champ at best and always was. As his career is showing.
Cleary, I've no view on as I've never seen him play at Champ level, and at the time there was no point holding onto him. A season of 7 goals in 42 games and 13 assists in League One, does that really make him better than we have? I have my doubts.
Azaz to me seems to have come a bit out of nowhere after floundering a lot, it took him 4 years after leaving us to actually start to show much of anything. We simply couldn't wait that long and had better options than him.
I can't even remember Taylor 
Field was better than that. Megson was a big, big fan of him, as was Pulis tbf, but he just had his usual fears. Problem was we had Barry who was a 'leader' which Moore preferred, and Moore, wrongly imo, preferred the athleticism of Harper, so Field went on loan to Charlton, which was awful for him, awful training and recovery meant he picked up a recurring injury that affected him badly, and still does. An injury he might well have never had if he'd been here playing.
Might have is doing a lot of heavy lifting there.
Kyle Edwards, Rakeem Harper and Jon Leko to an extent were all given opportunities and ultimately, none of them were Championship level footballers. Kane Wilson, was another one highly rated at the time, but was never at the right level for us. Jack Fitzwater the same.
Of the more recent crop, Cleary is at mid League One club, Mo Faal on loan to Cheltenham, a poor League Two side which is also where George Harmon ended up. Quevin Castro now plies his trade in the National League South. Ethan Ingram is in the Scottish Championship. Ted Cann is at Rotherham. Jovan Malcolm was with Stevenage, but got sent out on loan to Barrow, who have just been relegated from League Two.
All this to say that the concept that our academy is full of neglected talents who would have transformed our situation just isn't true.
Even if Field had played, the issue with Moore's team was that we leaked far too many goals due to the idea that Bartley and Hegazi could play out from the back. Had Moore kept the defence doing meat and potatoes stuff, we would have been promoted that year.
Posts: 3,107
Threads: 59
Joined: Sep 2025
Reputation:
20
05-05-2026, 11:06 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-05-2026, 11:07 PM by Tom Joad 25.)
(05-05-2026, 09:52 PM)Squid Wrote: (05-05-2026, 05:44 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (05-05-2026, 12:03 PM)MrBater Wrote: (05-05-2026, 11:57 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: There is a difference of opinion on here, I am in the school of thought that we aways seem reluctant to give our kids a go, the Sheff Wed game being a prime example.
I think that Aziz, Field, Taylor and Cleary would improve our squad, they would all cost more to buy than what we received for them in transfer fees.
Next season I hope we give our kids a chance, but suspect we will not. We have a weaker team than when we loaned Dawson, O'Shea and Fellows out, so the kids need not be as good. We also need to keep a close eye on our finances.
I liked Field, but he is mid-level Champ at best and always was. As his career is showing.
Cleary, I've no view on as I've never seen him play at Champ level, and at the time there was no point holding onto him. A season of 7 goals in 42 games and 13 assists in League One, does that really make him better than we have? I have my doubts.
Azaz to me seems to have come a bit out of nowhere after floundering a lot, it took him 4 years after leaving us to actually start to show much of anything. We simply couldn't wait that long and had better options than him.
I can't even remember Taylor 
Field was better than that. Megson was a big, big fan of him, as was Pulis tbf, but he just had his usual fears. Problem was we had Barry who was a 'leader' which Moore preferred, and Moore, wrongly imo, preferred the athleticism of Harper, so Field went on loan to Charlton, which was awful for him, awful training and recovery meant he picked up a recurring injury that affected him badly, and still does. An injury he might well have never had if he'd been here playing.
Might have is doing a lot of heavy lifting there.
Kyle Edwards, Rakeem Harper and Jon Leko to an extent were all given opportunities and ultimately, none of them were Championship level footballers. Kane Wilson, was another one highly rated at the time, but was never at the right level for us. Jack Fitzwater the same.
Of the more recent crop, Cleary is at mid League One club, Mo Faal on loan to Cheltenham, a poor League Two side which is also where George Harmon ended up. Quevin Castro now plies his trade in the National League South. Ethan Ingram is in the Scottish Championship. Ted Cann is at Rotherham. Jovan Malcolm was with Stevenage, but got sent out on loan to Barrow, who have just been relegated from League Two.
All this to say that the concept that our academy is full of neglected talents who would have transformed our situation just isn't true.
Even if Field had played, the issue with Moore's team was that we leaked far too many goals due to the idea that Bartley and Hegazi could play out from the back. Had Moore kept the defence doing meat and potatoes stuff, we would have been promoted that year.
I would suggest the players we bought in on considerable wages then put straight into the side have also virtually vanished into anonymity so that doesnt necessarily mean we were right not to play the academy players. The point remains that we are nursing academy players well into their 20s. Decisions need to be made sooner. At one point when I watched our youngsters more regularly we had 4 centre forwards we regularly rotated all virtually indistinguishable from each other. Lightweight in physique and not particularly fast or tricky. Fellows on the wing stood out for me, Andrews in MF too. (Ingram as well but I'm not paid to judge). Meantime Azaz was poached so someone elsewhere was better briefed as within 4 years he subsequently moved for first 2.5M then 14M. There are enough of our ex Academy players earning a living at all levels to indicate we do a lot right, where we aren't any good is in getting them into the senior game at the right age.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(05-05-2026, 11:06 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: (05-05-2026, 09:52 PM)Squid Wrote: (05-05-2026, 05:44 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (05-05-2026, 12:03 PM)MrBater Wrote: (05-05-2026, 11:57 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: There is a difference of opinion on here, I am in the school of thought that we aways seem reluctant to give our kids a go, the Sheff Wed game being a prime example.
I think that Aziz, Field, Taylor and Cleary would improve our squad, they would all cost more to buy than what we received for them in transfer fees.
Next season I hope we give our kids a chance, but suspect we will not. We have a weaker team than when we loaned Dawson, O'Shea and Fellows out, so the kids need not be as good. We also need to keep a close eye on our finances.
I liked Field, but he is mid-level Champ at best and always was. As his career is showing.
Cleary, I've no view on as I've never seen him play at Champ level, and at the time there was no point holding onto him. A season of 7 goals in 42 games and 13 assists in League One, does that really make him better than we have? I have my doubts.
Azaz to me seems to have come a bit out of nowhere after floundering a lot, it took him 4 years after leaving us to actually start to show much of anything. We simply couldn't wait that long and had better options than him.
I can't even remember Taylor 
Field was better than that. Megson was a big, big fan of him, as was Pulis tbf, but he just had his usual fears. Problem was we had Barry who was a 'leader' which Moore preferred, and Moore, wrongly imo, preferred the athleticism of Harper, so Field went on loan to Charlton, which was awful for him, awful training and recovery meant he picked up a recurring injury that affected him badly, and still does. An injury he might well have never had if he'd been here playing.
Might have is doing a lot of heavy lifting there.
Kyle Edwards, Rakeem Harper and Jon Leko to an extent were all given opportunities and ultimately, none of them were Championship level footballers. Kane Wilson, was another one highly rated at the time, but was never at the right level for us. Jack Fitzwater the same.
Of the more recent crop, Cleary is at mid League One club, Mo Faal on loan to Cheltenham, a poor League Two side which is also where George Harmon ended up. Quevin Castro now plies his trade in the National League South. Ethan Ingram is in the Scottish Championship. Ted Cann is at Rotherham. Jovan Malcolm was with Stevenage, but got sent out on loan to Barrow, who have just been relegated from League Two.
All this to say that the concept that our academy is full of neglected talents who would have transformed our situation just isn't true.
Even if Field had played, the issue with Moore's team was that we leaked far too many goals due to the idea that Bartley and Hegazi could play out from the back. Had Moore kept the defence doing meat and potatoes stuff, we would have been promoted that year.
I would suggest the players we bought in on considerable wages then put straight into the side have also virtually vanished into anonymity so that doesnt necessarily mean we were right not to play the academy players. The point remains that we are nursing academy players well into their 20s. Decisions need to be made sooner. At one point when I watched our youngsters more regularly we had 4 centre forwards we regularly rotated all virtually indistinguishable from each other. Lightweight in physique and not particularly fast or tricky. Fellows on the wing stood out for me, Andrews in MF too. (Ingram as well but I'm not paid to judge). Meantime Azaz was poached so someone elsewhere was better briefed as within 4 years he subsequently moved for first 2.5M then 14M. There are enough of our ex Academy players earning a living at all levels to indicate we do a lot right, where we aren't any good is in getting them into the senior game at the right age.
But there are only a very small handful earning a living at our level (or above) and of those, most did get an opportunity in our first team.
Finn Azaz left because he was offered more money elsewhere. There wasn't much we could do about that. Likewise Tim Iroegbunam being poached.
I remember when some were convinced that Fenton Herd was the next big thing. He's at Rushall Olympic now and has hardly played in the past two seasons.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Like I said, I don't think we've missed out on any stars or similar, Field was an example of my wider point, which is if a players is regarded as ready, don't sign players ahead of them unnecessarily, make them part of the rotation with enough game time to see if they do step up. This is where we've sometimes struggled.
It's not an exact science, problem us, if a player struggles to play first team football after academy football, it stifles a key part of their development heavily, whether it's because of injury or over caution.
What I don't want to see is players signing to be underbelly, like Devante Cole, that's for academy players to fill.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(05-05-2026, 05:38 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I've said before, well, I say it too many times.
We can produce them, our problem is integration, we seem to be able to do two things:
1. Future star, comes in, does amazingly well, sell for good money. Ferguson, O'Shea, Fellows.
2. Makes debut, can't hold down place, disappears, not even squad cover, just... Disappears. Almost all others.
The better clubs than us, use the not quite good enough youth for squad cover rather than use expensive players who probably still aren't good enough. Prime example was Field. He was ready to step up when Fletcher left, we didn't need Barry at all, and the tourist wasn't really needed. So he dropped down, and his career then stop starts. All because Pulis was terrified of the lack of experience, players and coaches, Megson especially, wanted Field to be in that standard midfield rotation.
I don't disagree with Lurker, none of the current crop are stars, but we should use them more rather than signing average squad fillers, restricting us fir the star players we do need.
This is very well written and you make a good point about
"The better clubs than us, use the not quite good enough youth for squad cover rather than use expensive players who probably still aren't good enough"
There are a whole host of players we brought in who were never good enough (or past it) Albrighton, Barry, Kelly, Reach, Rogic etc
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(05-06-2026, 06:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Like I said, I don't think we've missed out on any stars or similar, Field was an example of my wider point, which is if a players is regarded as ready, don't sign players ahead of them unnecessarily, make them part of the rotation with enough game time to see if they do step up. This is where we've sometimes struggled.
It's not an exact science, problem us, if a player struggles to play first team football after academy football, it stifles a key part of their development heavily, whether it's because of injury or over caution.
What I don't want to see is players signing to be underbelly, like Devante Cole, that's for academy players to fill.
Now I was one who never rated Caleb Taylor that highly when we was here but there is no way you can convince me that the 26 apps Mason Holgate made for us last season shouldn't have gone to him. Who knows, in a different world he really comes on across that half a season and we don't flog him to Millwall. Birdy is right, it's really poor squad management and for a team who've spoken at length about development and selling players for profit, I worry they don't realise you need to give players the opportunity to develop and show their value.
|