Quick ratings - WMETM
#11
Whenever we win we can't keep saying it was in spite of Mason. That's not really fair.
Reply
#12
(12-30-2025, 07:47 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Whenever we win we can't keep saying it was in spite of Mason. That's not really fair.

And it just wasn't the case last night. 

He made the correct subs, at the correct times. Credit where it's due.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#13
(12-29-2025, 11:19 PM)waffle Wrote: Agree bar one of those. Mason. 

Original team selection wrong
Taking off MJ instead of SIJ
Showing frustration with fans over MJ sub
Absolute mess of the Mepham substitution

I’ve given Mason the benefit of the doubt more than many on here. However, I think we won despite Mason than because of Mason. 

One positive was that, despite not starting, he’d built bridges with Price after Boxing Day.

Why was the Mepham substitution a mess? Did i miss something? I thought it worked.
Reply
#14
Pretty much spot on Lurker.

SIJ is a frustrating one as at times we need him in the side because he has a an asset - pace - that we are so badly lacking and even when his product is shit his mere presence forces the oppo into doing things that help us elsewhere. If we could get a SIJ with product or even just an additional pace merchant I think it would be a big help.
Raw Sausage
Reply
#15
(12-30-2025, 08:01 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 11:19 PM)waffle Wrote: Agree bar one of those. Mason. 

Original team selection wrong
Taking off MJ instead of SIJ
Showing frustration with fans over MJ sub
Absolute mess of the Mepham substitution

I’ve given Mason the benefit of the doubt more than many on here. However, I think we won despite Mason than because of Mason. 

One positive was that, despite not starting, he’d built bridges with Price after Boxing Day.

Why was the Mepham substitution a mess? Did i miss something? I thought it worked.

Abella gave the instructions to Mepham to go into a back 5. As soon as Mepham went into position, Mason started going crazy at the defence as that wasn’t what he wanted. I’m not sure what he did want, and neither did the players. Then 30 seconds of confusion with the players not knowing where they should be, Mason unhappy at Abella for not understanding what he wanted. In the end, Mason relents and sticks with the instructions given by Abella. Abella walks away confused. Mason stood there shaking is head. 

We were a little better defensively yesterday. Taylor’s performance surprised me but a lack of organisation at the back is the cause of a lot of the goals conceded recently. What happened during that sub cemented my view that this lack of organisation is more down to Mason than the players.
Reply
#16
(12-30-2025, 08:11 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Pretty much spot on Lurker.

SIJ is a frustrating one as at times we need him in the side because he has a an asset - pace - that we are so badly lacking and even when his product is shit his mere presence forces the oppo into doing things that help us elsewhere. If we could get a SIJ with product or even just an additional pace merchant I think it would be a big help.

I also think Mason got the timings of the subs right yesterday, although I'd have brought on Dike and not Maja. Maja seems incapable or unwilling to do more than a light jog these days.

In terms of SIJ, I'm convinced that he'd be a different player down the left. On the match day thread, I think someone bemoaned how he kept going backwards or sidewards, I think that's because he often finds himself on his weaker right foot. I'd really like to see him given a try down the left side.
Reply
#17
(12-30-2025, 09:34 AM)ElbowGrease73 Wrote:
(12-30-2025, 08:11 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Pretty much spot on Lurker.

SIJ is a frustrating one as at times we need him in the side because he has a an asset - pace - that we are so badly lacking and even when his product is shit his mere presence forces the oppo into doing things that help us elsewhere. If we could get a SIJ with product or even just an additional pace merchant I think it would be a big help.

I also think Mason got the timings of the subs right yesterday, although I'd have brought on Dike and not Maja. Maja seems incapable or unwilling to do more than a light jog these days.

In terms of SIJ, I'm convinced that he'd be a different player down the left. On the match day thread, I think someone bemoaned how he kept going backwards or sidewards, I think that's because he often finds himself on his weaker right foot. I'd really like to see him given a try down the left side.

Agree - Dike looked reasonably sharp against Bristol when he came on. I also agree that Maja don't look the same - he slowed a bit for that final 5 yesterday as well and looked "tight". i actually think the effort was there last night / intention I just don't think he's the same imho. Obviously wait till he leaves and he score 20 for another team to shove that down my throat  Big Grin

I bemoan SIJ for sure passing backwards as it's frustrating and stalls momentum. On balance maybe that's not his fault, maybe it's just a square peg in a round hole.
Reply
#18
(12-29-2025, 10:47 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Quick 'what my eyes told me' scores in the doors. 

Wildsmith - 6 - no fault for the goal. A few dodgy kicks. 2 good crosses claimed. 

Campbell - 8 - Could be a real player. Strong, fast, technically decent. Lots to improve, but seems a clever sort. Cracking header too. 
Phillips - 8 - Back to his early season form. And a great goal. 
Taylor - 8 - best performance yet. A better CB in a three than fullback. Passed the ball superbly. 

SIJ - 6 - Either sublime or ridiculous. Nearly created a few key openings with his pace but also set them up 3 times with loose passes. 
Diakite - 6 - See above. But his good bits were in transition not attack. Some absolute howler brain farts in possession at times though. 
Mowatt - 6 - Did his job. Looked a bit rusty. Good to have his calm head back. 
Styles - 8 - Ferreted away well and some good set play deliveries including his assist. Great 1v1 defending numerous times too. 

MJ - 7 - Worked hard, good delivery for Nats goal. 
Heggebo - 6 - Grafted, not involved as much as normal. But still linked play well. 
Grant - 8 - MOTM - could have been. 10 so easily. 

Subs:
Molumby - 7 - Made a positive impact as Mowatts understudy. 
Maja - 7 - linked play well 3 times looked more engaged. 
Mepham - not long enough to make an impact. 
Price - 7 - Set up 2 CCCs in his short time on. Ran what seemed like a world record 5k. 

Mason - 8 - reacts well to being ahead where a neutral change is a positive. All credit to him today, and some credit for getting us sorted from set plays. Now let's see something when chasing a result FFS.
Agree pretty much:
Wildsmith 6. Nothing to do.

Campbell 7. Improved as the game went on. Needs to improve his passing. Great athlete.
Phillips 8. Much improved, albeit against a nothing attack. Great goal.
Taylor 7. Found his position at last. Very steady all game.
Styles 8.5. Great tackling, drive, wins an amazing amount of headers. Contender for POTS.

SIJ 6. Good in parts. I keep saying it but so obviously needs to play on the left.
Diakite 7. Steady but would be better played deep in a holding position. 
Mowatt 6. Below par. Possibly carrying a knock or low on fuel?
MJ 7. Tireless effort and grabbed an assist.
Grant  9. Just a clean finish away from a 10.

Heggebo 6. No service and unusually for him couldn't make an impression.

Subs. All 7.
RM. 7. Got it right over the 90. Good subs and slight tactical tweaks.

Couple of thoughts. The 'foul' for their 1st goal was ridiculous BUT Campbell did put the slightest of hands on him. No need.
 The subbing of MJ was necessary to get a grip further upfield, it was a disappointing reaction to what I thought was an obvious move. 
The crowd in general were very supportative though and responded well to the Rs fans who actually turned up vocally for the 1st time in my memory. Their fans can't possibly be happy with such a backwards and sidewards tactic?
With little to no time on the training pitch it was vital to get a positive result and we now have a great chance to break this away run at Swansea.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)