Are we better without MJ?
#21
I don't think our upturn in form has anything to do with the players available to Mozza, it's all about fitness, coaching and pragmatic tactics. Mason seemed to be very limited in his ambition and in his ability to utilise the squad. Ramsay seemed to be over-ambitious in his intention to change things and in his vision of what these players could do. Mozza and Matt Gill are making the best of what we've got and playing to the strengths of the squad. Old-fashioned it may be, but coaches "got away with it" for decades.

Are we better without MJ? No, I think he would be a good option to have available. I'm glad Grant got mentioned further up the thread. How would he fit in? Don't know, but it would be good to have the option.

It works both ways. I've been a stern critic of Chris Mepham, but if you ask me "are we better without Mepham?", the answer is "I don't know". He might be better alongside Campbell than Phillips. It'll be interesting to see what Mozza does when Mepham is fit, but I'm guessing he won't drop Campbell any time soon.
Reply
#22
(03-22-2026, 08:30 PM)Majas magic Wrote:
(03-22-2026, 07:22 PM)Peachofacross Wrote: MJ is absolute quality imo. It's only a shame he got injured 15 mins into Mozza's reign. I think he would be revelling in this 4-4-2 personally on the left or right.

I really like the look of Price coming in off the left like he does for Ireland but I'd still love it if MJ was fit now and we had the option.

We are doing better now because we are playing a system and style that suits our squad make up not because MJ is injured. We'd be a much stronger squad for having MJ fit.

Didn’t he get injured the game before Mozza ? When everything felt very different.

It's like everyone is just blanking out Oxford being part of the Morrison reign, and I'm here for it.  Big Grin
Reply
#23
No.

The fact Grant should’ve been included in the OP along with Mikey says it all.

On Saturday I noticed how we use the left wing less, since Mikey and Grant are no longer available.  Mikey needs 2 defenders to try to eliminate his threat, creating space elsewhere.

Until Grant can play 90 mins, Price is ok as a makeshift. But it goes back to playing players in their natural / best position.  Mikey is head and shoulders our best left winger and if anything, we miss him.
Reply
#24
(03-22-2026, 07:22 PM)Peachofacross Wrote: MJ is absolute quality imo. It's only a shame he got injured 15 mins into Mozza's reign. I think he would be revelling in this 4-4-2 personally on the left or right.

I really like the look of Price coming in off the left like he does for Ireland but I'd still love it if MJ was fit now and we had the option.

We are doing better now because we are playing a system and style that suits our squad make up not because MJ is injured. We'd be a much stronger squad for having MJ fit.

This is my my opinion. I think MJ would fit in perfectly on the left or right hand side in the current formation. The fact the players are doing so well now without him is testament to what a job Morrison is doing. We've lost arguably our best player yet we've managed to overcome that.
Reply
#25
(03-23-2026, 08:13 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(03-22-2026, 07:22 PM)Peachofacross Wrote: MJ is absolute quality imo. It's only a shame he got injured 15 mins into Mozza's reign. I think he would be revelling in this 4-4-2 personally on the left or right.

I really like the look of Price coming in off the left like he does for Ireland but I'd still love it if MJ was fit now and we had the option.

We are doing better now because we are playing a system and style that suits our squad make up not because MJ is injured. We'd be a much stronger squad for having MJ fit.

This is my my opinion. I think MJ would fit in perfectly on the left or right hand side in the current formation. The fact the players are doing so well now without him is testament to what a job Morrison is doing. We've lost arguably our best player yet we've managed to overcome that.

Agree. One of the problems we had under previous coaches was that we had a tricky player who could beat defenders but rarely had the support or an overlap option. And when defences doubled up or trebled up on him we didn't move it quickly enough to take advantage of spaces and gaps elsewhere.
Reply
#26
(03-22-2026, 10:49 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(03-22-2026, 07:48 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-22-2026, 07:24 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: In reply to Bob, I think - mostly due to poor tactics, coaching and deployment, not to mention having too few outlets - we just haven’t seen enough quality from Mowatt this year. I don’t know him personally, but he seems genuine (and has a definite fanboy following on here), but it isn’t doing him any harm whatsoever having to compete for his place back whilst shaking whatever knocks he reportedly has been playing with.

The fact we don’t miss him currently doesn’t mean we don’t/won’t need him before too long. He’s one CM sending-off away from becoming a critical part of the side again.

Meanwhile, why bemoan genuine competition for places, in a formation that - finally - suits us. If Molumby or Diakite picks up an injury or suspension, all of a sudden he becomes very important again. That isn’t a bad place to be.
I didn’t bemoan anything. Stop bemoaning me when I’m not even bemoaning. Caprice?

You’re bemoaning my post!

