Subs Bench
#11
(01-01-2026, 09:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Okay... Let's entertain him. If he really did only have Dike, Price, Molumby and Maja ready for half hour.

Why did he have to make like for like changes until the last 5 mins?

The final line up could have looked...

Wildshit
Campbell Phillips Taylor
Grant Price Molumby Styles
Dike Maja Heggebo

Or;
Wildshit
Campbell Phillips Taylor Styles
MJ Price Molumby Grant
Dike Maja

Two formations, different players rested, but both more ambitious and adventurous.. especially if the subs were made together to change the momentum.

Instead? Like for like. No additional threat until the last 5. That's not even considering we could have used Mepham and Bostock to change shapes and remove booked players to allow us to increase our aggression .

Basically he's unambitious and has no vision when trying to win a game. Really sad, as I genuinely like him.
Genuine question, what’s to like? Not a stick to beat him with but, I find it impossible to find him either likeable or not, he’s just bland. There’s absolutely no humour in his comments, nor any real aggression or passion. His comments always come across as dull and ambiguous with little content. He doesn’t appear particularly friendly with the players, especially subs coming on or off, there’s little engagement or motivation. Often players coming off get no recognition whatsoever.
I’m not saying he’s not a nice fella, I couldn’t know, I’ve never met him, just that personality is important and he doesn’t appear to have much of one. 

Maybe it is just another stick to beat him with, but I think a big part of his problem he’s difficult to empathise with because he’s so devoid of emotion.
Of course, if we were winning, this bland, studious, stoic persona might work, but, when not he’s just making no connection with the fans.
Reply
#12
(01-02-2026, 12:19 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-01-2026, 09:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Okay... Let's entertain him. If he really did only have Dike, Price, Molumby and Maja ready for half hour.

Why did he have to make like for like changes until the last 5 mins?

The final line up could have looked...

Wildshit
Campbell Phillips Taylor
Grant Price Molumby Styles
Dike Maja Heggebo

Or;
Wildshit
Campbell Phillips Taylor Styles
MJ Price Molumby Grant
Dike Maja

Two formations, different players rested, but both more ambitious and adventurous.. especially if the subs were made together to change the momentum.

Instead? Like for like. No additional threat until the last 5. That's not even considering we could have used Mepham and Bostock to change shapes and remove booked players to allow us to increase our aggression .

Basically he's unambitious and has no vision when trying to win a game. Really sad, as I genuinely like him.
Genuine question, what’s to like? Not a stick to beat him with but, I find it impossible to find him either likeable or not, he’s just bland. There’s absolutely no humour in his comments, nor any real aggression or passion. His comments always come across as dull and ambiguous with little content. He doesn’t appear particularly friendly with the players, especially subs coming on or off, there’s little engagement or motivation. Often players coming off get no recognition whatsoever.
I’m not saying he’s not a nice fella, I couldn’t know, I’ve never met him, just that personality is important and he doesn’t appear to have much of one. 

Maybe it is just another stick to beat him with, but I think a big part of his problem he’s difficult to empathise with because he’s so devoid of emotion.
Of course, if we were winning, this bland, studious, stoic persona might work, but, when not he’s just making no connection with the fans.

I have met him and briefly spoke to him (at the Open Day for the 125th year of the Hawthorns). Thoroughly likeable and pleasant chap. But he would definately be the bloke in the pub who wears a knitted cardigan, orders a pint of Moorhens Shredded Sporran and sits in the corner with a copy of Wisden.
Reply
#13
(01-02-2026, 12:48 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(01-02-2026, 12:19 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-01-2026, 09:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Okay... Let's entertain him. If he really did only have Dike, Price, Molumby and Maja ready for half hour.

Why did he have to make like for like changes until the last 5 mins?

The final line up could have looked...

Wildshit
Campbell Phillips Taylor
Grant Price Molumby Styles
Dike Maja Heggebo

Or;
Wildshit
Campbell Phillips Taylor Styles
MJ Price Molumby Grant
Dike Maja

Two formations, different players rested, but both more ambitious and adventurous.. especially if the subs were made together to change the momentum.

Instead? Like for like. No additional threat until the last 5. That's not even considering we could have used Mepham and Bostock to change shapes and remove booked players to allow us to increase our aggression .

Basically he's unambitious and has no vision when trying to win a game. Really sad, as I genuinely like him.
Genuine question, what’s to like? Not a stick to beat him with but, I find it impossible to find him either likeable or not, he’s just bland. There’s absolutely no humour in his comments, nor any real aggression or passion. His comments always come across as dull and ambiguous with little content. He doesn’t appear particularly friendly with the players, especially subs coming on or off, there’s little engagement or motivation. Often players coming off get no recognition whatsoever.
I’m not saying he’s not a nice fella, I couldn’t know, I’ve never met him, just that personality is important and he doesn’t appear to have much of one. 

Maybe it is just another stick to beat him with, but I think a big part of his problem he’s difficult to empathise with because he’s so devoid of emotion.
Of course, if we were winning, this bland, studious, stoic persona might work, but, when not he’s just making no connection with the fans.

I have met him and briefly spoke to him (at the Open Day for the 125th year of the Hawthorns). Thoroughly likeable and pleasant chap. But he would definately be the bloke in the pub who wears a knitted cardigan, orders a pint of Moorhens Shredded Sporran and sits in the corner with a copy of Wisden.
That’s exactly what I thought and it’s a shame because if you need to win fans over and get them on board, you need to be a bit more outgoing and rousing. 
Wrong job for him at this stage, unfortunately.
Nice to hear from someone who has actually met him though, all be it, briefly and get an insight into his character. It does help to empathise.
Reply
#14
(01-02-2026, 01:21 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-02-2026, 12:48 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(01-02-2026, 12:19 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-01-2026, 09:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Okay... Let's entertain him. If he really did only have Dike, Price, Molumby and Maja ready for half hour.

Why did he have to make like for like changes until the last 5 mins?

The final line up could have looked...

Wildshit
Campbell Phillips Taylor
Grant Price Molumby Styles
Dike Maja Heggebo

Or;
Wildshit
Campbell Phillips Taylor Styles
MJ Price Molumby Grant
Dike Maja

Two formations, different players rested, but both more ambitious and adventurous.. especially if the subs were made together to change the momentum.

Instead? Like for like. No additional threat until the last 5. That's not even considering we could have used Mepham and Bostock to change shapes and remove booked players to allow us to increase our aggression .

Basically he's unambitious and has no vision when trying to win a game. Really sad, as I genuinely like him.
Genuine question, what’s to like? Not a stick to beat him with but, I find it impossible to find him either likeable or not, he’s just bland. There’s absolutely no humour in his comments, nor any real aggression or passion. His comments always come across as dull and ambiguous with little content. He doesn’t appear particularly friendly with the players, especially subs coming on or off, there’s little engagement or motivation. Often players coming off get no recognition whatsoever.
I’m not saying he’s not a nice fella, I couldn’t know, I’ve never met him, just that personality is important and he doesn’t appear to have much of one. 

Maybe it is just another stick to beat him with, but I think a big part of his problem he’s difficult to empathise with because he’s so devoid of emotion.
Of course, if we were winning, this bland, studious, stoic persona might work, but, when not he’s just making no connection with the fans.

I have met him and briefly spoke to him (at the Open Day for the 125th year of the Hawthorns). Thoroughly likeable and pleasant chap. But he would definately be the bloke in the pub who wears a knitted cardigan, orders a pint of Moorhens Shredded Sporran and sits in the corner with a copy of Wisden.
That’s exactly what I thought and it’s a shame because if you need to win fans over and get them on board, you need to be a bit more outgoing and rousing. 
Wrong job for him at this stage, unfortunately.
Nice to hear from someone who has actually met him though, all be it, briefly and get an insight into his character. It does help to empathise.
ALBEIT!!!  FFS!!!
Reply
#15
(01-02-2026, 02:05 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(01-02-2026, 01:21 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-02-2026, 12:48 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(01-02-2026, 12:19 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-01-2026, 09:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Okay... Let's entertain him. If he really did only have Dike, Price, Molumby and Maja ready for half hour.

Why did he have to make like for like changes until the last 5 mins?

The final line up could have looked...

Wildshit
Campbell Phillips Taylor
Grant Price Molumby Styles
Dike Maja Heggebo

Or;
Wildshit
Campbell Phillips Taylor Styles
MJ Price Molumby Grant
Dike Maja

Two formations, different players rested, but both more ambitious and adventurous.. especially if the subs were made together to change the momentum.

Instead? Like for like. No additional threat until the last 5. That's not even considering we could have used Mepham and Bostock to change shapes and remove booked players to allow us to increase our aggression .

Basically he's unambitious and has no vision when trying to win a game. Really sad, as I genuinely like him.
Genuine question, what’s to like? Not a stick to beat him with but, I find it impossible to find him either likeable or not, he’s just bland. There’s absolutely no humour in his comments, nor any real aggression or passion. His comments always come across as dull and ambiguous with little content. He doesn’t appear particularly friendly with the players, especially subs coming on or off, there’s little engagement or motivation. Often players coming off get no recognition whatsoever.
I’m not saying he’s not a nice fella, I couldn’t know, I’ve never met him, just that personality is important and he doesn’t appear to have much of one. 

Maybe it is just another stick to beat him with, but I think a big part of his problem he’s difficult to empathise with because he’s so devoid of emotion.
Of course, if we were winning, this bland, studious, stoic persona might work, but, when not he’s just making no connection with the fans.

I have met him and briefly spoke to him (at the Open Day for the 125th year of the Hawthorns). Thoroughly likeable and pleasant chap. But he would definately be the bloke in the pub who wears a knitted cardigan, orders a pint of Moorhens Shredded Sporran and sits in the corner with a copy of Wisden.
That’s exactly what I thought and it’s a shame because if you need to win fans over and get them on board, you need to be a bit more outgoing and rousing. 
Wrong job for him at this stage, unfortunately.
Nice to hear from someone who has actually met him though, all be it, briefly and get an insight into his character. It does help to empathise.
ALBEIT!!!  FFS!!!

Get in  Big Grin
Reply
#16
(01-01-2026, 07:31 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: I've listened to both the official after match interview and the one with the BBC and Mason references not being able to make changes to the team and having injured/ill players on the bench. I am aware that Bielek is carrying an injury from the Hull game but looking at that bench before kick off it was as clear as day which subs he may use. If we had been hanging on for a win or draw then Mepham would have likely come on and in any other circumstance the 4 subs that he made were very predictable with everyone on the planet knowing that if Dike was going to come on then he would be the final sub.

So which of these players is he referring to that are injured or ill? - they can't have been too bad as he bought 4 of them onto the pitch.

His recent comments don't really align with his previous ones where he stated that he wouldn't put young players on the bench unless they had earned the right. And therefore we can assume that Bostock has earned the right seeing as he has been on the bench numerous times now. His use of Bostock is criminal - he was given 10 minutes away at Millwall and looked very bright. I was there that day and to be honest he was the only bright spot in a thoroughly miserable performance. His reward for that showing has been to sit on the bench for the next 3 months - shocking management in my opinion. Let's face it - we have lost 9 away games on the bounce and the only one where we were not behind going into the last 10 minutes was Charlton. So what reason does Mason have for not bringing on a young attack minded player when we need a goal - it makes zero sense to me. 


And likewise why not bring Dike on earlier in games when we are chasing a goal and try something different? We are so predictable that any opposition manager must already know what we are going to do as there is rarely any variation. A lot of the criticism towards Mason relates to him 'not learning' and much of that can be related to the fact that he rarely tries anything different. I think that he would have had a slightly easier ride from supporters if we had seen him trying different things but all we see is the same repeated actions game after game.

One interesting point today was the commentator mentioning the fact that Molumby and Maja coming on bang on the 60th minute and how it was likely to be a pre-planned change I appreciate that this was likely to be the case but to me it spoke volumes if that was the case. The more pressing reason for making the change was the fact that I didn't see us have possession of the ball in Swansea's half after half time until about the 59th minute. A manager has to be able to react to what he is seeing on the pitch and not just make changes that have been pre-planned - if that was the case then Mason may as well not bother turning up.
What a great idea!
Reply
#17
Can anyone tell me if Bielik needs to be named in the squad I order to be around the squad in tgd dressing room and to sit on the bench? If not why isn't he just there with them offering his moral support?
Reply
#18
Is the subs bench next to the cuck chair where Mason sits?
Reply
#19
(01-02-2026, 02:49 PM)1952 Wrote: Can anyone tell me if Bielik needs to be named in the squad I order to be around the squad in tgd dressing room and to sit on the bench? If not why isn't he just there with them offering his moral support?

I said this the other day. No need at all. He's an employee of the club and can go where he likes. He can travel with the team like youngsters do who don't make the match day squad.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)