Tice & Rayner
#1
As someone who runs 3 limited companies including a propco (and several other propcos & SPVs in the past) - and pays all taxes that are legally due - it strikes me as morally bankrupt that our politicians seem to think compliance is for the plebs like me.

Rayner went out of her way to construct a framework to avoid paying the correct SDLT.

Now Tice has been caught with his trousers down blatantly misusing (and possibly mispresenting) a REIT to evade £120,000 in Witholding Tax. 

https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2026/04/11/rich...dividends/
Reply
#2
(04-12-2026, 11:47 AM)Protheroe Wrote: As someone who runs 3 limited companies including a propco (and several other propcos & SPVs in the past) - and pays all taxes that are legally due - it strikes me as morally bankrupt that our politicians seem to think compliance is for the plebs like me.

Rayner went out of her way to construct a framework to avoid paying the correct SDLT.

Now Tice has been caught with his trousers down blatantly misusing (and possibly mispresenting) a REIT to evade £120,000 in Witholding Tax. 

https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2026/04/11/rich...dividends/

That's a pretty detailed report! Although Tice dismisses it with a couple of paragraphs that are a much easier read for those that can't be bothered to look into the representatives they choose. Scary.
Reply
#3
It's a far clearer case than Rayner's tbh. You have to ask why the HMRC hasn't acted on this already, they really are a exceptionally badly run organisation.

Again, both cases illustrate why tax simplification is so desperately needed. I'm sure I'd end up paying more, but for every additional £1 I reckon it'd be 80p less in accountancy fees and hours and hours less aggravation which I can also put a value on.
Reply
#4
(04-12-2026, 12:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It's a far clearer case than Rayner's tbh. You have to ask why the HMRC hasn't acted on this already, they really are a exceptionally badly run organisation.

Again, both cases illustrate why tax simplification is so desperately needed. I'm sure I'd end up paying more, but for every additional £1 I reckon it'd be 80p less in accountancy fees and hours and hours less aggravation which I can also put a value on.

Agree. Although a whole industry will argue against it.
Reply
#5
The commentary in the media about these two things tells you everything you need to know.

Rayner hounded and forced to resign.

Tumbleweed on Tice.

What's the difference?
Reply
#6
Tbf Rayner was deputy PM.
Reply
#7
Has Tice been charged with anything yet?

Protheroe's attitude is interesting, a few months ago he described anyone who paid inheritance tax as stupid, pointing out how the Duke of Westminster was able to avoid it. He does not appear so sympathetic to Mr Tice!
Reply
#8
(04-14-2026, 09:47 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Tbf Rayner was deputy PM.

What's the difference?

They're both MPs. They're both subject to the same rules. They both broke those rules. Yet the treatment of them is vastly different. Why?
Reply
#9
(04-14-2026, 10:03 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Has Tice been charged with anything yet?

Protheroe's attitude is interesting, a few months ago he described anyone who paid inheritance tax as stupid, pointing out how the Duke of Westminster was able to avoid it. He does not appear so sympathetic to Mr Tice!

Because IHT s entirely avoidable using legal means.

Tice appears to have evaded tax that was legally due.

I might add that the changes to BPR mean that JCB is considering domiciling itself in the states to avoid a huge tax hit on the death of the current head of the family firm. Hoe does that help anyone?
Reply
#10
(04-14-2026, 10:40 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-14-2026, 10:03 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Has Tice been charged with anything yet?

Protheroe's attitude is interesting, a few months ago he described anyone who paid inheritance tax as stupid, pointing out how the Duke of Westminster was able to avoid it. He does not appear so sympathetic to Mr Tice!

Because IHT s entirely avoidable using legal means.

Tice appears to have evaded tax that was legally due.

I might add that the changes to BPR mean that JCB is considering domiciling itself in the states to avoid a huge tax hit on the death of the current head of the family firm. Hoe does that help anyone?

Sounds like they've dug themselves into a bit of a hole there.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)