But OK, poor choice of words I know. But I think it’s a good thing we’ve players of Mowatt’s potential calibre that can’t at present get in the side. He could (as I’ve said before) be very important towards the season’s end should we suffer some unfortunate selection luck in the middle. I agree entirely though that Molumby and Diakite are presently undroppable, on recent form. Especially the latter, whom since his return from compassionate leave looks like a new signing.
I know and am definitely not anti Mowatt, I just think we need Diakite's aggression and energy more than Mowatt's composure, at this moment in time.
Reply
#27
(03-23-2026, 06:04 AM)RamsAy it Wrote: No.

The fact Grant should’ve been included in the OP along with Mikey says it all.

On Saturday I noticed how we use the left wing less, since Mikey and Grant are no longer available.  Mikey needs 2 defenders to try to eliminate his threat, creating space elsewhere.

Until Grant can play 90 mins, Price is ok as a makeshift. But it goes back to playing players in their natural / best position.  Mikey is head and shoulders our best left winger and if anything, we miss him.
We’ll agree to disagree about that one, I didn’t include Grant in the OP because I personally think we are better off without him and I’ll be glad when his contract expires. Just my opinion of course, I know others rate him but his goals and assists stats this season (3 and 0) say it all for me.
Reply
#28
MJ's problem in being effective is not of his own making, it's down to the coaching and tactics.

He's had to pick up the ball deep in our half and carry it 70 yards  in a shit team, with shit tactics, courtesy of the two previous clueless coaches.

In the Mozza's  set up he would be receiving the ball well into the opposition half,  and probably only have to beat one man to get a cross or a shot in.
Reply
#29
(03-23-2026, 10:28 AM)Johnny akes Wrote:
(03-23-2026, 06:04 AM)RamsAy it Wrote: No.

The fact Grant should’ve been included in the OP along with Mikey says it all.

On Saturday I noticed how we use the left wing less, since Mikey and Grant are no longer available.  Mikey needs 2 defenders to try to eliminate his threat, creating space elsewhere.

Until Grant can play 90 mins, Price is ok as a makeshift. But it goes back to playing players in their natural / best position.  Mikey is head and shoulders our best left winger and if anything, we miss him.
We’ll agree to disagree about that one, I didn’t include Grant in the OP because I personally think we are better off without him and I’ll be glad when his contract expires. Just my opinion of course, I know others rate him but his goals and assists stats this season (3 and 0) say it all for me.

With Price able to cover left wing and possibly Styles too, I’d be surprised if Grant is offered a new contract.  So you’ll be happy Big Grin
Reply
#30
(03-23-2026, 08:59 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-22-2026, 10:49 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(03-22-2026, 07:48 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-22-2026, 07:24 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: In reply to Bob, I think - mostly due to poor tactics, coaching and deployment, not to mention having too few outlets - we just haven’t seen enough quality from Mowatt this year. I don’t know him personally, but he seems genuine (and has a definite fanboy following on here), but it isn’t doing him any harm whatsoever having to compete for his place back whilst shaking whatever knocks he reportedly has been playing with.

The fact we don’t miss him currently doesn’t mean we don’t/won’t need him before too long. He’s one CM sending-off away from becoming a critical part of the side again.

Meanwhile, why bemoan genuine competition for places, in a formation that - finally - suits us. If Molumby or Diakite picks up an injury or suspension, all of a sudden he becomes very important again. That isn’t a bad place to be.
I didn’t bemoan anything. Stop bemoaning me when I’m not even bemoaning. Caprice?

You’re bemoaning my post!

But OK, poor choice of words I know. But I think it’s a good thing we’ve players of Mowatt’s potential calibre that can’t at present get in the side. He could (as I’ve said before) be very important towards the season’s end should we suffer some unfortunate selection luck in the middle. I agree entirely though that Molumby and Diakite are presently undroppable, on recent form. Especially the latter, whom since his return from compassionate leave looks like a new signing.
I know and am definitely not anti Mowatt, I just think we need Diakite's aggression and energy more than Mowatt's composure, at this moment in time.

I’m in complete agreement, Mr Fossil. It’s all part and parcel of that ‘back to basics’ approach we needed - and is working - right now. I think Mowatt is better suited to games he can gradually help us build aggressive play, and that needs decent wingers and fully fit and firing forwards (whom besides Hedgehog, I wouldn’t say either of the other two are, just yet). And on the flanks, besides Jed, and the loanee seal, we haven’t any fit enough to help Mowatt do his Mowatt thing. To bring it back to topic, given his preference positionally, he’s better with an MJ or a Grant to work beside him. 

Meanwhile, I’m happy for Uzi to be the hard man, and Mozza really seems to be getting the best from Molumby. It’s hardly a surprise, as (during his playing days) they’re similar types of player (wish Jimmy could somehow teach both to shoot, though). But that CH pairing picks itself right now. 

Just hope many staying home and not busy during the break get the rest they need. Especially Jed, who looked fucked by the time he came off Satdee. The one thing he lacks right now is stamina.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)