Reform Conference
#91
You do realise I said that the Civil Service should try to recruit people with ambition, not that they currently do? Because currently the only people who join that have said ambition are passing through or are on secondment from industry, both of which carry huge conflicts of interest the type of which we've seen manifesto at Ofwat. The fact is that the benefits that you talk about do not carry much weight anymore outside of job security, flexible working is the norm and the private sector can and does offer a lot more generous pension schemes than they used to which add up with the increased pay. It isn't 1999 anymore, final salary pensions are long gone replaced with average salary DB instead and the advantages the CS had over flexible working don't exist anymore.
Reply
#92
In my experience all many public sector folk are looking for at work is security, flexible working, a much better DB pension than they would get outside (still) and the general notion of being moved sideways rather than sacked if anything goes wrong. The vast majority of civil servants are not senior in rank, the private sector pays neither the wages nor the anything like the same benefits to them.

And that is the point. A rump of low-performing, unambitious, unsackable public apparatchiks are asking to stay at home more "cos petrol prices". Fuck that.
Reply
#93
It's like you've completely ignored every single word I've written. Who are you responding to, yourself?
Reply
#94
I haven't ignored it. I'm just returning to the point we started at.

Yes the Civil Service ought to employ ambitious people but why would ambitious people be drawn to sclerotic and insular institutions more concerned with their own survival than the public good, or God forbid a profit motive?
Reply
#95
(04-02-2026, 02:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I haven't ignored it. I'm just returning to the point we started at.

Yes the Civil Service ought to employ ambitious people but why would ambitious people be drawn to sclerotic and insular institutions more concerned with their own survival than the public good, or God forbid a profit motive?

Odd you should say that, for I once applied for a CS job - based on bringing profitable, sustained yet specialised international trade and industry to the UK (which is what I’ve done quite nicely out of my entire career) - and didn’t get it. They didn’t give a specific reason (and were actually really nice about it - perhaps the most polite rejection I’ve ever had), but I strongly suspect their reasoning to be my complete lack of of public sector experience. I think some internal pen-pusher got it in the end. 

But you see, Growth is a magic word, so we will all be OK.
Reply
#96
Different take I’m coming up to retirement worked hard all my life
Started at 16 hopefully finishing at 66.5 mostly in engineering
Will have a full state pension around 12 grand a year and various
Work pensions which add up to around 6.5 grand a year which will be taxed
I am lucky enough to have a bit of savings which I will use to supplement
The above.
I tell my kids try and pay into a private pension as much as you can afford
But it is difficult in today’s world when having ordinary jobs
Education is the key my mom & dad knew nothing about pensions
So I followed suit

As the saying goes I came in with nothing and will go out with nothing.
Reply
#97
(04-02-2026, 05:38 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(04-02-2026, 02:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I haven't ignored it. I'm just returning to the point we started at.

Yes the Civil Service ought to employ ambitious people but why would ambitious people be drawn to sclerotic and insular institutions more concerned with their own survival than the public good, or God forbid a profit motive?

Odd you should say that, for I once applied for a CS job - based on bringing profitable, sustained yet specialised international trade and industry to the UK (which is what I’ve done quite nicely out of my entire career) - and didn’t get it. They didn’t give a specific reason (and were actually really nice about it - perhaps the most polite rejection I’ve ever had), but I strongly suspect their reasoning to be my complete lack of of public sector experience. I think some internal pen-pusher got it in the end. 

But you see, Growth is a magic word, so we will all be OK.

Precisely. Public authorities choose to recruit people who will act accordingly. Why rock the boat with innovation or commercial nous?
Reply
#98
(04-03-2026, 11:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-02-2026, 05:38 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(04-02-2026, 02:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I haven't ignored it. I'm just returning to the point we started at.

Yes the Civil Service ought to employ ambitious people but why would ambitious people be drawn to sclerotic and insular institutions more concerned with their own survival than the public good, or God forbid a profit motive?

Odd you should say that, for I once applied for a CS job - based on bringing profitable, sustained yet specialised international trade and industry to the UK (which is what I’ve done quite nicely out of my entire career) - and didn’t get it. They didn’t give a specific reason (and were actually really nice about it - perhaps the most polite rejection I’ve ever had), but I strongly suspect their reasoning to be my complete lack of of public sector experience. I think some internal pen-pusher got it in the end. 

But you see, Growth is a magic word, so we will all be OK.

Precisely. Public authorities choose to recruit people who will act accordingly. Why rock the boat with innovation or commercial nous?

Yep. During my cover letter, I even tried to turn my lack of civil service experience from a con to a pro. Basically stating that I’d made stacks for them via various mechanisms (corporation tax from the profitable work I’d won, 95% of which external i.e. non-UK sales orders, a lot of income tax and NI generated therefrom - not just from me - but the sizeable team(s) I’d grown to turn those orders into export sales), and that it would be great not only seeing how I can continue to make this happen ‘from the other side of the coin’ as it were, but also knew precisely (first hand in fact) what the UK presently lacked in making export sales easier and more commonly achievable for aspiring creative/innovative SMEs; and the typical export obstacles so many face. I’d made companies who’d struggle to send an international letter by air mail into frequent, regular, profitable net-exporters. And of actual ‘things’, i.e. stuff we had made - not mere services - which also require skills, education and upstream expertise to fulfil, therefore benefitting many more localised suppliers additionally. 

Anyway, all fell on deaf ears. Probably went instead to a lad named Tristan who knows fuck all about industry but can fill in a pointless form like the back of his hand.
Reply
#99
Fascists lose seat in a council that they control
A good day.

BBC News - Greens win by-election to replace jailed councillor
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cdxde5e4rngo
Reply
The runner up was brilliant in Disney's The Great Mouse Detective.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)