No identity, no clarity...
#11
We have clarity! ER is not fit to manage our club and Nestor can join him too!
Reply
#12
(01-31-2026, 05:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We can keep changing the ‘manager’ but the problems are at ownership and senior management level. They don’t know what they are doing, the last three managerial appointments have made no sense. If Mowbray, Mason and Ramsay are best they can either afford or think are good enough, then we are in for a very depressing journey into the lower leagues. Say goodbye to Blues, Wolves and Villa and hello Walsall not just for a season but years to come.

What can Patel do? The obvious choice is to sack Nestor so then where do we go?

You bang on about generating new revenue streams, you don't get any points for that. It was never going to help us in the 12 months after they took over.

We had to sell players, players we probably didn't want to. Now you can look down your nose at whatever process has been used to identify replacements but it didn't work too well went we went with the Steve Bruce school either did it? 

We badly neglected a couple of really key positions this summer and it'll probably relegate us. It kind of feels inevitable, almost like it needs to happen but let's not pretend this wasn't a clusterfuck that's been the best part of a decade in the making.
Reply
#13
(01-31-2026, 07:36 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 05:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We can keep changing the ‘manager’ but the problems are at ownership and senior management level. They don’t know what they are doing, the last three managerial appointments have made no sense. If Mowbray, Mason and Ramsay are best they can either afford or think are good enough, then we are in for a very depressing journey into the lower leagues. Say goodbye to Blues, Wolves and Villa and hello Walsall not just for a season but years to come.

What can Patel do? The obvious choice is to sack Nestor so then where do we go?

You bang on about generating new revenue streams, you don't get any points for that. It was never going to help us in the 12 months after they took over.

We had to sell players, players we probably didn't want to. Now you can look down your nose at whatever process has been used to identify replacements but it didn't work too well went we went with the Steve Bruce school either did it? 

We badly neglected a couple of really key positions this summer and it'll probably relegate us. It kind of feels inevitable, almost like it needs to happen but let's not pretend this wasn't a clusterfuck that's been the best part of a decade in the making.

Unfortunately to do that he would not only have to admit that Nestor was incompetent, but also that he is incompetent in appointing him in the first place
Reply
#14
(01-31-2026, 07:39 PM)strawman Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 07:36 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 05:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We can keep changing the ‘manager’ but the problems are at ownership and senior management level. They don’t know what they are doing, the last three managerial appointments have made no sense. If Mowbray, Mason and Ramsay are best they can either afford or think are good enough, then we are in for a very depressing journey into the lower leagues. Say goodbye to Blues, Wolves and Villa and hello Walsall not just for a season but years to come.

What can Patel do? The obvious choice is to sack Nestor so then where do we go?

You bang on about generating new revenue streams, you don't get any points for that. It was never going to help us in the 12 months after they took over.

We had to sell players, players we probably didn't want to. Now you can look down your nose at whatever process has been used to identify replacements but it didn't work too well went we went with the Steve Bruce school either did it? 

We badly neglected a couple of really key positions this summer and it'll probably relegate us. It kind of feels inevitable, almost like it needs to happen but let's not pretend this wasn't a clusterfuck that's been the best part of a decade in the making.

Unfortunately to do that he would not only have to admit that Nestor was incompetent, but also that he is incompetent in appointing him in the first place

So do we trust the man who picked the man who picked the men to pick the man who picks the next men?
Reply
#15
(01-31-2026, 07:42 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 07:39 PM)strawman Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 07:36 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 05:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We can keep changing the ‘manager’ but the problems are at ownership and senior management level. They don’t know what they are doing, the last three managerial appointments have made no sense. If Mowbray, Mason and Ramsay are best they can either afford or think are good enough, then we are in for a very depressing journey into the lower leagues. Say goodbye to Blues, Wolves and Villa and hello Walsall not just for a season but years to come.

What can Patel do? The obvious choice is to sack Nestor so then where do we go?

You bang on about generating new revenue streams, you don't get any points for that. It was never going to help us in the 12 months after they took over.

We had to sell players, players we probably didn't want to. Now you can look down your nose at whatever process has been used to identify replacements but it didn't work too well went we went with the Steve Bruce school either did it? 

We badly neglected a couple of really key positions this summer and it'll probably relegate us. It kind of feels inevitable, almost like it needs to happen but let's not pretend this wasn't a clusterfuck that's been the best part of a decade in the making.

Unfortunately to do that he would not only have to admit that Nestor was incompetent, but also that he is incompetent in appointing him in the first place

So do we trust the man who picked the man who picked the men to pick the man who picks the next men?

Ultimately, we have no say, but nice conundrum  Smile
Reply
#16
We're far worse than under Mason, and we were poor under him. At least Mason had us creating chances. Ramsay has totally nullified us as an attacking threat
Reply
#17
(01-31-2026, 07:36 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 05:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We can keep changing the ‘manager’ but the problems are at ownership and senior management level. They don’t know what they are doing, the last three managerial appointments have made no sense. If Mowbray, Mason and Ramsay are best they can either afford or think are good enough, then we are in for a very depressing journey into the lower leagues. Say goodbye to Blues, Wolves and Villa and hello Walsall not just for a season but years to come.

What can Patel do? The obvious choice is to sack Nestor so then where do we go?

You bang on about generating new revenue streams, you don't get any points for that. It was never going to help us in the 12 months after they took over.

We had to sell players, players we probably didn't want to. Now you can look down your nose at whatever process has been used to identify replacements but it didn't work too well went we went with the Steve Bruce school either did it? 

We badly neglected a couple of really key positions this summer and it'll probably relegate us. It kind of feels inevitable, almost like it needs to happen but let's not pretend this wasn't a clusterfuck that's been the best part of a decade in the making.

