Has there ever been a manager so unanimously wanted out?
#91
(01-04-2026, 11:58 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(01-04-2026, 11:38 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-04-2026, 11:24 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Good posts Clem and Ted.

One thing to add we spent big on wages as we couldn’t on transfer fees and wages, it was a trade off that comes with owners who said all along that they would not invest in the team outside of what the club brought in. That means you will end up with an older squad with no resale value if your sole objective is to stay up each season.

The idea that because the wages alone were comparable to other clubs at the time in midtable, misses the point that other teams were spending big on transfers and wages. I said at the time that fans should make the most of those years instead of pissing and moaning even under Roy, because there was no ffs ‘next level’ for us, particularly as a self sufficient club.

Much of this is fair, but also, other teams around us were selling players for big fees too - take our contemporaries at the time in Swansea who matched us in terms of results and achievements, as well as having a cup win and a European tour whilst a playing a generally more pleasing style of football - they were regularly selling players for big fees.

Pulis did a good job overall in terms of his results.. he more than matched the budget he was working with, but at a huge cost in terms of enjoyment and fan engagement, that’s why for me his success here ranks below what Roy and Clarke achieved, and was probably around the same level as RDM, Mowbray and Bilic, but far less enjoyable to watch.
Agreed that the football was not enjoyable to watch and that made defeats feel ten times worse, however you always felt pre-match that we would be organised and competitive which - Carlos aside - has been a feeling I have not had very much in the last five years.
Fair point. But my God the football was turgid!
Mainly because of lack of ambition. Pulis always tried - and sometimes succeeded - to not lose matches, as we all know. But let's not forget that he lost more than he won. 
I liked CC and Roy, who both played solid football, but at least had an idea how to score a goal.
Pulis had the distant Rondon and set pieces.
Fine when you're away at Man U. But not home to a poor villa team.
Reply
#92
There seem to be people in football outside the club that want Mason to succeed, seems like he is a decent bloke, good coach and has unfinished business due to his playing career ending too soon.
Reply
#93
(01-04-2026, 12:20 PM)RJohnnykayeengland Wrote:
(01-04-2026, 11:58 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(01-04-2026, 11:38 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-04-2026, 11:24 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Good posts Clem and Ted.

One thing to add we spent big on wages as we couldn’t on transfer fees and wages, it was a trade off that comes with owners who said all along that they would not invest in the team outside of what the club brought in. That means you will end up with an older squad with no resale value if your sole objective is to stay up each season.

The idea that because the wages alone were comparable to other clubs at the time in midtable, misses the point that other teams were spending big on transfers and wages. I said at the time that fans should make the most of those years instead of pissing and moaning even under Roy, because there was no ffs ‘next level’ for us, particularly as a self sufficient club.

Much of this is fair, but also, other teams around us were selling players for big fees too - take our contemporaries at the time in Swansea who matched us in terms of results and achievements, as well as having a cup win and a European tour whilst a playing a generally more pleasing style of football - they were regularly selling players for big fees.

Pulis did a good job overall in terms of his results.. he more than matched the budget he was working with, but at a huge cost in terms of enjoyment and fan engagement, that’s why for me his success here ranks below what Roy and Clarke achieved, and was probably around the same level as RDM, Mowbray and Bilic, but far less enjoyable to watch.
Agreed that the football was not enjoyable to watch and that made defeats feel ten times worse, however you always felt pre-match that we would be organised and competitive which - Carlos aside - has been a feeling I have not had very much in the last five years.
Fair point. But my God the football was turgid!
Mainly because of lack of ambition. Pulis always tried - and sometimes succeeded - to not lose matches, as we all know. But let's not forget that he lost more than he won. 
I liked CC and Roy, who both played solid football, but at least had an idea how to score a goal.
Pulis had the distant Rondon and set pieces.
Fine when you're away at Man U. But not home to a poor villa team.
Ultimately that is why he was more successful keeping teams up than promoting them. Moyes and Roy were always a notch above for me as they could combine the strong defence and organisation with some goal threat.
Reply
#94
It should be the bare minimum for any manager and team not to throw away the point you start a game with. Missed chances are part of the game and can't be coached. A basic level of organisation and structure to ensure that you can keep hold of your clean sheet can. Our best managers of the last 25 years (Megson, Hodgson, Pulis, Corberan) did this.

A lot has been made of missed chances under Mason, but we missed chances under Carlos and Val too. The difference is, especially when compared to Carlos is that a game we didn't do enough to win, we'd rarely lose. There are easily 4-5 away defeats we've had this season that could have been 0-0s. That's more points, more clean sheets a more organised and confident team. Worryingly Mason speaks as though he thinks you can only win or lose away from home.
Reply
#95
(01-04-2026, 12:34 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: It should be the bare minimum for any manager and team not to throw away the point you start a game with. Missed chances are part of the game and can't be coached. A basic level of organisation and structure to ensure that you can keep hold of your clean sheet can. Our best managers of the last 25 years (Megson, Hodgson, Pulis, Corberan) did this.

A lot has been made of missed chances under Mason, but we missed chances under Carlos and Val too. The difference is, especially when compared to Carlos is that a game we didn't do enough to win, we'd rarely lose. There are easily 4-5 away defeats we've had this season that could have been 0-0s. That's more points, more clean sheets a more organised and confident team. Worryingly Mason speaks as though he thinks you can only win or lose away from home.
Absolutely.
Reply
#96
(01-04-2026, 11:58 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(01-04-2026, 11:38 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-04-2026, 11:24 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Good posts Clem and Ted.

One thing to add we spent big on wages as we couldn’t on transfer fees and wages, it was a trade off that comes with owners who said all along that they would not invest in the team outside of what the club brought in. That means you will end up with an older squad with no resale value if your sole objective is to stay up each season.

The idea that because the wages alone were comparable to other clubs at the time in midtable, misses the point that other teams were spending big on transfers and wages. I said at the time that fans should make the most of those years instead of pissing and moaning even under Roy, because there was no ffs ‘next level’ for us, particularly as a self sufficient club.

Much of this is fair, but also, other teams around us were selling players for big fees too - take our contemporaries at the time in Swansea who matched us in terms of results and achievements, as well as having a cup win and a European tour whilst a playing a generally more pleasing style of football - they were regularly selling players for big fees.

Pulis did a good job overall in terms of his results.. he more than matched the budget he was working with, but at a huge cost in terms of enjoyment and fan engagement, that’s why for me his success here ranks below what Roy and Clarke achieved, and was probably around the same level as RDM, Mowbray and Bilic, but far less enjoyable to watch.
Agreed that the football was not enjoyable to watch and that made defeats feel ten times worse, however you always felt pre-match that we would be organised and competitive which - Carlos aside - has been a feeling I have not had very much in the last five years.
A lot of the football was turgid "professional" stuff but we also played some decent football as well, especially earlier on.  The pity is he wasn't shown the exit sooner.
Reply
#97
I don't think there's been a Manager since Buckley who has held onto their job for such a long time while under pressure from a large proportion of the fanbase.

I think it's now reached the point of no turning back, because there aren't many fans on his side. He'll need an upturn in form and points to turn it around, but I have no belief that this will happen.

He's not an unlikeable chap, but he's sadly out of his depth, and must be close to losing his job now, regardless of Nestor's statement just a few weeks ago.
Reply
#98
I don't get this narrative that Mason is a "good coach". 

Name a single player who has improved under his good coaching?
Reply
#99
(01-04-2026, 02:20 PM)Old Fart Wrote: I don't get this narrative that Mason is a "good coach". 

Name a single player who has improved under his good coaching?
Heggebo?
Reply
(01-04-2026, 03:32 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(01-04-2026, 02:20 PM)Old Fart Wrote: I don't get this narrative that Mason is a "good coach". 

Name a single player who has improved under his good coaching?
Heggebo?

A la Monty Python, "Well, yes all right, but apart from Heggebo?"
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)