Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
This isn't a 'told you so' post. This isn't a post criticising the club for sacking Mason. I think it was probably the right decision (I believe he'd have kept us up). It wasn't great under him, but we weren't a million miles away.
I understand the club's decision to sack him, and I can't really argue against it. The run of form and some of the performances were unacceptable. However, all we needed was for someone to come in, make us more defensively sound, get the team back to doing the basics, and, let's be honest, get some more luck than Mason had.
We needed slight tweaks, nothing major. What we absolutely didn't need is someone coming in, ripping everything up, and confusing the players with a complete new style and ideas. Whilst that was probably needed long term, i.e over the Summer, it's not what was needed half way through the season.
It really is a monumental fuck up by Nestor.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
Tells you all you need to know about this shambolic squad we've been left with that we only really looked competitive under Mason after he'd had two months of pre-season on the training pitch. In the circumstances Mason's position was untenable but we didn't have to replace him with a bloke who had zero experience in a proper league who had success with a system that our squad is woefully ill-equipped to play.
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
Didn’t we just….
We needed an experienced hand to get them defending as a unit, improve focus on set pieces, boost confidence and get us over the line with a bit of in-game management. Instead, the baby has gone out with the bath water.
Either Eric is doing things totally differently to what he said in interview or, and far more likely I imagine, the people who recruited him didn’t ask of his plans or, when they found them out, see that a mid-season change in system might be an issue.
Posts: 1,020
Threads: 31
Joined: Nov 2025
Reputation:
3
Let's be honest we just needed a Mason 2.0 that new how to make in game subs, had a little bit more luck and would be a bit more consistent in his selections i.e. less bat shit crazy.
Instead we threw the baby out with the bath water and decided to rip up the playbook and go with a coach who had a totally different system that we didn't have the players for. I must admit I was hoodwinked as he spoke well and I thought maybe he would be the guy. I am now almost certain he is not the answer to our problems and it was naive bordering on completely stupid to go with a coach who has a different play style in the midst of a relegation battle whilst we could not afford to buy in players for his system due to PSR.
It wasn't a hard appointment I don't think, even Mozza would have been better. Play the system we have the players for, make better subs, use the kids - that's your brief until the end of the season i.e. don't fuck it up.
Never felt so pessimistic about our chances of survival - even more so when the tool says the system isn't the problem. Yes the players are poor but you're not helping them one bit.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(02-01-2026, 09:18 AM)HeggebøsBarnDoor Wrote: Let's be honest we just needed a Mason 2.0 that new how to make in game subs, had a little bit more luck and would be a bit more consistent in his selections i.e. less bat shit crazy.
Instead we threw the baby out with the bath water and decided to rip up the playbook and go with a coach who had a totally different system that we didn't have the players for. I must admit I was hoodwinked as he spoke well and I thought maybe he would be the guy. I am now almost certain he is not the answer to our problems and it was naive bordering on completely stupid to go with a coach who has a different play style in the midst of a relegation battle whilst we could not afford to buy in players for his system due to PSR.
It wasn't a hard appointment I don't think, even Mozza would have been better. Play the system we have the players for, make better subs, use the kids - that's your brief until the end of the season i.e. don't fuck it up.
Never felt so pessimistic about our chances of survival - even more so when the tool says the system isn't the problem. Yes the players are poor but you're not helping them one bit.
What you describe is essentially Mason with the benefit of a seasons worth of experience. What a fuck up.
Posts: 3,622
Threads: 253
Joined: Apr 2025
Reputation:
1
I said a couple of months ago that I think if we'd have kept Mowbray and given him a pre season we'd be better off. Maybe only mid table but better off. I was told then I was wrong.
Posts: 612
Threads: 53
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
(02-01-2026, 08:33 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: This isn't a 'told you so' post. This isn't a post criticising the club for sacking Mason. I think it was probably the right decision (I believe he'd have kept us up). It wasn't great under him, but we weren't a million miles away.
I understand the club's decision to sack him, and I can't really argue against it. The run of form and some of the performances were unacceptable. However, all we needed was for someone to come in, make us more defensively sound, get the team back to doing the basics, and, let's be honest, get some more luck than Mason had.
We needed slight tweaks, nothing major. What we absolutely didn't need is someone coming in, ripping everything up, and confusing the players with a complete new style and ideas. Whilst that was probably needed long term, i.e over the Summer, it's not what was needed half way through the season.
It really is a monumental fuck up by Nestor.
Good post agree .I do think it is a Patel appointment this time though.
Posts: 1,170
Threads: 103
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
6
(02-01-2026, 09:52 AM)CIM Wrote: I said a couple of months ago that I think if we'd have kept Mowbray and given him a pre season we'd be better off. Maybe only mid table but better off. I was told then I was wrong.
When managerial appointments are made it’s in the hope of things improving.
The vast majority thought Mowbray had to go and the same thing with Mason.
Hindsight and a parallel universe in which different decisions are made aren’t easy to find for the told you so mob.
Posts: 26
Threads: 0
Joined: Jan 2026
Reputation:
0
There's more than just tactics at play, reading between the lines, the players morale is shot and they don't want to go out infront of the fans. That's on the fans who got on their back when we were not that bad under Mason, started booing individuals on the ball and basically forced the ownership into sacking a Manager that needed time, a bit of support and a transfer window.
The ownership haven't helped by basically keeping quiet and making Mason bear the brunt of fans frustration. They should have been easing expectations, making changes to the match day experience, club comms and other things that aren't PSR restricted but instead they have just kept their head down until this poorly timed, poorly thought out appointment.
Things are unlikely to get better now, the players are stuck having to play for a manager they know hasn't got a clue, in a style that they know doesn't work, in front of fans they know are going to be on their back from the first minute. At the end of the day, this is their job, they don't play for Albion because they love it, they do it for a wage and however good that wage is, going into your job every day to deal with shithead decisions from the people at the top and being blamed for everything going wrong is not something you can just ignore.
The club really should have given Mason some help, both with the footballing side but also the PR side. Send Dike, Maja etc out to play 60 minutes with the under 21s for a few games to see if they can hack it, bring in a set piece coach, engage with the people making podcasts and tik toks and what have you slagging off the team every week and give them a reason to get behind the team.
We were probably a bit of luck, a decent defensive reinforcement and a couple of fit strikers away from being in the top half of the table and now we're almost certainly relegated. You're right, we were not far off, but we are now.
|