I disagree, we did not have to employ two managers without Championship or league 1 or 2 experience or similar from Europe. I don’t understand the need to take such risks with the clubs future. If that is looking down my nose at the process, so be it.
Reply
#18
(01-31-2026, 08:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 07:36 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 05:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We can keep changing the ‘manager’ but the problems are at ownership and senior management level. They don’t know what they are doing, the last three managerial appointments have made no sense. If Mowbray, Mason and Ramsay are best they can either afford or think are good enough, then we are in for a very depressing journey into the lower leagues. Say goodbye to Blues, Wolves and Villa and hello Walsall not just for a season but years to come.

What can Patel do? The obvious choice is to sack Nestor so then where do we go?

You bang on about generating new revenue streams, you don't get any points for that. It was never going to help us in the 12 months after they took over.

We had to sell players, players we probably didn't want to. Now you can look down your nose at whatever process has been used to identify replacements but it didn't work too well went we went with the Steve Bruce school either did it? 

We badly neglected a couple of really key positions this summer and it'll probably relegate us. It kind of feels inevitable, almost like it needs to happen but let's not pretend this wasn't a clusterfuck that's been the best part of a decade in the making.

I disagree, we did not have to employ two managers without Championship or league 1 or 2 experience or similar from Europe. I don’t understand the need to take such risks with the clubs future. If that is looking down my nose at the process, so be it.

No we didn't, but Steve Bruce was just as bad and we needed Carlos to turn us round. Neither approach has worked for us which is why I'm starting to think we need to go down in order to really flush the chain on a pretty miserable decade.
Reply
#19
(01-31-2026, 08:41 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 08:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 07:36 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 05:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We can keep changing the ‘manager’ but the problems are at ownership and senior management level. They don’t know what they are doing, the last three managerial appointments have made no sense. If Mowbray, Mason and Ramsay are best they can either afford or think are good enough, then we are in for a very depressing journey into the lower leagues. Say goodbye to Blues, Wolves and Villa and hello Walsall not just for a season but years to come.

What can Patel do? The obvious choice is to sack Nestor so then where do we go?

You bang on about generating new revenue streams, you don't get any points for that. It was never going to help us in the 12 months after they took over.

We had to sell players, players we probably didn't want to. Now you can look down your nose at whatever process has been used to identify replacements but it didn't work too well went we went with the Steve Bruce school either did it? 

We badly neglected a couple of really key positions this summer and it'll probably relegate us. It kind of feels inevitable, almost like it needs to happen but let's not pretend this wasn't a clusterfuck that's been the best part of a decade in the making.

I disagree, we did not have to employ two managers without Championship or league 1 or 2 experience or similar from Europe. I don’t understand the need to take such risks with the clubs future. If that is looking down my nose at the process, so be it.

No we didn't, but Steve Bruce was just as bad and we needed Carlos to turn us round. Neither approach has worked for us which is why I'm starting to think we need to go down in order to really flush the chain on a pretty miserable decade.

This is a weak argument, we didn’t have to go from Bruce/Mowbray to Mason. Going down will put us back years, I doubt we would be spending our way out of the division and all the time we will lose touch with our local rivals. This season has been avoidable, it is either arrogance or naivety that we thought we could put a rookie manager in charge of a weakened squad in such a pivotal season.
Reply
#20
(01-31-2026, 09:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 08:41 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 08:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 07:36 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-31-2026, 05:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We can keep changing the ‘manager’ but the problems are at ownership and senior management level. They don’t know what they are doing, the last three managerial appointments have made no sense. If Mowbray, Mason and Ramsay are best they can either afford or think are good enough, then we are in for a very depressing journey into the lower leagues. Say goodbye to Blues, Wolves and Villa and hello Walsall not just for a season but years to come.

What can Patel do? The obvious choice is to sack Nestor so then where do we go?

You bang on about generating new revenue streams, you don't get any points for that. It was never going to help us in the 12 months after they took over.

We had to sell players, players we probably didn't want to. Now you can look down your nose at whatever process has been used to identify replacements but it didn't work too well went we went with the Steve Bruce school either did it? 

We badly neglected a couple of really key positions this summer and it'll probably relegate us. It kind of feels inevitable, almost like it needs to happen but let's not pretend this wasn't a clusterfuck that's been the best part of a decade in the making.

I disagree, we did not have to employ two managers without Championship or league 1 or 2 experience or similar from Europe. I don’t understand the need to take such risks with the clubs future. If that is looking down my nose at the process, so be it.

No we didn't, but Steve Bruce was just as bad and we needed Carlos to turn us round. Neither approach has worked for us which is why I'm starting to think we need to go down in order to really flush the chain on a pretty miserable decade.

This is a weak argument, we didn’t have to go from Bruce/Mowbray to Mason. Going down will put us back years, I doubt we would be spending our way out of the division and all the time we will lose touch with our local rivals. This season has been avoidable, it is either arrogance or naivety that we thought we could put a rookie manager in charge of a weakened squad in such a pivotal season.

Course we didn't. I don't disagree with a lot of what you say, I'm just in a never ending cycle of trying to get to the bottom of what you'd be happy with. You talk a lot in end results without any acceptance that good process is what enables the result. I agreed that given the timing I don't think I'd have sacked Mason. You're also arguing directly against the sort of method that got us halfway up the PL without a wealthy backer. Agree with the rest of what you say, there is no room for positively around a relegation to the third tier. Fact remains we've tried one experienced manager and two rookies, albeit one who's managed abroad and we've been heading towards the bottom three under all of them.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: