Calmed down
#51
(03-02-2026, 03:47 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(03-02-2026, 03:44 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: I'm sure Bany being injured twice and missing the entire season wasn't part of the plan when we bought him. 20/20 hindsight is very easy.

Bany had suffered with serious injuries before joining us. Missing the season may not have been part of the plan, but the research beforehand would have showed you this was an expensive gamble. Another poor decision these guys have made.
The Bany purchase would have been fine had we not decided to put all our eggs in his basket as the number ten. We have consequently played a full season without a proper number ten.
Reply
#52
(03-02-2026, 07:40 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-02-2026, 06:50 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(03-02-2026, 05:03 PM)SmethwickEnd Wrote:
(03-02-2026, 04:55 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(03-02-2026, 04:00 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote: The damage started with selling Palmer losing a decent keeper for 3 million was a stupid decision
And then selling Fellows for 7 million was another ridiculous decision
At least we got decent money for Heggem but we haven’t reinvested wisely
I have been going for over 50 + years but my loyalty is being tested big time
At the moment looking forward to going to Halesowen Saturday a day off
From our wasters.

Palmer, Fellows and Heggem is almost £20m in fees. I'd expect any scouting network worth its salt to be able to produce a PO team at this level with that kind of money.

That money was used to bring ourselves back in line with PSR restrictions. We never had £20m to spend.

Well then we were fucked from the get go weren't we. Someone had to be sold, stands to reason that the ones sold will be the ones people want to buy.

We had a percentage of that money to reinvest. Hence the reason we bought players like Price and Bany in.

Price and Bany were the window before. Summer window was about replacing the entire defence. Partially because the contracts were allowed to expire, partially because injury woes caught up with them, partially because they were the only saleable assets.

The number 10 position probably didn’t even factor all that much. We’d got Bany in the Jan, Maja ready to come back, Price had more than filled in during his period with us up to that point.
Reply
#53
(03-01-2026, 11:57 PM)Old Fart Wrote: Trev the Shed had more idea than this lot.  

I fear we are in for a period of chaos until a Jeremy Peace character emerges with yet another change of ownership and a clear strategy emerges with the funds and know how required.

Peace rode on back of Paul Thompson. Along with Megson he is the one we had to thank for our resurrection

(03-02-2026, 09:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-02-2026, 07:53 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(03-01-2026, 10:04 PM)Sliced Wrote: As I've said before, I genuinely don't put a blame on the players for this situation. It's all from above. For anyone wondering what the strategy is with regards to the players:

1. Get rid of higher earners that we can, replace with cheaper from abroad/youth/lower leagues.

2. Any of those that turn out to be decent, sell those on as well and replace.

3. Repeat.

So who does that leave you with? A team primarily made up of the ones that no one else wants and the less good players we've signed while the decent ones have been sold off.

The managerial strategy is "get in a young up and coming manager without really vetting them". Seemingly because it's progressive, but the manager is the most important decision of the football club and now 3 times in a row we've gotten it completely wrong....and it's quite likely Raphael Wicky would have been a pile of shite too if Nestor chose him.

What we have now is a mish mash of players who hardly know each other; a keeper who's never been particularly good but gets zero protection from a centre back partnership (any of them) that hasn't been coached to be a cohesive unit at any point this season. We have what is likely our best centre back out at right back because all of our other right back options are a million miles away from being adequate at this level, Styles who is arguably first name on the team sheet despite being brought in as a utility backup player. Moving into midfield there's Mowatt and Molumby who loads seem to have a problem with one or the other, they clash when playing together but the only other semi-reasonable alternatives are Diakite who is fine at breaking up play but allergic to passing forwards (actually just passing in general, I don't think I've seen a footballer struggle to kick a ball in a straight line before) and Styles who might be ok but we have no viable alternative at left back, so we have to play them. Price was alright initially but he's clearly not a player for a relegation battle, our wide players are children, OAPs or injured and our striking choices are Maja who's unfit, Dike who's not the same after being injured and Heggebo who's out of form.

Other than that we're alright.


I do take a more che sera sera view than birdy though. I'm not happy with our plight but what will be will be. Eventually we'll get to a League where we start winning some games, even if it's in a few seasons time Big Grin

Points 1 and 2 are why Coventry are top the league and why Norwich are the form side this calendar year.

Coventry sold Gyokeres and Hamer and built a title winning team with the proceeds. 

Norwich got rid of Sargent and signed Meghoma, Toure and Ahmed and now they look a totally different side, albeit with a better manager. They also signed Makama from League One for cost of a Chris Mepham that we didn't need.

We sold out best players and replaced them with shit, we didn't have to. The £10m we got for Fellows could have signed us those players that Norwich did. Our scouting and player ID has been awful the last 18 months. I've no problem with the method, every issue with the execution.

Coventry posted over £20m losses last year thanks to investment in the squad and Lampard. They have spent two decades homeless, pot less and only now thanks to relatively new owners pumping millions into the club are they able to compete. There is no such thing as a successful self sufficient club in the Championship, where you buy players cheap and sell for a huge profit, year after year. 

Let’s stop using Coventry as an example of good practice unless our owners offer ‘significant external investment’ beyond sales of players. 

Coventry finances

Not sure where the Cov owners are getting the money from bar player sales? Doug King isn't particularly rich. His brother made sone money (and he had a small investment in) selling King of Shaves. Doug lived with my brother in a shared/rented house when they worked together for Cargill in Liverpool in the early 90s. He's a Norwich fan. Think he's done ok in business but doesn’t have the wealth the Patels do.
Reply
#54
(03-03-2026, 05:54 AM)SmethwickEnd Wrote: Price and Bany were the window before. Summer window was about replacing the entire defence. Partially because the contracts were allowed to expire, partially because injury woes caught up with them, partially because they were the only saleable assets.

The number 10 position probably didn’t even factor all that much. We’d got Bany in the Jan, Maja ready to come back, Price had more than filled in during his period with us up to that point.

I think there are 2 factors here too...

First is we replaced a defence that contained Ajayi and Heggem, two players with pace and technique, with Bielik, Phillips and Mepham who haven't got an ounce of pace between them, and in Campbell are using our only semi pacy CB out wide... even Holgate had legs. And, secondly, there was a huge, cumulative failing in our attack, either we overestimated the physical capabilties of Maja and Dike to overcome injuries, or our coaches and recruitment strategy failed to prepare this part of the squad effectively.

I can sympathise on the right side sales - we absolutely wouldn't have anticipated the Furlong sale but it was too good to turn down, and Fellows we HAD to sell and didn't get the money we anticipated, but this does no excuse us spending a fee and committing decent wages to both Bielik and Mepham when we knew we would need a pacy, right sided player when Fellows was sold. I think the unexpected Bartley retirement sent us into a panic in terms of needing a physical presence, experience and leader at the back - hence Mepham, Taylor, Bielik arriving. I'd wager had Bartley retired a few weeks sooner, we probably wouldn't have sold Taylor.

I guess it's all just one massive fucking mess really.
Reply
#55
(03-03-2026, 10:17 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-03-2026, 05:54 AM)SmethwickEnd Wrote: Price and Bany were the window before. Summer window was about replacing the entire defence. Partially because the contracts were allowed to expire, partially because injury woes caught up with them, partially because they were the only saleable assets.

The number 10 position probably didn’t even factor all that much. We’d got Bany in the Jan, Maja ready to come back, Price had more than filled in during his period with us up to that point.

I think there are 2 factors here too...

First is we replaced a defence that contained Ajayi and Heggem, two players with pace and technique, with Bielik, Phillips and Mepham who haven't got an ounce of pace between them, and in Campbell are using our only semi pacy CB out wide... even Holgate had legs. And, secondly, there was a huge, cumulative failing in our attack, either we overestimated the physical capabilties of Maja and Dike to overcome injuries, or our coaches and recruitment strategy failed to prepare this part of the squad effectively.

I can sympathise on the right side sales - we absolutely wouldn't have anticipated the Furlong sale but it was too good to turn down, and Fellows we HAD to sell and didn't get the money we anticipated, but this does no excuse us spending a fee and committing decent wages to both Bielik and Mepham when we knew we would need a pacy, right sided player when Fellows was sold. I think the unexpected Bartley retirement sent us into a panic in terms of needing a physical presence, experience and leader at the back - hence Mepham, Taylor, Bielik arriving. I'd wager had Bartley retired a few weeks sooner, we probably wouldn't have sold Taylor.

I guess it's all just one massive fucking mess really.

Have you been listening to the Albion Analysis podcast by any chance? They were also lamenting the lack of place in the team due to poor recruitment.
Reply
#56
(03-03-2026, 11:21 AM)Squid Wrote:
(03-03-2026, 10:17 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-03-2026, 05:54 AM)SmethwickEnd Wrote: Price and Bany were the window before. Summer window was about replacing the entire defence. Partially because the contracts were allowed to expire, partially because injury woes caught up with them, partially because they were the only saleable assets.

The number 10 position probably didn’t even factor all that much. We’d got Bany in the Jan, Maja ready to come back, Price had more than filled in during his period with us up to that point.

I think there are 2 factors here too...

First is we replaced a defence that contained Ajayi and Heggem, two players with pace and technique, with Bielik, Phillips and Mepham who haven't got an ounce of pace between them, and in Campbell are using our only semi pacy  CB out wide... even Holgate had legs. And, secondly, there was a huge, cumulative failing in our attack, either we overestimated the physical capabilties of Maja and Dike to overcome injuries, or our coaches and recruitment strategy failed to prepare this part of the squad effectively.

I can sympathise on the right side sales - we absolutely wouldn't have anticipated the Furlong sale but it was too good to turn down, and Fellows we HAD to sell and didn't get the money we anticipated, but this does no excuse us spending a fee and committing decent wages to both Bielik and Mepham when we knew we would need a pacy, right sided player when Fellows was sold. I think the unexpected Bartley retirement sent us into a panic in terms of needing a physical presence, experience and leader at the back - hence Mepham, Taylor, Bielik arriving. I'd wager had Bartley retired a few weeks sooner, we probably wouldn't have sold Taylor.

I guess it's all just one massive fucking mess really.

Have you been listening to the Albion Analysis podcast by any chance? They were also lamenting the lack of place in the team due to poor recruitment.

I watched the E&S podcast by Drury and Lewis. Further confirmation, if needed, that we have a number of players within the club who are weak mentally. I think this has been an issue for a few years and several managers now
Reply
#57
(03-03-2026, 12:46 PM)Chippy Clark 1966 Wrote:
(03-03-2026, 11:21 AM)Squid Wrote:
(03-03-2026, 10:17 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-03-2026, 05:54 AM)SmethwickEnd Wrote: Price and Bany were the window before. Summer window was about replacing the entire defence. Partially because the contracts were allowed to expire, partially because injury woes caught up with them, partially because they were the only saleable assets.

The number 10 position probably didn’t even factor all that much. We’d got Bany in the Jan, Maja ready to come back, Price had more than filled in during his period with us up to that point.

I think there are 2 factors here too...

First is we replaced a defence that contained Ajayi and Heggem, two players with pace and technique, with Bielik, Phillips and Mepham who haven't got an ounce of pace between them, and in Campbell are using our only semi pacy  CB out wide... even Holgate had legs. And, secondly, there was a huge, cumulative failing in our attack, either we overestimated the physical capabilties of Maja and Dike to overcome injuries, or our coaches and recruitment strategy failed to prepare this part of the squad effectively.

I can sympathise on the right side sales - we absolutely wouldn't have anticipated the Furlong sale but it was too good to turn down, and Fellows we HAD to sell and didn't get the money we anticipated, but this does no excuse us spending a fee and committing decent wages to both Bielik and Mepham when we knew we would need a pacy, right sided player when Fellows was sold. I think the unexpected Bartley retirement sent us into a panic in terms of needing a physical presence, experience and leader at the back - hence Mepham, Taylor, Bielik arriving. I'd wager had Bartley retired a few weeks sooner, we probably wouldn't have sold Taylor.

I guess it's all just one massive fucking mess really.

Have you been listening to the Albion Analysis podcast by any chance? They were also lamenting the lack of place in the team due to poor recruitment.

I watched the E&S podcast by Drury and Lewis. Further confirmation, if needed, that we have a number of players within the club who are weak mentally. I think this has been an issue for a few years and several managers now

Agree Chippy. As evident from us not managing to win a must-win in recent memory.
Reply
#58
Our squad is well known for their mental fortitude in high pressure games.

It’ll serve us well in the coming weeks.
Reply
#59
(03-03-2026, 11:21 AM)Squid Wrote:
(03-03-2026, 10:17 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-03-2026, 05:54 AM)SmethwickEnd Wrote: Price and Bany were the window before. Summer window was about replacing the entire defence. Partially because the contracts were allowed to expire, partially because injury woes caught up with them, partially because they were the only saleable assets.

The number 10 position probably didn’t even factor all that much. We’d got Bany in the Jan, Maja ready to come back, Price had more than filled in during his period with us up to that point.

I think there are 2 factors here too...

First is we replaced a defence that contained Ajayi and Heggem, two players with pace and technique, with Bielik, Phillips and Mepham who haven't got an ounce of pace between them, and in Campbell are using our only semi pacy  CB out wide... even Holgate had legs. And, secondly, there was a huge, cumulative failing in our attack, either we overestimated the physical capabilties of Maja and Dike to overcome injuries, or our coaches and recruitment strategy failed to prepare this part of the squad effectively.

I can sympathise on the right side sales - we absolutely wouldn't have anticipated the Furlong sale but it was too good to turn down, and Fellows we HAD to sell and didn't get the money we anticipated, but this does no excuse us spending a fee and committing decent wages to both Bielik and Mepham when we knew we would need a pacy, right sided player when Fellows was sold. I think the unexpected Bartley retirement sent us into a panic in terms of needing a physical presence, experience and leader at the back - hence Mepham, Taylor, Bielik arriving. I'd wager had Bartley retired a few weeks sooner, we probably wouldn't have sold Taylor.

I guess it's all just one massive fucking mess really.

Have you been listening to the Albion Analysis podcast by any chance? They were also lamenting the lack of place in the team due to poor recruitment.

Listened to it on the way home tonight coincidentally, and as ever was regularly agreeing with everything Chris said… Joe Chapman annoys me as it just feels like he shows up and wings it saying generic man in the pub comments whereas Chris is prepared and researched, but it was as ever the best reflection on our position.

Love the idea of sticking Moore, Reid and Appleton in the dressing room to question players’ effort at full time.
Reply
#60
No disrespect but pointing out our squad lacks pace isn’t exactly going to surprise any fan who has paid attention
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: