Has there ever been a manager so unanimously wanted out?
#71
(01-03-2026, 07:24 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(01-03-2026, 07:02 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-03-2026, 07:01 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't care if Pulis had relative success, the bloke is a cunt, and he sucked the life out of the club. I genuinely see that as the low point in 30 years of following us.

Then you really haven’t been paying attention.

It's just my opinion. Pulis was and is poison. I'm not the only one to share that view. 

Dawn Astle's comments of his arrogance on Astley day speaks volumes of the type of character he is.

I must have missed that huge tribute we did for Rick. I'm not surprised Dawn Astle would be rather miffed by it.
Reply
#72
(01-03-2026, 08:16 PM)Merkinagogo Wrote:
(01-03-2026, 08:05 PM)Sliced Wrote: Pardew was definitely both worse and more unanimously wanted out. 100%

I don't think I have genuinely hated a West Brom manager like I did Pardew.

Pulis and Gould and a few others have been grim, but ...

Mason is just out of his depth, and might have been OK if we were in a better position, but his time has gone now.

+1. Odious shite. Still remember feeling ill and disgusted when we appointed him.
Reply
#73
Jesus, SW4 you must have a dartboard with Mason’s face on it and a voodoo doll that you wake up in the early hours stabbing pins into.
There’s many managers more that fans have wanted out.
It’s just a weird one this where the home form has just kept him from the trap door.
I want him gone but even now I would love nothing more than us to win 4 or 5 on a row and make me eat my words.
I think that’s how most balanced fans feel.
Reply
#74
(01-03-2026, 09:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-03-2026, 08:55 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-03-2026, 08:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-03-2026, 08:18 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-03-2026, 08:01 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: We let him run riot with the family silver parachute payments. He then picked a fight with supporters over fan-favourite, Bojan. Similar to Pulis in that he liked to purchase big name decent players and then get the team to play like Gillingham. 

We were probably his chance to prove he was more than just a Championship plodder, and he blew it. Not the last one to do that at Stoke, admittedly. He wouldn't be accepted by Albion fans, IMO. He was made for Millwall and will probably end up back there someday.

I could stomach Rowett on a deal until the summer to just ensure we survive this season and instill some defensive nous into the side, and  give Bikul 6 months to find the next manager and plan for next sumer’s - hopefully - more free transfer window. You know with Rowett you won’t go down, and I’d take crap football with some points for 6 months in the same way I was hoping we’d dispense of Pulis after 18 months when the ship had been steadied.

I have no ill will towards Mason, I want him gone as it’s clear he’s out of his depth, and I really hope he goes on to have a good career as he’s overcome huge personal issues and deserves some success, but he won’t have it here… similar to AFI, I have no ill will towards him, and he did some good in terms of integrating Berahino and Dawson, he just wasn’t cut out to be a PL manager, although his record was admittedly better than many seem to remember.

Pulis, Bruce and Pardew represented a laziness behind the scenes that a club like ours can never afford to let set in. The second we appointed them it was was beginning of the end.

What were progressive appointments AFI and Pepe Mel?

You’re the only one who keeps parroting that progressive bullshit Derek. 

We used to outperform other clubs by doing things differently, and making well researched and thoroughly thought through appointments that fitted the squad we had. The others were the equivalent of the football panic button appointed by out of touch or incompetent directors. 

Their appointments symbolise is going off course.

That is some serious revision on what actually happened.

AFI - awful appointment, what research did we use to employ him? If we had been as well run as you say we were, we wouldn’t have needed Pulis to save Peace’s nest egg. 

Mel - awful appointment, when we started to believe our own hype, bailed out by Brunt and other senior players after completely hobbling the mangers agency.

The club had a window of two or three seasons where we can say we did things more professionally than others, the wheels came off as soon as we tried to replace key individuals such as Ashworth with lesser ones and started to believe our own hype. The season we bought AFI to the club, our brilliant research and thorough analysis left us with half a squad and a randomly and hastily assembled bunch of pretty ropey players such as Gamboa, Blanco, Samaras and Davidson etc and an untried coach to keep us in the league. 

We have been on the slide as a club for years, ever since Peace realised he needed to cash in on his nest egg before the wheels came off. Peace knew the only way he could secure his payday was by bringing in Pulis to keep us up and ensure the club was in the Prem to sell.  

Incidentky our two most successful managers in the Prem were Hodgson, Clarke and Pulis only one of them needed much research. 

As usual, the only revisionism in this post is your version of the thread… I didn’t being AFI into things, AFI was the result of us appointing Terry Fucking Burton as DoF thinking a bloke who’d been a forward thinking coach 30 years ago was the way to go - see my point about appointing out if touch/incompetents.

I’ve not mentioned Mel… you keep bringing him up… Mel created a brilliant side in Betis, but was brought in mid season, to a squad that was not suited to his play, wasn’t allowed to bring his assistant who spoke English and had McDonut pulling strings above him. I’d have kept Clarke, but again, see above about incompetent DoFs… my thoughts on Mel were that had we kept him in the summer, given him the coaching staff he needed and actually brought some players in that could press, who knows.

Everything else you write supports what I said, we got lazy and needed Pulis. Not sure why you’re being so antagonistic?

(01-03-2026, 09:47 PM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote: Jesus, SW4 you must have a dartboard with Mason’s face on it and a voodoo doll that you wake up in the early hours stabbing pins into.
There’s many managers more that fans have wanted out.
It’s just a weird one this where the home form has just kept him from the trap door.
I want him gone but even now I would love nothing more than us to win 4 or 5 on a row and make me eat my words.
I think that’s how most balanced fans feel.

I think you need to re-read this thread and my posts. I hold no ill will towards Mason, I believe he’s trying his best, and I much prefer him as a person than say Pulis or Pardew. I just want the club to realise their mistake and end this stupid experiment.
Reply
#75
(01-03-2026, 09:50 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-03-2026, 09:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-03-2026, 08:55 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-03-2026, 08:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-03-2026, 08:18 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I could stomach Rowett on a deal until the summer to just ensure we survive this season and instill some defensive nous into the side, and  give Bikul 6 months to find the next manager and plan for next sumer’s - hopefully - more free transfer window. You know with Rowett you won’t go down, and I’d take crap football with some points for 6 months in the same way I was hoping we’d dispense of Pulis after 18 months when the ship had been steadied.

I have no ill will towards Mason, I want him gone as it’s clear he’s out of his depth, and I really hope he goes on to have a good career as he’s overcome huge personal issues and deserves some success, but he won’t have it here… similar to AFI, I have no ill will towards him, and he did some good in terms of integrating Berahino and Dawson, he just wasn’t cut out to be a PL manager, although his record was admittedly better than many seem to remember.

Pulis, Bruce and Pardew represented a laziness behind the scenes that a club like ours can never afford to let set in. The second we appointed them it was was beginning of the end.

What were progressive appointments AFI and Pepe Mel?

You’re the only one who keeps parroting that progressive bullshit Derek. 

We used to outperform other clubs by doing things differently, and making well researched and thoroughly thought through appointments that fitted the squad we had. The others were the equivalent of the football panic button appointed by out of touch or incompetent directors. 

Their appointments symbolise is going off course.

That is some serious revision on what actually happened.

AFI - awful appointment, what research did we use to employ him? If we had been as well run as you say we were, we wouldn’t have needed Pulis to save Peace’s nest egg. 

Mel - awful appointment, when we started to believe our own hype, bailed out by Brunt and other senior players after completely hobbling the mangers agency.

The club had a window of two or three seasons where we can say we did things more professionally than others, the wheels came off as soon as we tried to replace key individuals such as Ashworth with lesser ones and started to believe our own hype. The season we bought AFI to the club, our brilliant research and thorough analysis left us with half a squad and a randomly and hastily assembled bunch of pretty ropey players such as Gamboa, Blanco, Samaras and Davidson etc and an untried coach to keep us in the league. 

We have been on the slide as a club for years, ever since Peace realised he needed to cash in on his nest egg before the wheels came off. Peace knew the only way he could secure his payday was by bringing in Pulis to keep us up and ensure the club was in the Prem to sell.  

Incidentky our two most successful managers in the Prem were Hodgson, Clarke and Pulis only one of them needed much research. 

As usual, the only revisionism in this post is your version of the thread… I didn’t being AFI into things, AFI was the result of us appointing Terry Fucking Burton as DoF thinking a bloke who’d been a forward thinking coach 30 years ago was the way to go - see my point about appointing out if touch/incompetents.

I’ve not mentioned Mel… you keep bringing him up… Mel created a brilliant side in Betis, but was brought in mid season, to a squad that was not suited to his play, wasn’t allowed to bring his assistant who spoke English and had McDonut pulling strings above him. I’d have kept Clarke, but again, see above about incompetent DoFs… my thoughts on Mel were that had we kept him in the summer, given him the coaching staff he needed and actually brought some players in that could press, who knows.

Everything else you write supports what I said, we got lazy and needed Pulis. Not sure why you’re being so antagonistic?

(01-03-2026, 09:47 PM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote: Jesus, SW4 you must have a dartboard with Mason’s face on it and a voodoo doll that you wake up in the early hours stabbing pins into.
There’s many managers more that fans have wanted out.
It’s just a weird one this where the home form has just kept him from the trap door.
I want him gone but even now I would love nothing more than us to win 4 or 5 on a row and make me eat my words.
I think that’s how most balanced fans feel.

I think you need to re-read this thread and my posts. I hold no ill will towards Mason, I believe he’s trying his best, and I much prefer him as a person than say Pulis or Pardew. I just want the club to realise their mistake and end this stupid experiment.

Our most successful managers in the Prem were Hodgson, Clarke and Pulis and our most successful manager before this was Megson… they are all very different characters and operated under very different circumstances. There isn’t any guarantees that sacking Mason alone will deliver the success fans want. In answer to the original post, Pardew I was mortified we employed and wanted him gone before h arrived.
Reply
#76
I agree with you Derek… Megson was the result of Paul Thompson - ie a very capable owner who wanted to invest in data and analysis a decade before anyone else to give us an advantage… Clarke was an excellent appointment by a fully functioning system, and Roy landed in our lap, but we adapted very well to his availability.

Pulis did the job Pulis did, he kept a side with the 10th highest budget around 10th. He may well be successful on paper, but much like Mowbray first time round, he delivered what was to be expected given the resources available, but playing much worse football.
Reply
#77
I hadn't thought about that Derek but I agree, they are the best we have had over last 30 years.

I say that through gritted teeth re Pulis.

Loved SGM and Roy. Shame how Clarke went off the boil so quickly but he's still showing what he can do with those SCOTCH PRYCKS. Glad for him.
Reply
#78
I'll stand corrected but I don't believe for a minute our performances didn't wildly exceed our budget from 2011 to 2016 barring the weird end to 2014.
Reply
#79
(01-03-2026, 11:18 PM)Jacko Wrote: I'll  stand corrected but I don't believe for a minute our performances didn't wildly exceed our budget from 2011 to 2016 barring the weird end to 2014.

Under Roy and Clarke I’d imagine they did, and in TP’s first half season he did an excellent job stabilising a broken squad - although as is often forgotten, we weren’t in the bottom 3 when he arrived.

The following season onwards was when we started to really spend - we threw some very hefty wages at the likes of Evans and Rondon, as well as having already recruited Fletcher. By that time we’d had 5 years in the PL and our budget was that of a solid mid table side.

Pulis did a very good job in his first 6 months, and continued to stabilise us the following year, but we should have packed him off after 18 months, from there on in it got toxic, even if we did somehow get a top half finish the season before he decided to line his pockets.
Reply
#80
(01-03-2026, 11:54 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-03-2026, 11:18 PM)Jacko Wrote: I'll  stand corrected but I don't believe for a minute our performances didn't wildly exceed our budget from 2011 to 2016 barring the weird end to 2014.

Under Roy and Clarke I’d imagine they did, and in TP’s first half season he did an excellent job stabilising a broken squad - although as is often forgotten, we weren’t in the bottom 3 when he arrived.

The following season onwards was when we started to really spend - we threw some very hefty wages at the likes of Evans and Rondon, as well as having already recruited Fletcher. By that time we’d had 5 years in the PL and our budget was that of a solid mid table side.

Pulis did a very good job in his first 6 months, and continued to stabilise us the following year, but we should have packed him off after 18 months, from there on in it got toxic, even if we did somehow get a top half finish the season before he decided to line his pockets.

Hopefully history repeats because Alan Fucking Irvine was clueless. We're in the same situation now. We don't need to be in the bottom 3 to make a change.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)