Learning from the mistakes of the 1970s oil crisis
#1
Accelerate new nuclear power station development via funding GB Energy to create joint enterprises with EDF, KEPCO and Hitachi, grant GB Energy licences to extract O+G from the North Sea and DO NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES privatise it, keep windfall taxes on Shell and BP and ringfence it to fund new nuclear, grid expansion and intensive industry subsidies, double down on LDES, build more interconnectors, put every major conurbation with a central population of over 1m inhabitants onto a heat network and decouple heat network charges from gas, electrify more railways via a rolling programme, ensure that nobody as stupid as Nigel Lawson gets anywhere near the Treasury or Energy Departments, tell the SNP, Greens, Tories and Reform to suck a lemon, double down on carbon border mechanisms.

We cannot afford a repeat of the idiocy of 1980s and 1990s energy policy again.
Reply
#2
The future of SMRs looks interesting, as the ‘ideal’ carbon neutral grid currently lacks the (comparatively) instant switch-on, switch-off capability of smaller CCGTs.

Wind and solar are, well, what they are, and you can’t just switch on a traditional BWR or PWR at a moment’s notice during peak periods of consumption.

I’m with you on the rest, though. Doosan and Toshiba would additionally make equally suitable JV partners for public nuke investment.
Reply
#3
(03-20-2026, 07:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Accelerate new nuclear power station development via funding GB Energy to create joint enterprises with EDF, KEPCO and Hitachi, grant GB Energy licences to extract O+G from the North Sea and DO NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES privatise it, keep windfall taxes on Shell and BP and ringfence it to fund new nuclear, grid expansion and intensive industry subsidies, double down on LDES, build more interconnectors, put every major conurbation with a central population of over 1m inhabitants onto a heat network and decouple heat network charges from gas, electrify more railways via a rolling programme, ensure that nobody as stupid as Nigel Lawson gets anywhere near the Treasury or Energy Departments, tell the SNP, Greens, Tories and Reform to suck a lemon, double down on carbon border mechanisms.

We cannot afford a repeat of the idiocy of 1980s and 1990s energy policy again.

Why are you disparaging about Nigel Lawson? He was an intelligent man, I assume anybody you disagree with 
politically is stupid! I did not vote for the Conservatives either.
Reply
#4
(03-23-2026, 03:14 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(03-20-2026, 07:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Accelerate new nuclear power station development via funding GB Energy to create joint enterprises with EDF, KEPCO and Hitachi, grant GB Energy licences to extract O+G from the North Sea and DO NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES privatise it, keep windfall taxes on Shell and BP and ringfence it to fund new nuclear, grid expansion and intensive industry subsidies, double down on LDES, build more interconnectors, put every major conurbation with a central population of over 1m inhabitants onto a heat network and decouple heat network charges from gas, electrify more railways via a rolling programme, ensure that nobody as stupid as Nigel Lawson gets anywhere near the Treasury or Energy Departments, tell the SNP, Greens, Tories and Reform to suck a lemon, double down on carbon border mechanisms.

We cannot afford a repeat of the idiocy of 1980s and 1990s energy policy again.

Why are you disparaging about Nigel Lawson? He was an intelligent man, I assume anybody you disagree with 
politically is stupid! I did not vote for the Conservatives either.

An intelligent man that killed off the domestic nuclear power industry and then lobbied against the veracity of not only anthropogenic climate change but all climate change for decades? He's the reason our energy bills are fucked pal.
Reply
#5
(03-23-2026, 10:19 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-23-2026, 03:14 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(03-20-2026, 07:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Accelerate new nuclear power station development via funding GB Energy to create joint enterprises with EDF, KEPCO and Hitachi, grant GB Energy licences to extract O+G from the North Sea and DO NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES privatise it, keep windfall taxes on Shell and BP and ringfence it to fund new nuclear, grid expansion and intensive industry subsidies, double down on LDES, build more interconnectors, put every major conurbation with a central population of over 1m inhabitants onto a heat network and decouple heat network charges from gas, electrify more railways via a rolling programme, ensure that nobody as stupid as Nigel Lawson gets anywhere near the Treasury or Energy Departments, tell the SNP, Greens, Tories and Reform to suck a lemon, double down on carbon border mechanisms.

We cannot afford a repeat of the idiocy of 1980s and 1990s energy policy again.

Why are you disparaging about Nigel Lawson? He was an intelligent man, I assume anybody you disagree with 
politically is stupid! I did not vote for the Conservatives either.

An intelligent man that killed off the domestic nuclear power industry and then lobbied against the veracity of not only anthropogenic climate change but all climate change for decades? He's the reason our energy bills are fucked pal.

I remember listening to the twat in that infamous R4 Today interview where he expounded his views on man made climate change without scientific challenge. I was absolutely stunned by it and it battered my faith in the BBC. Wasn't it him who ended MIRAS which had a profound negative effect of the housing market. Basically a Tory Tosser
Reply
#6
Showing your political colours!

MIRAS ended years ago, it hardly had a long lasting negative effect on the housing market.
Reply
#7
(03-22-2026, 06:21 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: The future of SMRs looks interesting, as the ‘ideal’ carbon neutral grid currently lacks the (comparatively) instant switch-on, switch-off capability of smaller CCGTs.

Wind and solar are, well, what they are, and you can’t just switch on a traditional BWR or PWR at a moment’s notice during peak periods of consumption. 

I’m with you on the rest, though. Doosan and Toshiba would additionally make equally suitable JV partners for public nuke investment.

The problem with SMRs is that they're less economically efficient than larger reactors and none of them will be likely to be approved for use until the middle of the next decade. They may well be suitable for demand management (especially data centre demand) to reduce grid strain but I'm still unconvinced as to there actual viability, France and South Korea are the poster boys for nuclear power and neither have needed them. For the general power mix they just smack of a copout from people who don't want to pay capital costs but that just means higher costs on the long term which doesn't help with energy bills. 

With respect to wind and solar, the development of BESS definitely makes the latter reliable in the UK even in winter and especially if you get more BESS applications into the 12-hour+ timeframe as is happening in China now. And Spain has shown how renewables can help insulate from energy price shocks caused by fossil fuels.
Reply
#8
(03-23-2026, 10:57 AM)Pontificator Wrote: MIRAS which had a profound negative effect of the housing market. Basically a Tory Tosser

So you're against the removal of subsidies to mortgage payers?
Reply
#9
(03-24-2026, 10:23 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-22-2026, 06:21 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: The future of SMRs looks interesting, as the ‘ideal’ carbon neutral grid currently lacks the (comparatively) instant switch-on, switch-off capability of smaller CCGTs.

Wind and solar are, well, what they are, and you can’t just switch on a traditional BWR or PWR at a moment’s notice during peak periods of consumption. 

I’m with you on the rest, though. Doosan and Toshiba would additionally make equally suitable JV partners for public nuke investment.

The problem with SMRs is that they're less economically efficient than larger reactors and none of them will be likely to be approved for use until the middle of the next decade. They may well be suitable for demand management (especially data centre demand) to reduce grid strain but I'm still unconvinced as to there actual viability, France and South Korea are the poster boys for nuclear power and neither have needed them. For the general power mix they just smack of a copout from people who don't want to pay capital costs but that just means higher costs on the long term which doesn't help with energy bills. 

With respect to wind and solar, the development of BESS definitely makes the latter reliable in the UK even in winter and especially if you get more BESS applications into the 12-hour+ timeframe as is happening in China now. And Spain has shown how renewables can help insulate from energy price shocks caused by fossil fuels.

I get their inherent inefficiency by comparison, but that’s not what we’re talking here unless I’m mistaken? It’s the ability to quickly switch on and off that appeals - like any power producing plant, of course bigger is always better when it comes to being more efficient. Even earlier wind turbines weren’t viable commercially at one point without FITs, so it’s a start, at least.

So yep - sadly there is no overnight ‘click-your-fingers’ solution for the UK, hence the need to keep CCGTs going (at least just for now). BESS is great, and will only improve over time, but do we know much about the mess it makes afterwards? I know nuclear waste is hardly candy-floss, but I do wonder what we’ll do with the effluence of all of these new battery solutions; since no matter how ‘reusable’ they claim to be, nothing is ever ‘truly’ as such (without producing some pretty horrid waste). I do stand welcome to be corrected here, however, as it really isn’t my area of expertise. 

Spain and China are also large enough countries to mean the wind will generally be blowing, somewhere. They lend themselves well to BESS backing up something else. Especially with the latter’s hydro generation capacity. France just simply sells what it doesn’t need, or just powers down across the board when it can’t. Can’t speak for Korea, but again I bet China or Taiwan (assuming they can) are happy to buy any oversupply. Neither country you mention really needs SMRs.

Personally I’d like to see more thrown at tidal generation, also. We certainly have the tides...
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)