These players seeing off managers/ mentality
#1
Seen some murmurs of this but look at the eleven last night and 6 of the starters have only been here 6 months or so it’s not really relevant to say they have ‘seen off ‘ managers , what they are is a group that is weak mentally and unable to motivate themselves which points in the direction of the people that decided they were a wise investment ( that’s not forgiving the idiotic team selection last night), unless we gamble on a 2 or 3 loans or even gamble on a couple of out of contract players with the right mentality can’t see anything changing no matter what system he uses although reverting to 4-2-3-1 is a no brainier as long as the centre backs are Campbell/ Bielik
Reply
#2
(01-21-2026, 04:26 PM)Seat109 Wrote: Seen some murmurs of this but look at the eleven last night and 6 of the starters have only been here 6 months or so it’s not really relevant to say they have ‘seen off ‘ managers , what they are is a group that is weak mentally and unable to motivate themselves which points in the direction of the people that decided they were a wise investment ( that’s not forgiving the idiotic team selection last night), unless we gamble on a 2 or 3 loans or even gamble on a couple of out of contract players with the right mentality can’t see anything changing no matter what system he uses although reverting to 4-2-3-1 is a no brainier as long as the centre backs are Campbell/ Bielik

Have often wondered about the `mentally fragile` bit. Is it because, for the last 20 years or so, they have come through academies where they have been looked after / had top facilites, coaches etc. Years back, most had to come through lower league stuff, or were apprentices, cleaning the star players boots after training.
A different era, I know but I remember Denis Smith, { lousy manager for us, but a solid defender for Stoke }, saying he was getting married on the Tuesday afternoon, so the coach gave him the day off. He spent the morning turning out for the youth team, saying he needed the practice.
Reply
#3
The backroom staff and coaches need changing. All of them.
They're responsible for players fitness, skills, motivation. It's not all down to the manager.
Reply
#4
It could just be, we have replaced proven Championship standard players with inferior players on lower wages and we now look less than a competent Championship squad led by inexperienced managers that have no experience of the Championship.

I mean that might point towards the problem which is our president also having no experience in the English game… there’s a pattern here.
Reply
#5
Are these the Premier League cast offs that don't have that mental ability as much as the physical ability?
Reply
#6
(01-21-2026, 04:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It could just be, we have replaced proven Championship standard players with inferior players on lower wages and we now look less than a competent Championship squad led by inexperienced managers that have no experience of the Championship.

I mean that might point towards the problem which is our president also having no experience in the English game… there’s a pattern here.

Yup.  Rookie owner and rookie DOF (or president wtf) appointing rookie managers.  All learning on the job in one of the most challenging proffesional sporting environments in the world.  What could go wrong??

Still take Patel over Lai.  Gourlay was a waster but lucked out on Corbs, not sure i'd want him back though.  Managers? Apart from CC from Val onwards the appointments have been disastrous.  Val almost breaking the fans then Bruce, Mowbray and Mason all sending us into relegation form.

Feels like the natural culmination of Jeremy Roland taking the money and running all those years ago. I'll never truly forgive the slap headed old fucker.

Is rookie an Americanism?? Apologies if it is.
Reply
#7
(01-21-2026, 06:03 PM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-21-2026, 04:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It could just be, we have replaced proven Championship standard players with inferior players on lower wages and we now look less than a competent Championship squad led by inexperienced managers that have no experience of the Championship.

I mean that might point towards the problem which is our president also having no experience in the English game… there’s a pattern here.

Yup.  Rookie owner and rookie DOF (or president wtf) appointing rookie managers.  All learning on the job in one of the most challenging proffesional sporting environments in the world.  What could go wrong??

Still take Patel over Lai.  Gourlay was a waster but lucked out on Corbs, not sure i'd want him back.  Managers? Apart from CC from Val onwards the appointments have been disastrous.  Val almost breaking the fans then Bruce, Mowbray and Mason all sending us into relegation form.

Feels like the natural culmination of Jeremy Roland taking the money and running all those years ago.  I'll never truly forgive the slap headed old fucker.

Is rookie an Americanism?? Apologies if it is.

It's ironic to recall that we were 5th when Val was sacked!
Reply
#8
I think this sums it up perfectly:

West Bromwich Albion opinion: Anarchy reigns since Corberan exit - BBC Sport
Reply
#9
(01-21-2026, 04:39 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The backroom staff and coaches need changing. All of them.
They're responsible for players fitness, skills, motivation. It's not all down to the manager.

Argreed for more than a few seasons now our players look unfit and seem to regress at alarming rate no matter who is in charge the only constant is the majority of coaching staff get rid start afresh that goes for the medic team too.
Reply
#10
(01-21-2026, 06:15 PM)baggpuss Wrote: I think this sums it up perfectly:

West Bromwich Albion opinion: Anarchy reigns since Corberan exit - BBC Sport

Good piece that.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)