Do you need to have played the game at a decent level to comment about football?
#21
Depends what you call a decent standard.
I’ll go out on a limb and claim that someone who watches week in week out, games from all over the shop will know more than someone who never watches but played for £50 on a Saturday or Sunday.
If you played pro and were coached pro, then it changes, but it still comes down to how much you care about, and study, the game.
Reply
#22
(12-29-2025, 03:28 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Genuinely asking - I've seen this banded around a fair bit, not just here and not just Throstles related. 

For me, obviously having experience and 'inside' knowledge certainly helps, but it doesn't automatically mean your opinion is more valid than someone who hasn't played at a decent level. 

Interesting to see what people think!

Nope. Loads of footballers are professional footballers because they are talented. Most don't know much about the game, they are just told what to do and they use their skill.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#23
Same as any subject. I'm perfectly entitled to give an opinion on nuclear physics, but someone who's done it for years is going to have a bit more insight than me.

It is frustrating when people who haven't played the game to any level argue with people who clearly have and know more about how the game works and how players would have been coached and instructed in specific situations.

Didn't we say after Brexit we'd had enough of experts?
Reply
#24
(12-29-2025, 08:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Same as any subject. I'm perfectly entitled to give an opinion on nuclear physics, but someone who's done it for years is going to have a bit more insight than me.

It is frustrating when people who haven't played the game to any level argue with people who clearly have and know more about how the game works and how players would have been coached and instructed in specific situations.

Didn't we say after Brexit we'd had enough of experts?

Any level? Does district 4 count? 
A physicist is basically a data analyst. This proves the point that a non footballer could understand better than a footballer just by looking at stats and research. 
It’s like saying a junkie knows about drugs.
Reply
#25
(12-29-2025, 08:36 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 08:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Same as any subject. I'm perfectly entitled to give an opinion on nuclear physics, but someone who's done it for years is going to have a bit more insight than me.

It is frustrating when people who haven't played the game to any level argue with people who clearly have and know more about how the game works and how players would have been coached and instructed in specific situations.

Didn't we say after Brexit we'd had enough of experts?

Any level? Does district 4 count? 
A physicist is basically a data analyst. This proves the point that a non footballer could understand better than a footballer just by looking at stats and research. 
It’s like saying a junkie knows about drugs.

Well put, Bob.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#26
(12-29-2025, 08:36 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 08:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Same as any subject. I'm perfectly entitled to give an opinion on nuclear physics, but someone who's done it for years is going to have a bit more insight than me.

It is frustrating when people who haven't played the game to any level argue with people who clearly have and know more about how the game works and how players would have been coached and instructed in specific situations.

Didn't we say after Brexit we'd had enough of experts?

Any level? Does district 4 count? 
A physicist is basically a data analyst. This proves the point that a non footballer could understand better than a footballer just by looking at stats and research. 
It’s like saying a junkie knows about drugs.

Awkward omission of the word decent from my post, say anyone who's played semi-pro (local non-league level), by and large will know more than some bloke down the pub on the ale and shouting at the tele, when dissecting a football match.
Reply
#27
(12-29-2025, 08:41 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 08:36 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 08:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Same as any subject. I'm perfectly entitled to give an opinion on nuclear physics, but someone who's done it for years is going to have a bit more insight than me.

It is frustrating when people who haven't played the game to any level argue with people who clearly have and know more about how the game works and how players would have been coached and instructed in specific situations.

Didn't we say after Brexit we'd had enough of experts?

Any level? Does district 4 count? 
A physicist is basically a data analyst. This proves the point that a non footballer could understand better than a footballer just by looking at stats and research. 
It’s like saying a junkie knows about drugs.

Awkward omission of the word decent from my post, say anyone who's played semi-pro (local non-league level), by and large will know more than some bloke down the pub on the ale and shouting at the tele, when dissecting a football match.

I think it's easier to analyse a lower league game as the tolerances are higher. 

The higher up the pyramid you go, L2 and up really, you get into elite performance and the margins get so fine it sometimes difficult to pick the real meat off the bones tactically as the cliche "we ay werking ard enough" or "we need to play on the front foot!" lose their effectiveness and relevance.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#28
(12-29-2025, 08:41 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 08:36 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 08:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Same as any subject. I'm perfectly entitled to give an opinion on nuclear physics, but someone who's done it for years is going to have a bit more insight than me.

It is frustrating when people who haven't played the game to any level argue with people who clearly have and know more about how the game works and how players would have been coached and instructed in specific situations.

Didn't we say after Brexit we'd had enough of experts?

Any level? Does district 4 count? 
A physicist is basically a data analyst. This proves the point that a non footballer could understand better than a footballer just by looking at stats and research. 
It’s like saying a junkie knows about drugs.

Awkward omission of the word decent from my post, say anyone who's played semi-pro (local non-league level), by and large will know more than some bloke down the pub on the ale and shouting at the tele, when dissecting a football match.
I didn’t omit it, it’s not there.
What about the bloke who doesn’t drink, or shout, but watches 10 games a week, despite never having kicked a ball. 
I hate to go there but needs saying, some people cannot, physically, play football.
Reply
#29
(12-29-2025, 08:45 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 08:41 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 08:36 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 08:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Same as any subject. I'm perfectly entitled to give an opinion on nuclear physics, but someone who's done it for years is going to have a bit more insight than me.

It is frustrating when people who haven't played the game to any level argue with people who clearly have and know more about how the game works and how players would have been coached and instructed in specific situations.

Didn't we say after Brexit we'd had enough of experts?

Any level? Does district 4 count? 
A physicist is basically a data analyst. This proves the point that a non footballer could understand better than a footballer just by looking at stats and research. 
It’s like saying a junkie knows about drugs.

Awkward omission of the word decent from my post, say anyone who's played semi-pro (local non-league level), by and large will know more than some bloke down the pub on the ale and shouting at the tele, when dissecting a football match.
I didn’t omit it, it’s not there.
What about the bloke who doesn’t drink, or shout, but watches 10 games a week, despite never having kicked a ball. 
I hate to go there but needs saying, some people cannot, physically, play football.

No, I did the omitting. if you're having a tactical discussion about a football match, it's not outrageous to suggest the person who's been inside functioning dressing rooms, with qualified coaches playing against decent level opposition will know more than someone who watches lots of YouTube. It's not always the way, but it is OK to suggest some opinions are more valid than others. I'm pretty sure on here we all have posters who's opinions we value more than others when reading posts?

The line about good managers often not being great pros is often trotted out, but it's not like these coaches didn't have roles in football prior to becoming head coaches.
Reply
#30
(12-29-2025, 08:50 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 08:45 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 08:41 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 08:36 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-29-2025, 08:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Same as any subject. I'm perfectly entitled to give an opinion on nuclear physics, but someone who's done it for years is going to have a bit more insight than me.

It is frustrating when people who haven't played the game to any level argue with people who clearly have and know more about how the game works and how players would have been coached and instructed in specific situations.

Didn't we say after Brexit we'd had enough of experts?

Any level? Does district 4 count? 
A physicist is basically a data analyst. This proves the point that a non footballer could understand better than a footballer just by looking at stats and research. 
It’s like saying a junkie knows about drugs.

Awkward omission of the word decent from my post, say anyone who's played semi-pro (local non-league level), by and large will know more than some bloke down the pub on the ale and shouting at the tele, when dissecting a football match.
I didn’t omit it, it’s not there.
What about the bloke who doesn’t drink, or shout, but watches 10 games a week, despite never having kicked a ball. 
I hate to go there but needs saying, some people cannot, physically, play football.

No, I did the omitting. if you're having a tactical discussion about a football match, it's not outrageous to suggest the person who's been inside functioning dressing rooms, with qualified coaches playing against decent level opposition will know more than someone who watches lots of YouTube. It's not always the way, but it is OK to suggest some opinions are more valid than others. I'm pretty sure on here we all have posters who's opinions we value more than others when reading posts?

The line about good managers often not being great pros is often trotted out, but it's not like these coaches didn't have roles in football prior to becoming head coaches.
We’ll have to agree to disagree. I prefer to judge the opinion rather than the footballing history.
You are excluding an awful lot of people with your thought process, and creating an elitist gang.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)