Our group of players
#21
(02-18-2026, 06:25 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: 75% of our squad is good enough to get into 75% of teams in this division, that’s why for the most part we’ve been involved in tight games that have usually been decided by one goal - other than the blip where we shipped 8 in 2 games when we were missing defenders and midfielders aplenty.

The problem is that we lack creativity and pace and have been entirely dependent on Johnston, Mowatt and Heggebø. I doubt any other squad in the division has lacked these crucial ingredients as much as we have, and that’s why we are where we are.

Add to that poor coaching, poor management and terrible luck with niggling injuries and that’s why we are where we are. In another universe we’d have converted a few of thise defeats to draws and be looking at this year as a crap season of squad transition where we end up about 15th, but the silly points dropped are why we are where we are.

Good summary. I think if we can survive this year. Remodel the offensive side of the team and find a better more dynamic balance over the summer. ER will be more than good enough as a coach.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#22
(02-18-2026, 06:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-18-2026, 06:25 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: 75% of our squad is good enough to get into 75% of teams in this division, that’s why for the most part we’ve been involved in tight games that have usually been decided by one goal - other than the blip where we shipped 8 in 2 games when we were missing defenders and midfielders aplenty.

The problem is that we lack creativity and pace and have been entirely dependent on Johnston, Mowatt and Heggebø. I doubt any other squad in the division has lacked these crucial ingredients as much as we have, and that’s why we are where we are.

Add to that poor coaching, poor management and terrible luck with niggling injuries and that’s why we are where we are. In another universe we’d have converted a few of thise defeats to draws and be looking at this year as a crap season of squad transition where we end up about 15th, but the silly points dropped are why we are where we are.

Good summary. I think if we can survive this year. Remodel the offensive side of the team and find a better more dynamic balance over the summer. ER will be more than good enough as a coach.

Yes I think survival and modest investment with an average group of players, and an as yet unproven manager/coach, will make us an average team in an average league. 

  I've seen several comings of Messiahs over the years,  Ashman, Giles, Megson, Ronnie Allen and Fat Ron and even Ardilles to a lesser degree,  where serendipity smiled on them and their fortuitous inheritance of a core group of committed players, plus some astute signings - Cyrille-  and a bit of luck, changed the mentality of the players and the fans. 

Ramsay is not a new messiah, that's not his fault, but we're stuck in a rut of mediocrity until something radical happens again.  I know little about the current owners but right now they are hedging their bets.  They want to succeed but they are not going to bet their house on it and that's understandable. 

Something inspirational and exciting will turn up, it always does. But there's no sign of it at the moment and it could be a long wait. 

One final comment.  All of the above had an injection of kids we had scouted and recruited.   Cantello, Bomber, Statham, Bennett and many more.  We have an academy ( which I know nothing about) but other than Tom,  who else has come through the ranks ?      If the Villa are going to keep nicking good prospects, close it down and spend the money on proven players.  We appear to be fucking about nurturing players for other clubs. 

PS.  As usual I have had a drink.
Reply
#23
The squad is the worst we’ve had for twenty years. An expected consequence of selling out best players over the last 18mths. This is only sustainable if you have an exceptional recruitment team, management and DoF all working together. Given our recruitment this season even taking PSR restrictions into account we have failed to get close to replacing those who have left with better. Including DoF, manager(s) and scouting system. 

What is our reasoning when it comes to buying players? We buy Heggebo and sell arguably the best crosser of the ball to Southampton and bring in Price and Bany (this was factored in to his sale before he went), Price isn’t a replacement, and Bany is the invisible man. We waste money on an injury prone Bielik when we had Taylor who is both young and imo a much better prospect. What was the plan past reducing the wage bill? 

Are we recruiting for a possession based team? A counter attacking team? A hard working and disciplined team that grinds out results? Our squad just feels like a mismatch of players with no clear plan for how we play. I thought the plan was to data the shit out of the supercomputer and recruit smarter? The recruitment has been worse than GM and his Dad’s by a long, long way. 

I don’t know what we are trying to achieve on or off the pitch this season.
Reply
#24
(02-18-2026, 08:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The squad is the worst we’ve had for twenty years. An expected consequence of selling out best players over the last 18mths. This is only sustainable if you have an exceptional recruitment team, management and DoF all working together. Given our recruitment this season even taking PSR restrictions into account we have failed to get close to replacing those who have left with better. Including DoF, manager(s) and scouting system. 

What is our reasoning when it comes to buying players? We buy Heggebo and sell arguably the best crosser of the ball to Southampton and bring in Price and Bany (this was factored in to his sale before he went), Price isn’t a replacement, and Bany is the invisible man. We waste money on an injury prone Bielik when we had Taylor who is both young and imo a much better prospect. What was the plan past reducing the wage bill? 

Are we recruiting for a possession based team? A counter attacking team? A hard working and disciplined team that grinds out results? Our squad just feels like a mismatch of players with no clear plan for how we play. I thought the plan was to data the shit out of the supercomputer and recruit smarter? The recruitment has been worse than GM and his Dad’s by a long, long way. 

I don’t know what we are trying to achieve on or off the pitch this season.
Absolutely spot on this. 

Megson recruited based on character; this model is based on vaguely recruiting on position. Style of player, character, characteristics like pace are totally irrelevant. It was why a left wing back replaced the best right winger in the league. There appears zero footballing expertise or understanding behind any recruitment - coaches or players.
Reply
#25
Even when we were fourth earlier in the season ,I didn’t think we were any better than the fourth from bottom and so it has proved.Apart from the cream that has risen to the top Middlesbrough and Coventry ,I don’t think there’s much between the rest.
Unfortunately we are paying the price for some dreadful appointments and recruitment and add the lack of confidence and at times disorganisation then it’s know wonder we are where we are.
Reply
#26
Look at the match day squad from when be beat Huddersfield away nearly two years ago.

The difference is a coach that got the very best out of his squad.

The team that day had Reach and Peters in it.

Our problem is balance and character, we have very little.
Reply
#27
(02-18-2026, 08:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The squad is the worst we’ve had for twenty years. An expected consequence of selling out best players over the last 18mths. This is only sustainable if you have an exceptional recruitment team, management and DoF all working together. Given our recruitment this season even taking PSR restrictions into account we have failed to get close to replacing those who have left with better. Including DoF, manager(s) and scouting system. 

What is our reasoning when it comes to buying players? We buy Heggebo and sell arguably the best crosser of the ball to Southampton and bring in Price and Bany (this was factored in to his sale before he went), Price isn’t a replacement, and Bany is the invisible man. We waste money on an injury prone Bielik when we had Taylor who is both young and imo a much better prospect. What was the plan past reducing the wage bill? 

Are we recruiting for a possession based team? A counter attacking team? A hard working and disciplined team that grinds out results? Our squad just feels like a mismatch of players with no clear plan for how we play. I thought the plan was to data the shit out of the supercomputer and recruit smarter? The recruitment has been worse than GM and his Dad’s by a long, long way. 

I don’t know what we are trying to achieve on or off the pitch this season.

This is the key point. And the shield that I feel Nestor and Mason have fallen on. There is no apparent 'game model' as was promised.

My thinking differs in terms of the players signed and let go. 

Price and Bany weren't Fellows replacements. They were Grady and Swift replacements as were admitted by Pearce and Nestor. Fellows going, for what was such a small figure blindsided the club and stopped us reinvesting. Sadly this happens when first starting a process. But they can't be held responsible for the players they had to sell from before they were in charge.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#28
(02-18-2026, 09:11 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: Look at the match day squad from when be beat Huddersfield away nearly two years ago.

The difference is a coach that got the very best out of his squad.

The team that day had Reach and Peters in it.

Our problem is balance and character, we have very little.

That starting eleven from that day completely highlights the financial problems bikul inherited 8 gone and 16 from that squad gone , big ask to replace those players with limited funds especially when the recruitment department is pretty much clueless , think Pieters of 2/3 years ago would be 1st pick this season
Reply
#29
(02-18-2026, 09:45 PM)Seat109 Wrote:
(02-18-2026, 09:11 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: Look at the match day squad from when be beat Huddersfield away nearly two years ago.

The difference is a coach that got the very best out of his squad.

The team that day had Reach and Peters in it.

Our problem is balance and character, we have very little.

That starting eleven from that day completely highlights the financial problems bikul inherited 8 gone and 16 from that squad gone , big ask to replace those players with limited funds especially when the recruitment department is pretty much clueless , think Pieters of 2/3 years ago would be 1st pick this season

This...
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#30
The centre midfield (Mowatt, Molumby and Diakite) is the main problem with our team. I doubt any of them would get into any other top half championship teams. They do not seem able to release passes to players making runs in the channel. Most damning is the fact that they don't even look up when they are receiving the ball, they just play the simple sideways or backwards pass. They can even manage to misplace a 5 yard pass. They very rarely attempt to carry the ball forwards and beat a player. We are so formulaic in our play that it must be so simple to dominate our midfield. In most good teams the centre midfield is the engine room, but not ours. And we are stuck with at least two of them next season.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)