Aston Tel Aviv Protests
#41
(01-08-2026, 03:54 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 12:53 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The Police recognised that this game carried more than the standard football hooligan violence that can be managed through escorting, keeping behind and containing. They also recognised that the threat was more than the usual two football teams rivalries and the limited number of loons involved in thar. This was a lightning rod for two opposing ideologies that would be attracted for reasons other than football and involve a lot more Policing and segregating of individuals making the risk of injury or worse much higher.

In a standard game it is a case of segregating and protecting / policing one group - the away team supporters.

In this game you would have had:
The away team supporters
The home team wanky supporters
Those supporting Israel within the away support
Those supporting Israel within the home support
Those supporting Israel not attending the game but congregating for a protest around the ground
Those supporting Israel not attending the game but congregating for a protest away from the ground
Those supporting Palestine within the home support
Those supporting Palestine not attending the game but congregating for a protest around the game
Those supporting Palestine not attending the game but congregating for a protest away from the ground

The combinations of all or any of those coming together made the Policing of this near impossible and anyone who is asking for any other action than the Police took is basically gambling with another individual's life. The Police made the right call.

There was more than even that list. Your use of the term lightening rod for opposing ideologies, is bang on. I know 2 separate people that were at some of the meetings. One a steward -at Albion- as they were asked for assistance, another is in WM armed response team. There were a huge number of safety concerns all linked to those listed above. Even having to protect the ground for the week or more before the game, from intruders, from drones, explosives and more. Ultimately someone has to sign to say this match is 'safe'. Who would do that? The rights and wrongs are evident on both sides but in the end the decision was made to keep everyone from harm.

Correct. That's the long and short of it without the hysteria or conspiracy input
Raw Sausage
Reply
#42
Yet weekend after weekend Pro Palestinian marches went on without a whiff of any cancellations, just a bit of segregation required.
Reply
#43
I’d imagine because they have a far simpler list of considerations to manage than the list that TJ accurately posts above. I’m not sure that’s hard to understand.
Raw Sausage
Reply
#44
But it's hard to understand that you could be wrong and other people have different views. It's a bit patronising
Reply
#45
It’s not a view that one event you compare to another had far more complications for safety. It’s a fact.
Raw Sausage
Reply
#46
Again in your opinion
Reply
#47
(01-08-2026, 12:53 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The Police recognised that this game carried more than the standard football hooligan violence that can be managed through escorting, keeping behind and containing. They also recognised that the threat was more than the usual two football teams rivalries and the limited number of loons involved in thar. This was a lightning rod for two opposing ideologies that would be attracted for reasons other than football and involve a lot more Policing and segregating of individuals making the risk of injury or worse much higher.

In a standard game it is a case of segregating and protecting / policing one group - the away team supporters.

In this game you would have had:
The away team supporters
The home team wanky supporters
Those supporting Israel within the away support
Those supporting Israel within the home support
Those supporting Israel not attending the game but congregating for a protest around the ground
Those supporting Israel not attending the game but congregating for a protest away from the ground
Those supporting Palestine within the home support
Those supporting Palestine not attending the game but congregating for a protest around the game
Those supporting Palestine not attending the game but congregating for a protest away from the ground

The combinations of all or any of those coming together made the Policing of this near impossible and anyone who is asking for any other action than the Police took is basically gambling with another individual's life. The Police made the right call.

Absolutely spot on Baggy.
Reply
#48
The match was played, and everyone went home safe and sound. The ideal outcome.
But instead, some zealots in thrall to another country are trying to bring down the West Midlands police and the media are cheering it on. Even the usual suspects on here are no longer quibbling about it, because WMP made the right call, the match would have clearly been a nightmare. It is an entirely concocted outrage.
Reply
#49
(01-08-2026, 07:33 PM)Squid Wrote: The match was played, and everyone went home safe and sound. The ideal outcome.
But instead, some zealots in thrall to another country are trying to bring down the West Midlands police and the media are cheering it on. Even the usual suspects on here are no longer quibbling about it, because WMP made the right call, the match would have clearly been a nightmare. It is an entirely concocted outrage.

Sickening pro-Pal, pseudo-pacifist “peace in our time” nonsense. Islamist politicians began agitating  before any practical considerations of the fixture were even discussed. Two of them sat on the SAG and should have recused themselves from the outset given their entrenched anti-Zionist views, (antisemitic) One of them is objectively corrupt, while one only recused themselves after the decision had already been stitched up. John Cotton effectively threw them under the bus at the Commons committee on Tuesday, admitting what everyone could already see. 

The pressure came from elements within the Islamic community and true to form, blame was dumped on Jews. The decision dragged the city into disrepute and showed that intimidation works. In the long run, this kind of bullshit doesn’t protect Muslims, it puts them at greater risk, increases division and damages trust in the police. Far from the ideal outcome. Guilford is a gibbering clown who should resign, if not he should be sacked
Reply
#50
(01-09-2026, 06:25 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(01-08-2026, 07:33 PM)Squid Wrote: The match was played, and everyone went home safe and sound. The ideal outcome.
But instead, some zealots in thrall to another country are trying to bring down the West Midlands police and the media are cheering it on. Even the usual suspects on here are no longer quibbling about it, because WMP made the right call, the match would have clearly been a nightmare. It is an entirely concocted outrage.

Sickening pro-Pal, pseudo-pacifist “peace in our time” nonsense. Islamist politicians began agitating  before any practical considerations of the fixture were even discussed. Two of them sat on the SAG and should have recused themselves from the outset given their entrenched anti-Zionist views, (antisemitic) One of them is objectively corrupt, while one only recused themselves after the decision had already been stitched up. John Cotton effectively threw them under the bus at the Commons committee on Tuesday, admitting what everyone could already see. 

The pressure came from elements within the Islamic community and true to form, blame was dumped on Jews. The decision dragged the city into disrepute and showed that intimidation works. In the long run, this kind of bullshit doesn’t protect Muslims, it puts them at greater risk, increases division and damages trust in the police. Far from the ideal outcome. Guilford is a gibbering clown who should resign, if not he should be sacked
That's worded much better than my "locals threatened to play merry fuck up" post
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: