Least Worst…
#31
This was always the likely outcome of this by-election? More Labour voters are likely to fall to the left when looking elsewhere. Labour have come third in what for a hundred years has been a 1 horse race.

It matters little out of GRN or REF who won imo, this is seismic for Starmer either way.
Reply
#32
The only positive is that Reform didn’t win. Good on the Greens but I’m not sure that they have what it takes to govern. At least Steamer gets the bloody nose he deserves.

Shame the Lib Dems didn’t do better but it’s hardly their hunting grounds.

Interesting comments about the family/influencing of voters at the booths. Wonder if any truth, or just the disappointeds getting their excuses out?
Reply
#33
(02-27-2026, 11:38 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: There is currently a bill going around Parliament introduced by the Lib Dems to replace FPTP with STV. It has passed the first reading. The Labour government have prevented it from being offered time for a second reading until the end of May and have tried to get Labour backbenchers to oppose it (thankfully failed - just - at the first reading). It is entirely possible for the next election to be under STV instead of FPTP if the government bothered to read the writing on the wall.

Sounds reasonable - that was all I was asking
Reply
#34
(02-27-2026, 11:20 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-27-2026, 11:19 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-27-2026, 11:06 AM)baggy1 Wrote: They've won a bi-election that had a very strong left leaning and cut the left majority from 13k to 4k. If they replicate that split of the left vote across the country Reform will win a landslide.

They won a by-election where Labour came third.

And if you are worried about vote splitting and Reform taking advantage of the spoiler effect you'd better start campaigning to replace FPTP.

Do you think they'll get that in place before the next election?

(02-27-2026, 11:20 AM)DemonicBaggie Wrote:
(02-27-2026, 11:06 AM)baggy1 Wrote: They've won a bi-election that had a very strong left leaning and cut the left majority from 13k to 4k. If they replicate that split of the left vote across the country Reform will win a landslide.

Statistics and spin, eh?

I bet the Greens are so worried about the increase in their vote they’ll honourably hand the constituency over to Reform. After all, how dare they gain votes from Labour! Actually, Labour lost this by-election the moment Starmer blocked Burnham, but hey ho. 

Ultimately this result matters for one reason only. It stopped Reform. For that I think the Greens deserve credit. 

Just look at how Farage/Goodwin/GBNews are floating the cheating conspiracies à la trump/Fox to know this defeat has revealed an extremely dangerous political party.

No spin DB, just stats and reality. It will work where there is a large left majority, but that is a situation that is few and far between. Labours 'landslide' at the last election is paper thin and splitting 90% (that's a guess btw, I haven't looked it up) of the left leaning seats in half will result in both Labour and the Greens losing that seat.

Burnham isn't the answer and he has a job to do, him just upping and leaving at this point will both damage the people that voted him in to do a job and the Labour party as it gives the right wing press even more ammunition. He will have a chance when he completes his term as Mayor. What was it that Burnham offered that Stogia didn't?

Fair comment, B1, I see your point and it's entirely valid - I just found it offering a rather negative take on a result which saw a party gain its first ever by-election win and, critically, defeating a party I regard as entirely pernicious (hence my comment about their undignified and conspiracy-ridden response to their defeat). We could have been looking this morning at a victory for Reform and it hasn't come to pass - that's something to celebrate and tbh I would have been pleased if ANYONE had kept them from sitting in that constituency. I believe it sends out the message that there is at least a viable challenge to the emergence of the far right, a position from which Labour has entirely abdicated. Interesting times indeed, not least for the attempted movement away from FPTP mentioned elsewhere.
Reply
#35
This election is a portent of what is to come in many inner city constituencies at the next election. The Left will be fighting like cats in a bag over sectarian issues culturally alien to the rest of the electorate, whilst something awful sweeps into power.
Reply
#36
(02-27-2026, 01:23 PM)Protheroe Wrote: This election is a portent of what is to come in many inner city constituencies at the next election. The Left will be fighting like cats in a bag over sectarian issues culturally alien to the rest of the electorate, whilst something awful sweeps into power.

What does this even mean.
Reply
#37
(02-27-2026, 01:31 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(02-27-2026, 01:23 PM)Protheroe Wrote: This election is a portent of what is to come in many inner city constituencies at the next election. The Left will be fighting like cats in a bag over sectarian issues culturally alien to the rest of the electorate, whilst something awful sweeps into power.

What does this even mean.

You can do your own research on the campaigns in Ladywood, Hodge Hill, Perry Barr & Yardley at the last election. Next time it'll be even worse, particularly if extremists decide that's the route to power and the Greens let them into the tent.
Reply
#38
(02-27-2026, 01:38 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-27-2026, 01:31 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(02-27-2026, 01:23 PM)Protheroe Wrote: This election is a portent of what is to come in many inner city constituencies at the next election. The Left will be fighting like cats in a bag over sectarian issues culturally alien to the rest of the electorate, whilst something awful sweeps into power.

What does this even mean.

You can do your own research on the campaigns in Ladywood, Hodge Hill, Perry Barr & Yardley at the last election. Next time it'll be even worse, particularly if extremists decide that's the route to power and the Greens let them into the tent.

Behave.

The Islamists are going to take our country from us and they are going to do it by voting en masse for a party led by a Jewish gay man
Reply
#39
(02-27-2026, 02:01 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(02-27-2026, 01:38 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-27-2026, 01:31 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(02-27-2026, 01:23 PM)Protheroe Wrote: This election is a portent of what is to come in many inner city constituencies at the next election. The Left will be fighting like cats in a bag over sectarian issues culturally alien to the rest of the electorate, whilst something awful sweeps into power.

What does this even mean.

You can do your own research on the campaigns in Ladywood, Hodge Hill, Perry Barr & Yardley at the last election. Next time it'll be even worse, particularly if extremists decide that's the route to power and the Greens let them into the tent.

Behave.

The Islamists are going to take our country from us and they are going to do it by voting en masse for a party led by a Jewish gay man

Extremists will vote for whoever gives them a route to power.
Reply
#40
(02-27-2026, 03:08 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-27-2026, 02:01 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(02-27-2026, 01:38 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-27-2026, 01:31 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(02-27-2026, 01:23 PM)Protheroe Wrote: This election is a portent of what is to come in many inner city constituencies at the next election. The Left will be fighting like cats in a bag over sectarian issues culturally alien to the rest of the electorate, whilst something awful sweeps into power.

What does this even mean.

You can do your own research on the campaigns in Ladywood, Hodge Hill, Perry Barr & Yardley at the last election. Next time it'll be even worse, particularly if extremists decide that's the route to power and the Greens let them into the tent.

Behave.

The Islamists are going to take our country from us and they are going to do it by voting en masse for a party led by a Jewish gay man

Extremists will vote for whoever gives them a route to power.

Or far more likely ordinary Muslim voters, will vote for the candidate most likely to beat the candidate who displays a huge level of antipathy towards their community.

You seem to be suggesting that the whole Muslim community is extremists.. whatever that means in this context.

And I would go further, we have absolutely no idea how individual Muslims voted in yesterday's by election.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: